Enhancing prime editing efficiency by modified pegRNA with RNA G-quadruplexes

Xiangyang Li, Xin Wang, Wenjun Sun, Shisheng Huang, Mingtian Zhong, Yuan Yao, Quanjiang Ji, Xingxu HuangJournal of Molecular Cell Biology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel modification to prime editing guide RNAs (pegRNAs) by incorporating G-quadruplex structures at their 3' end. This modification significantly enhances prime editing efficiency at endogenous target sites, offering a more robust and versatile tool for precise genome editing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prime editing (PE) is a powerful genome editing technology that allows for precise base substitutions, insertions, and deletions without requiring double-strand breaks or donor DNA. However, its efficiency can be insufficient for broad applications. The efficiency of PE is partly dependent on the stability of the prime editing guide RNA (pegRNA), specifically its 3' non-structured terminal, which is prone to degradation. Previous work has shown that introducing structured RNA motifs to the 3' end of single-guide RNAs (sgRNAs) can improve CRISPR-Cas9 stability and cleavage efficiency. This paper investigates whether similar structured motifs, specifically G-quadruplexes, can enhance the stability and efficiency of pegRNAs for prime editing.

Methods

The researchers designed and tested three types of modifications at the 3' end of pegRNAs:

  1. Natural G-quadruplex: A noncanonical secondary structure formed by G-rich sequences, stabilized by cations.
  2. Non-structured modification: A mutant G-quadruplex sequence designed to block its function and create a non-structured 3' extension for protection.
  3. Hairpin-stem modification: A common secondary RNA structure consisting of a double-stranded RNA stem.

They constructed paired sgRNA, pegRNA, and modified pegRNA plasmids. Prime editing was performed in HEK293T cells, followed by sorting of GFP-mCherry double-positive cells to analyze editing efficiency. They tested base conversions at seven endogenous target sites. Further experiments involved testing other G-quadruplexes (from MT3, TERRA, and NRAS genes), evaluating editing in different cell lines (HeLa and U2OS), and assessing precise indel generation. Off-target effects were also analyzed.

Datasets

The study utilized endogenous target sites in HEK293T, HeLa, and U2OS cell lines for evaluation. Specific target sites included RNF2, RUNX1, LSP1, SEC61B, UBE3A, FANCF, and SHANK3. Targeted amplicon sequencing data was deposited in NCBI under Bio-Project number SUB10748207.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • G-quadruplexes are potent stabilizers for pegRNAs: The G-quadruplex structure, particularly from the human telomerase RNA (hTR), significantly improved prime editing efficiency, suggesting its ability to protect the pegRNA from degradation.
  • Structure matters, not just length: A non-structured modification using a mutated G-quadruplex sequence did not enhance efficiency, highlighting that the specific secondary structure of the 3' extension is critical for improvement.
  • Broad applicability across cell types: The G-quadruplex modification (G-PE) demonstrated enhanced editing efficiency in multiple cell lines (HEK293T, HeLa, U2OS), indicating its general utility.
  • Enhances both base editing and indel generation: The modified pegRNAs not only improved base conversion efficiency but also increased the efficiency of precise insertions and deletions.
  • High fidelity maintained: Despite increased editing efficiency, the G-quadruplex modification did not significantly increase unintended edits or off-target effects, preserving the high fidelity of prime editing.

Key Results

  • G-quadruplex modification (specifically hTR G-quadruplex) increased editing efficiency by >80% at endogenous target sites in HEK293T cells, compared to ~50% for hairpin-stem modification.
  • G-PE showed increased editing efficiency at 6 out of 7 tested endogenous sites (85.7%) in HEK293T cells.
  • In HeLa and U2OS cells, G-PE induced 1.7- and 1.9-fold higher editing efficiency than the original PE at 4 out of 7 and 3 out of 7 target sites, respectively.
  • G-PE induced precise indel editing with increased efficiency at 3 out of 4 tested sites.
  • Off-target analysis showed that G-PE maintained low off-target editing frequencies (<0.1%) and no statistical difference compared to the original PE.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that further extensive development is required. While G-quadruplex modification shows promise, the study also notes that the TERRA G-quadruplex modification performed inconsistently. The paper also references a recent study (Nelson et al., 2022) that independently confirmed the benefits of incorporating various structured RNA motifs, including G-quadruplexes, to pegRNAs, reinforcing the findings but also suggesting that the field is rapidly evolving. Future work could explore optimizing G-quadruplex sequences and their placement, as well as investigating their efficacy in a wider range of cell types and in vivo applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2022enhancing,
  author = {Xiangyang Li and Xin Wang and Wenjun Sun and Shisheng Huang and Mingtian Zhong and Yuan Yao and Quanjiang Ji and Xingxu Huang},
  title = {{Enhancing prime editing efficiency by modified pegRNA with RNA G-quadruplexes}},
  journal = {Journal of Molecular Cell Biology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/jmcb/mjac022},
}
Figure