Enhancement of prime editing via xrRNA motif-joined pegRNA

Guiquan Zhang, Yao Liu, Shisheng Huang, Shiyuan Qu, Daolin Cheng, Yuan Yao, Quanjiang Ji, Xiaolong Wang, Xingxu Huang, Jianghuai LiuNature Communications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new prime editing system called "xrPE" by adding a viral RNA motif (xrRNA) to the guide RNA. This modification significantly boosts editing efficiency for various genetic changes, including base conversions, small deletions, and insertions, while maintaining high accuracy and low off-target effects. xrPE offers a more robust and adaptable tool for precise genome editing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prime editing (PE) is a powerful genome editing technology that allows for precise genetic modifications without causing double-strand breaks, a major advantage over traditional CRISPR-Cas9. However, a significant hurdle limiting its widespread application has been its often suboptimal editing efficiency. This means that PE doesn't always work as effectively as desired, especially at certain genomic locations. The researchers in this paper aimed to overcome this limitation by improving the stability and activity of the prime editing guide RNA (pegRNA), which is a key component of the PE system.

Methods

The core innovation of this study is the development of the "xrPE" platform. This involves appending a viral exoribonuclease-resistant RNA motif (xrRNA) to the 3' end of the prime editing guide RNA (pegRNA). xrRNAs are naturally occurring RNA structures found in viruses that protect viral RNA from degradation by cellular enzymes. The researchers hypothesized that adding this motif would make the pegRNA more resistant to degradation within the cell, thereby increasing its stability and ultimately enhancing prime editing efficiency.

They tested several xrRNA motifs from different flaviviruses (Murray Valley encephalitis, West Nile virus, Zika, Dengue, and Yellow Fever). The modified pegRNAs, termed "xr-pegRNAs," were then used in conjunction with prime editors (PE2 and PE3 systems) to perform various genetic edits, including base conversions, small deletions, and small insertions. The performance of xrPE was evaluated using fluorescent reporter systems and deep sequencing to quantify editing efficiency and accuracy (edit:indel ratios). They also compared xrPE to the canonical PE3 system and a recently developed enhanced prime editing system (epegRNA). Mechanistic studies were conducted to investigate the stability of xr-pegRNAs and their impact on editing intermediates.

Datasets

The study utilized established human cell lines (HEK293T, HeLa) and a mouse cell line (N2a) for their experiments. They targeted multiple endogenous human gene loci for various types of edits. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the performance was evaluated on endogenous genomic sites.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • xrRNA as a pegRNA stabilizer: The addition of xrRNA motifs to the 3' end of pegRNAs significantly enhances their resistance to degradation by cellular exonucleases. This is a direct translation of a viral defense mechanism into a gene editing tool.
  • Improved editing efficiency across multiple edit types: xrPE demonstrates substantial improvements in editing efficiency for base conversions, small deletions, and small insertions, making it a more versatile tool.
  • Comparable accuracy to existing methods: Despite the increased efficiency, xrPE maintains comparable edit:indel ratios and minimal off-target editing to the canonical PE3 system, ensuring high precision.
  • Equivalent performance to cutting-edge systems: xrPE performs comparably to the recently developed epegRNA system, suggesting that stabilizing the pegRNA is a key strategy for enhancing prime editing.
  • Mechanistic basis for improvement: The enhanced stability of xr-pegRNAs appears to shift the balance towards productive reverse transcription of the intended edit, reducing the formation of unedited intermediates.

Key Results

  • Base Conversions: xrPE showed an average enhancement of up to 3.1-fold in base conversion efficiency across multiple cell types compared to canonical PE3.
  • Small Deletions: xrPE achieved an average enhancement of up to 4.5-fold for small deletions.
  • Small Insertions: xrPE demonstrated an average enhancement of up to 2.5-fold for small insertions.
  • Edit:Indel Ratios: xrPE exhibited comparable edit:indel ratios to canonical PE3, indicating maintained editing accuracy.
  • Off-Target Editing: xrPE showed similarly minimal off-target editing as canonical PE3.
  • Comparison to epegRNA: xrPE showed largely equivalent editing performances to the epegRNA-based PE system.
  • Viral Motif Performance: The Zika virus-derived xrRNA motif consistently showed the best enhancement effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • RNA Synthesis Challenges: The increased size of xr-pegRNAs might pose challenges for chemical synthesis, particularly for applications like mRNA/protein-based prime editing. However, the authors suggest that in vitro transcription of larger xr-pegRNAs could be a viable alternative.
  • Linker Exploration: While the direct joining of xrRNA to pegRNA without a linker proved effective, the authors acknowledge that further exploration of linker sequences might be beneficial for optimizing performance in specific contexts, although their current findings suggest linkers are not strictly necessary for xrPE.
  • Mechanistic Understanding of Cellular Responses: The paper highlights that undesired indels are often coupled with the generation of editing intermediates. Further research into cellular responses downstream of these intermediates could lead to even more advanced PE methods.
  • Broad Applicability: The authors suggest that future work could focus on identifying additional intrinsically stable RNA motifs (natural or engineered) that could further enhance pegRNA performance and broaden the applicability of PE.

Summary updated

Abstract

The prime editors (PEs) have shown great promise for precise genome modification. However, their suboptimal efficiencies present a significant technical challenge. Here, by appending a viral exoribonuclease-resistant RNA motif (xrRNA) to the 3'-extended portion of pegRNAs for their increased resistance against degradation, we develop an upgraded PE platform (xrPE) with substantially enhanced editing efficiencies in multiple cell lines. A pan-target average enhancement of up to 3.1-, 4.5- and 2.5-fold in given cell types is observed for base conversions, small deletions, and small insertions, respectively. Additionally, xrPE exhibits comparable edit:indel ratios and similarly minimal off-target editing as the canonical PE3. Of note, parallel comparison of xrPE to the most recently developed epegRNA-based PE system shows their largely equivalent editing performances. Our study establishes a highly adaptable platform of improved PE that shall have broad implications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022enhancement,
  author = {Guiquan Zhang and Yao Liu and Shisheng Huang and Shiyuan Qu and Daolin Cheng and Yuan Yao and Quanjiang Ji and Xiaolong Wang and Xingxu Huang and Jianghuai Liu},
  title = {{Enhancement of prime editing via xrRNA motif-joined pegRNA}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-29507-x},
}
Figure