Engineering Design of an Active-Passive Combined Thermal Control Technology for an Aerial Optoelectronic Platform

Zhifeng Cheng, Lu Sun, Fuhe Liu, Xiaofeng Liu, Lei Li, Quanchao Li, Richa HuSensors 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an innovative active-passive combined thermal control system for aerial optoelectronic platforms, crucial for maintaining imaging performance in extreme low-temperature environments. By integrating passive insulation with targeted active heating, the system effectively keeps the primary mirror within operational temperature ranges and significantly reduces temperature gradients, ensuring high-quality imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aerial optoelectronic platforms, vital for applications like surveying and military reconnaissance, face a significant challenge: the extreme temperature fluctuations encountered during flight. Unlike ground-based systems, these platforms operate in environments where temperatures can plummet to -55°C. Such low temperatures can severely degrade the performance of sensitive optical components, leading to issues like image distortion and reduced resolution. While thermal control for space-based systems is relatively mature, research specifically addressing the unique challenges of aerial platforms, especially for complex optoelectronic systems with multiple mirrors, has been limited. This paper tackles the problem of ensuring precise thermal control for an aerial optoelectronic platform, focusing on maintaining both the overall temperature of critical components like the primary mirror and minimizing temperature gradients between optical elements to preserve imaging quality.

Methods

The researchers developed an active-passive combined thermal control technology.

  • Passive Measures: This involved applying a polyurethane foam insulation layer to the inner surface of the spherical shell and the back surface of the secondary mirror heating cover. This layer, combined with a double-sided aluminized polyester film, aims to minimize heat loss to the external environment. Key components were also blackened (using black paint or anodizing) to achieve an emissivity of at least 0.8, ensuring uniform temperature distribution.
  • Active Measures: The core of the active control is a switch-type temperature control strategy using DS18B20 digital sensors and 125µm polyimide film electric heating pieces.
  • Heating Covers: These are strategically placed on the shell, secondary mirror, and primary mirror. The shell heating cover is divided into 18 areas, the secondary mirror heating cover has one area, and the primary mirror heating cover has three areas.
  • Control Strategy: The target temperature for the secondary mirror heating cover is set to the current average temperature of the primary mirror control points to minimize the gradient between them. For other areas, the target temperature is the primary mirror's average temperature, but it's capped between -10°C and +30°C. This ensures a comfortable working environment for all loads.
  • Heating Logic: Heating is activated when the measured temperature drops below the target temperature by 0.1°C and deactivated when it exceeds it by 0.1°C, with a control period of no more than 1 second.
  • Thermal Analysis: A finite element model of the aerial optoelectronic platform was created using NX SST module for thermal analysis. This model incorporated detailed structural components, surface treatments, and their thermal properties.
  • Experimental Verification: The proposed thermal control technology was tested under simulated low-temperature conditions (-55°C) with and without active control.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on thermal analysis simulations and experimental tests conducted on a prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Active-Passive Synergy is Crucial: The paper strongly suggests that a combination of passive insulation and active heating is essential for achieving the required thermal stability in extreme environments, rather than relying on either alone.
  • Temperature Gradient is More Critical than Level: The research highlights that temperature gradients between optical elements (primary and secondary mirrors) have a more significant impact on imaging quality (wave phase difference) than the absolute temperature level of individual components. This informed the control strategy for the secondary mirror.
  • Targeted Heating for Primary/Secondary Mirrors: The design emphasizes localized heating for the primary and secondary mirrors, recognizing their critical role in imaging and the need to manage their inter-mirror temperature gradient.
  • Simulation vs. Reality Gap: While simulations provide valuable insights into thermal trends, the study acknowledges a noticeable gap between simulation results and experimental data, attributing it to inconsistencies in input conditions and the limitations of simulating complex active control strategies. This underscores the importance of experimental validation.

Key Results

  • Improved Primary Mirror Temperature: Without active control, the primary mirror temperature dropped below -30°C. With the active-passive system, it was maintained at approximately 20°C under -55°C ambient conditions, meeting the -20°C to +50°C requirement.
  • Reduced Temperature Gradient: The temperature gradient between the primary and secondary mirrors was reduced to less than 5°C with active control, meeting the critical imaging quality requirement. Without active control, this gradient was initially higher and still above the required threshold.
  • Enhanced Imaging Quality: Visual comparison of target images showed significantly improved imaging quality when the active thermal control was engaged, demonstrating the system's effectiveness.
  • Simulation Accuracy: The simulation results showed a primary mirror temperature of -12.4°C and a gradient of 1.8°C with active control. While directionally correct, these values differed from the test results (20°C and <5°C respectively), highlighting the need for further simulation refinement.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation Accuracy: The authors acknowledge a gap between simulation and test results, suggesting that the simulation software's ability to accurately model the active control strategy needs improvement. Future work should focus on enhancing simulation accuracy.
  • Active Control Algorithm: The paper states that the active thermal control algorithm itself needs further study to achieve more precise thermal control. This is a key area for future research.
  • Test Conditions: The experimental tests were conducted under normal pressure due to limitations in test equipment, rather than the target 30 kPa flight altitude pressure. The authors argue that the system's performance at 30 kPa would be even better, but this remains to be experimentally verified.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{cheng2019engineering,
  author = {Zhifeng Cheng and Lu Sun and Fuhe Liu and Xiaofeng Liu and Lei Li and Quanchao Li and Richa Hu},
  title = {{Engineering Design of an Active-Passive Combined Thermal Control Technology for an Aerial Optoelectronic Platform}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/s19235241},
}
Figure