Enhanced marine biological carbon pump as a trigger for Early Mississippian marine anoxia and climatic cooling

Feifei Zhang, Maya Elrick, Alexandre Pohl, Keyi Cheng, Peter W. Crockford, Mojtaba Fakhraee, Yibo Lin, Mengchun Cao, Guang‐Yi Wei, Na Li, Shuzhong Shen, Peter K. Swart2023 · DOI

Introduction

The Early Mississippian (approximately 350 million years ago) represents a pivotal interval in Earth's history, characterized by the mid-Tournaisian carbon isotope excursion (TICE). This event marks one of the most significant disruptions to the global carbon cycle during the late Paleozoic, coinciding with a dramatic climatic transition from a "greenhouse" state to an "icehouse" state. While researchers have long hypothesized that this shift was driven by the massive burial of organic carbon in the oceans, direct evidence for the underlying biological mechanisms has remained elusive. This study provides the first direct geochemical evidence that an enhanced marine biological carbon pump was the primary driver for both global cooling and widespread ocean oxygen depletion during this period.

The Role of the Biological Carbon Pump

The "biological carbon pump" is a critical planetary mechanism wherein marine organisms fix atmospheric $CO_2$ through photosynthesis in the surface ocean. Upon death, their carbon-rich remains sink into the deep ocean, where they are either sequestered in sediments or decomposed. An intensification of this pump effectively "scrubs" $CO_2$ from the atmosphere.

During the TICE, it is suspected that a surge in marine productivity accelerated this pump. However, identifying this surge requires proxies that can distinguish between simple carbon burial and active biological export. This research addresses the gap by utilizing barium isotopes to track "export productivity"—the specific fraction of organic matter that successfully exits the surface ocean.

Methodology: Barium Isotopes and Earth System Modeling

To investigate these dynamics, the research team employed a multi-disciplinary approach:

  1. Barium Isotope Analysis ($\delta^{138}Ba$): In marine limestones, barium isotopes serve as a sensitive proxy for biological productivity. As organic matter sinks and decays, it influences the isotopic composition of barium in the water column, which is then preserved in the geological record.
  2. Comparative Stratigraphy: The team analyzed two distinct geological sections in the United States: the Pahranaghat Range (PR) and the Sacagawea Peak (SP). Separated by approximately 1,200 km, these sites allow researchers to differentiate between localized environmental fluctuations and broader regional or global signals.
  3. Earth System Modeling (cGENIE): The researchers utilized the cGENIE model to simulate various atmospheric $CO_2$ levels and nutrient concentrations (specifically phosphates, $[PO_4]$). This modeling was essential to validate whether the observed isotopic shifts could realistically be explained by changes in the biological pump.

Evidence of a Productivity Surge

The geochemical data revealed a massive shift in the Pahranaghat Range (PR) section, with $\delta^{138}Ba$ values ranging from −0.15‰ to 1.12‰. This represents the largest positive $\delta^{138}Ba$ excursion ever recorded in the geological record, providing a "smoking gun" for an unprecedented surge in marine productivity.

In contrast, the Sacagawea Peak (SP) section showed a more modest range of −0.20‰ to 0.26‰. This discrepancy suggests significant nutrient heterogeneity across the Early Mississippian oceans. The PR site likely functioned as a high-nutrient "hotspot," where phosphate availability fueled extreme biological activity, while other regions experienced more moderate productivity increases.

Climatic and Oceanographic Consequences

The intensification of the biological pump had two profound effects on the Earth system:

  • Global Cooling: By drawing down atmospheric $CO_2$, the enhanced pump triggered a transition to an icehouse climate. The study found that a scenario moving from high atmospheric $CO_2$ (8PAL) to significantly lower levels (2PAL) best aligns with the observed $\delta^{138}Ba$ data and existing oxygen isotope ($\delta^{18}O$) temperature proxies.
  • Marine Anoxia: The massive influx of sinking organic matter required vast amounts of oxygen for decomposition. This process depleted oxygen levels in the subsurface ocean, leading to widespread anoxia. This finding is supported by uranium isotope ($\delta^{238}U$) records, which indicate a global expansion of oxygen-depleted "dead zones" during the TICE.

Conclusion

This research provides a cohesive link between biological activity, carbon sequestration, and climate change during the Early Mississippian. The data suggest that the biological carbon pump was not merely a participant in the TICE but the primary engine driving the Earth into an icehouse state.

While the findings from the North American sections are robust, future research should expand barium isotope analysis to other paleocontinents to confirm the global extent of this productivity spike. Furthermore, investigating the triggers for the initial nutrient surge—such as accelerated continental weathering or shifts in ocean circulation—will be vital to understanding the full lifecycle of this ancient climatic transition.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023enhanced,
  author = {Feifei Zhang and Maya Elrick and Alexandre Pohl and Keyi Cheng and Peter W. Crockford and Mojtaba Fakhraee and Yibo Lin and Mengchun Cao and Guang‐Yi Wei and Na Li and Shuzhong Shen and Peter K. Swart},
  title = {{Enhanced marine biological carbon pump as a trigger for Early Mississippian marine anoxia and climatic cooling}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.7185/gold2023.17195},
}
Figure