Enhanced proton acceleration in an applied longitudinal magnetic field

Alexey Arefiev, T. Toncian, G. FikselNew Journal of Physics 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated that applying a strong, kT-level magnetic field during laser-driven proton acceleration can significantly enhance proton energies and beam collimation. This is achieved by suppressing the sideways movement of hot electrons, leading to a more efficient acceleration process and a substantial increase in the conversion of laser energy into energetic protons.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Laser-driven ion acceleration, particularly the Target Normal Sheath Acceleration (TNSA) mechanism, offers a compact way to generate high-energy particle beams. However, several challenges limit its practical applications: increasing proton energies, controlling beam divergence, reducing energy bandwidth, and improving the efficiency of converting laser energy into proton energy. While TNSA is effective, the energetic electrons responsible for generating the accelerating electric fields tend to spread out, limiting the overall acceleration. This paper investigates a novel approach to overcome these limitations by applying an external magnetic field.

Methods

The study employs two-dimensional (2D) particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations using the EPOCH code. PIC simulations are a standard computational technique for modeling plasma behavior by tracking the motion of individual charged particles and their interactions through electromagnetic fields. The researchers simulated the interaction of a laser pulse with a solid-density target under different conditions: with and without an externally applied longitudinal magnetic field of varying strengths (0 T, 150 T, and 1.5 kT). They focused on the 1.5 kT case, as it showed significant effects. The simulations accounted for a pre-pulse to model initial target ionization and pre-expansion, and the laser parameters were set to a peak intensity of 2.2 x 10¹⁹ W/cm².

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated by the PIC code.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Magnetic field as a "control knob": The study highlights that a strong longitudinal magnetic field acts as a powerful tool to "tune" the proton acceleration process.
  • Electron transport suppression is key: The primary mechanism for enhanced proton acceleration is not direct interaction with the magnetic field, but rather its ability to significantly inhibit the transverse (sideways) motion of hot electrons within the target.
  • Efficient energy transfer: By confining hot electrons, the magnetic field allows them to sustain a stronger and more localized accelerating electric field at the rear of the target, leading to more efficient energy transfer to protons.
  • Focusing sheath field: The magnetic field induces a focusing effect on the sheath electric field, which in turn directs and collimates the accelerated protons.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Proton Energies: A 1.5 kT magnetic field led to a significant enhancement in the proton energy spectrum. The number of protons with energies above 1 MeV increased by a factor of 2.25, and those above 10 MeV increased by a factor of 2.83. The cutoff proton energy also increased by approximately 50%.
  • Improved Collimation: The proton beam generated with the magnetic field was significantly better collimated, with a sharp peak in the distribution at zero angle relative to the laser propagation axis for energetic protons.
  • Increased Laser-to-Proton Energy Conversion: The efficiency of converting laser energy into multi-MeV protons was enhanced by a factor of approximately 2.4 to 3.25.
  • Weak impact on electron heating: The applied magnetic field had a minimal effect on the initial heating of hot electrons by the laser itself, indicating that the benefits arise from the subsequent electron dynamics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation dimensionality: The study was conducted using 2D simulations. While providing valuable insights, 3D simulations would be necessary to fully capture all aspects of the plasma dynamics and confirm these findings in a more realistic scenario.
  • Magnetic field strength feasibility: The paper notes that kT-level magnetic fields are becoming feasible with advancements in laser-driven coils. However, achieving and precisely controlling such strong fields in experiments remains a significant technological challenge.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that further investigations into the role of magnetic fields in laser-plasma interactions, particularly in the context of proton acceleration, are warranted. Exploring different target geometries and laser parameters in conjunction with magnetic fields could lead to even greater improvements. The potential for these enhanced proton beams in applications like fast ignition fusion and medical isotope production is a strong motivation for continued research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations, we examine how an externally applied strong magnetic field impacts proton acceleration in laser-irradiated solid-density targets. We find that a kT-level external magnetic field can sufficiently inhibit transverse transport of hot electrons in a flat laser-irradiated target. While the electron heating by the laser remains mostly unaffected, the reduced electron transport during proton acceleration leads to an enhancement of maximum proton energies and the overall number of energetic protons. The resulting proton beam is much better collimated compared to a beam generated without applying a kT-level magnetic field. A factor of three enhancement of the laser energy conversion efficiency into multi-MeV protons is another effect of the magnetic field. The required kT-level magnetic fields are becoming feasible due to a significant progress that has been made in generating magnetic fields with laser-driven coils using ns-long laser pulses. The possibility of improving characteristics of laser-driven proton beams using such fields is a strong motivation for further development of laser-driven magnetic field capabilities.
BibTeX
@article{arefiev2016enhanced,
  author = {Alexey Arefiev and T. Toncian and G. Fiksel},
  title = {{Enhanced proton acceleration in an applied longitudinal magnetic field}},
  journal = {New Journal of Physics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1088/1367-2630/18/10/105011},
}
Figure