Enhancing Environmental Awareness for Sustainable Retail: Analysis of the Buy-Online-and-Return-in-Store Policy Adoption Using Theory of Planned Behavior

Xinyu Yao, Yanfeng Liu, Guanqiu QiJ. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how consumers decide to use "Buy-Online-and-Return-in-Store" (BORS) policies, a key strategy for sustainable retail. It finds that while attitudes, social norms, and perceived ease of use are crucial, environmental awareness plays a significant role, both directly and by boosting perceived ease of use, ultimately encouraging more sustainable consumption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The retail industry is increasingly adopting "omni-channel" strategies, integrating online and offline experiences. A key component is the Buy-Online-and-Return-in-Store (BORS) policy, which offers convenience for consumers and potential environmental benefits by reducing reverse logistics. However, despite these advantages, understanding consumer adoption of BORS, especially concerning its environmental implications, remains underexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how consumers' environmental awareness and understanding of consequences influence their intention to use BORS, and how this, in turn, promotes sustainable consumption.

Methods

The study employs the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) as its theoretical framework, extending it with environmental awareness and awareness of consequences. A structural equation modeling (SEM) approach was used to analyze survey data from 405 participants. This allowed the researchers to test the direct and indirect relationships between TPB constructs, environmental factors, intention to use BORS, and sustainable consumption behavior. A multi-group analysis was also conducted to compare the influence of online versus offline return channels.

Datasets

The study utilized a survey dataset collected from 405 participants in China. The data was gathered through the Chinese third-party online platform "Wenjuanxing" between December 14, 2023, and January 14, 2024. The questionnaire included demographic information, questions about BORS usage intentions, and return preferences.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental Awareness is a Double-Edged Sword: It directly influences the intention to use BORS and, perhaps more importantly, significantly boosts the perceived ease of using the policy. This suggests that making consumers feel like BORS is easy is key, and environmental awareness helps achieve that.
  • Consequence Awareness Works Indirectly: While consumers' awareness of the environmental consequences of their actions doesn't directly drive them to use BORS, it strongly shapes their positive attitudes towards it. This highlights the importance of education and communication about the environmental benefits.
  • Offline Returns Matter for Environmentalists: Consumers who prefer returning items to physical stores (offline returns) show a stronger influence from environmental awareness compared to those who primarily use online returns. This suggests BORS is particularly appealing to the environmentally conscious.
  • BORS as a Gateway to Sustainable Behavior: The study confirms that a strong intention to use BORS policies directly leads to more sustainable consumption behaviors. This positions BORS not just as a convenience feature but as a tool for promoting broader environmental responsibility.

Key Results

  • TPB Core Variables are Key: Attitudes (0.213), subjective norms (0.217), and perceived behavioral control (0.137*) all positively and significantly influenced the intention to use the BORS policy.
  • Environmental Awareness Impact: Environmental awareness directly influenced the intention to use BORS (0.368) and significantly increased perceived behavioral control (0.741**).
  • Consequence Awareness Role: Awareness of consequences did not directly impact the intention to use BORS (0.035ns) but significantly influenced attitudes (0.650***), which in turn indirectly affected intention.
  • BORS Drives Sustainable Consumption: The intention to use BORS policy positively influenced sustainable consumption behavior (0.646***).
  • Mediation Effect: Attitude fully mediated the relationship between awareness of consequences and the intention to use BORS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Specificity: The study was conducted in China, where BORS policies are relatively new. Future research should explore these dynamics in other countries to verify findings.
  • Secondary Consumption: The BORS policy might encourage consumers to engage in secondary consumption (buying more because returns are easy), which warrants further investigation.
  • Broader Factors: Future studies could incorporate additional factors influencing consumer behavior, such as altruism and egoistic motivations, for a more comprehensive understanding.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yao2024enhancing,
  author = {Xinyu Yao and Yanfeng Liu and Guanqiu Qi},
  title = {{Enhancing Environmental Awareness for Sustainable Retail: Analysis of the Buy-Online-and-Return-in-Store Policy Adoption Using Theory of Planned Behavior}},
  journal = {J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer19040129},
}
Figure