Enhancing heat transfer in the core flow by using porous medium insert in a tube

Zhangfeng Huang, Akira Nakayama, Kun Yang, Chen Yang, Wenyu LiuInternational Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for enhancing heat transfer in tubes by inserting porous media into the core flow. By making the core flow temperature more uniform, they achieve significant heat transfer augmentation, particularly in laminar flow, with a manageable increase in pressure drop. This "core flow enhancement" offers a promising alternative to traditional boundary-focused methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional heat transfer enhancement techniques primarily focus on modifying the tube wall or disrupting the boundary layer near the wall. While effective, these methods often lead to a substantial increase in flow resistance, requiring more pumping power. This paper addresses the limitation of existing methods by proposing a new concept: enhancing heat transfer in the core flow of a tube. The authors argue that by making the temperature more uniform in the core, a steeper temperature gradient can be established near the wall, leading to improved heat transfer without excessively increasing flow resistance. They aim to investigate the effectiveness and trade-offs of this approach using porous medium inserts.

Methods

The study employs a dual approach: experimental investigation and numerical simulation.

  • Experimental Setup: A test rig was built using a stainless steel tube with a constant and uniform heat flux condition. Porous medium inserts, made from copper screens, were placed in the core of the tube. The experiments covered a range of Reynolds numbers from laminar to turbulent flow. Key parameters measured included air flow rate, temperature at various points, pressure drop, and heat input.
  • Numerical Simulation: A two-dimensional, axisymmetric model was developed to simulate the flow and heat transfer within the tube with porous inserts. The simulation used the k-ε turbulence model and incorporated the Darcian equation with the Forcheimer revision to account for the porous medium's resistance. The model was validated against experimental data and empirical correlations.
  • Data Processing: Standard heat transfer and fluid dynamics parameters like Nusselt number, friction factor, and performance evaluation criteria (PEC) were calculated. The concept of "field synergy" was also applied to analyze the interaction between velocity and temperature gradients.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from the custom-built rig and numerical simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Core Flow Enhancement is Viable: The central idea that enhancing heat transfer in the core flow can lead to significant overall augmentation is validated. This is achieved by creating a more uniform temperature distribution in the core, which in turn sharpens the thermal boundary layer at the wall.
  • Porous Media as Core Inserts: Porous media are identified as suitable inserts for core flow enhancement due to their inherent ability to promote temperature uniformity.
  • Laminar vs. Turbulent Flow Performance: The porous inserts show much greater heat transfer enhancement in laminar flow compared to turbulent flow. This is attributed to the already more uniform temperature and higher velocity in turbulent flow, which diminish the impact of the inserts.
  • Porosity Trade-off: Higher porosity generally leads to better heat transfer but also increases flow resistance. The optimal porosity depends on the flow regime and desired performance.
  • Field Synergy Principle: The study leverages the field synergy principle, showing that reducing the "synergy angle" between velocity and temperature gradients (achieved by the porous inserts) directly correlates with enhanced heat transfer.
  • Porous Radius Ratio (Rrad) Importance: A larger Rrad (closer to the tube wall) leads to a more uniform core temperature and a thinner thermal boundary layer, thus improving heat transfer. However, excessively large Rrad can disproportionately increase flow resistance.

Key Results

  • Heat Transfer Augmentation: The porous inserts achieved heat transfer rates 1.6-5.5 times higher than a smooth tube in laminar, transitional, and turbulent flow regimes.
  • Pressure Drop Increase: While heat transfer was enhanced, the flow resistance also increased, though generally to a lesser extent than the heat transfer gain, especially in laminar flow.
  • Performance Evaluation Criteria (PEC): In laminar flow, PEC values were consistently greater than 1, indicating a net benefit. However, in turbulent flow, PEC values were often less than 1, suggesting that the increased flow resistance outweighed the heat transfer gains.
  • Numerical vs. Experimental Agreement: The numerical simulations showed good agreement with experimental results, with most Nu errors below 20% and friction factor errors below 10%. Discrepancies were attributed to factors like the assumption of isotropic porous media in simulations and potential conductive heat transfer in experiments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Turbulent Flow Performance: The integrated performance (PEC) in turbulent flow was less favorable than in laminar flow. The authors suggest that further development of inserts for enhancing heat transfer in tube flow with better integrated performance at high flow rates is needed.
  • Anisotropic Porous Media: The numerical model assumed homogeneous and isotropic porous media, while the experimental inserts were anisotropic. This difference contributed to discrepancies between numerical and experimental results.
  • Optimal Insert Design: While the study explored porosity and radius ratio, further optimization of porous insert design (e.g., shape, internal structure) for specific applications and flow regimes is implied.
  • Material Properties: The accuracy of numerical predictions relies on accurate physical parameters of the porous material, which can be challenging to obtain experimentally.

The study concludes that enhancing heat transfer in the core flow using porous inserts is an efficacious method, particularly for laminar flow, and offers a promising avenue for future heat exchanger designs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{huang2009enhancing,
  author = {Zhangfeng Huang and Akira Nakayama and Kun Yang and Chen Yang and Wenyu Liu},
  title = {{Enhancing heat transfer in the core flow by using porous medium insert in a tube}},
  journal = {International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2009.10.038},
}
Figure