Energy storage applications for low voltage consumers in Uruguay

Md Umar Hashmi, José Horta, Diego Kiedanski, Ana Busic, Daniel KofmanarXiv 2020 · arXiv

As global power grids transition toward intermittent renewable energy sources like wind and solar, the role of the "prosumer"—consumers who both produce and consume energy—becomes increasingly vital. Uruguay, a global leader in renewable integration, provides a unique regulatory environment for testing residential energy management strategies. This paper explores how residential consumers in Uruguay can utilize battery storage systems to significantly reduce electricity bills by co-optimizing energy arbitrage and reactive power compensation.

The Regulatory Landscape in Uruguay

The profitability of residential battery storage is heavily dictated by the interaction between pricing structures and compensation mechanisms. In many international markets, complex "lookahead" models are required to predict future prices and usage. However, Uruguay's regulatory framework simplifies this significantly.

Classification of pricing and compensation scenarios, highlighting Case 1 (ToU + Equal Buy & Sell) as the focus for uncertainty-free arbitrage.

As illustrated in Figure 1, the combination of Time-of-Use (ToU) pricing and an "Equal Buy & Sell" compensation mechanism (Net Metering) creates a scenario (Case 1) where storage performing arbitrage is not sensitive to uncertainty. Because the price for selling energy back to the grid is identical to the purchase price, the optimal control strategy becomes "myopic"—it only needs to consider the current price to make an optimal decision, removing the need for complex future price forecasting.

Hierarchical Myopic Control: A Simplified Approach

The researchers proposed a two-step hierarchical controller designed for robustness and simplicity:

  1. Active Power (Arbitrage): The controller employs threshold-based logic to determine charging and discharging cycles. It prioritizes charging during off-peak hours and discharging during peak hours. The symmetry in buying and selling prices ensures that any energy not consumed locally can be exported without financial penalty, effectively treating the grid as an infinite, lossless battery.
  2. Reactive Power (Power Factor Correction): Beyond energy arbitrage, the system utilizes the remaining capacity in the battery’s power converter for Power Factor Correction (PFC). Many household appliances create "reactive power," which can lead to utility penalties. By using the converter's idle capacity, the system reduces these charges at zero additional hardware cost.

Analyzing Utility Contracts

The study evaluated three specific consumer contracts introduced by the Uruguayan state utility, UTE: C1 (flat rate), C2 (two-level ToU), and C3 (three-level ToU).

The 3-level Time-of-Use (ToU) contract (C3) offered by UTE, which provides the highest potential for energy arbitrage savings.

As shown in Figure 6, the C3 contract offers the most significant price differentials between time blocks (ranging from 1.803 to 8.623 peso/kWh). The research highlights that the choice of contract is often more critical than the battery hardware itself; moving from a flat-rate C1 contract to the tiered C3 structure is essential for achieving a return on investment.

Economic Viability and Results

Using performance data from the Tesla PowerWall 1 (6.4 kWh) and PowerWall 2 (13.5 kWh), the study incorporated realistic battery degradation models to assess long-term profitability. Key findings include:

  • Arbitrage Potential: Under the C3 contract, a battery can generate approximately 4.91 pesos per day per kWh of capacity.
  • Total Savings: A Tesla PowerWall 2 can provide over 50% savings on the variable portion of a typical electricity bill when combining arbitrage and reactive power compensation.
  • Hardware Viability: While the PowerWall 2 proved financially viable due to its lower cost-per-kWh, the older PowerWall 1 struggled to offset its higher initial investment costs despite the favorable regulatory environment.

Conclusion

Uruguay’s Net Metering policy effectively removes the risk of price uncertainty for residential battery owners, allowing for simple yet highly effective control strategies. While the current study focuses on individual consumer benefits, future work could explore "aggregator" models. By coordinating thousands of residential batteries as a Virtual Power Plant (VPP), these systems could provide advanced grid services such as frequency regulation and national-level peak shaving, further enhancing the stability of Uruguay's renewable-heavy grid.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy storage can be used for many applications in the Smart Grid such as energy arbitrage, peak demand shaving, power factor correction, energy backup to name a few, and can play a major role at increasing the capacity of power networks to host renewable energy sources. Often, storage control algorithms will need to be \textit{tailored} according to power networks billing structure, reliability restrictions, and other local power networks norms. In this paper we explore residential energy storage applications in Uruguay, one of the global leaders in renewable energies, where new low-voltage consumer contracts were recently introduced. Based on these billing mechanisms, we focus on energy arbitrage and reactive energy compensation with the aim of minimizing the cost of consumption of an end-user. Given that in the new contacts the buying and selling price of electricity are equal and that reactive power compensation is primarily governed by the installed converter, the storage operation is not sensitive to parameter uncertainties and, therefore, no lookahead is required for decision making. A threshold-based \textit{hierarchical} controller is proposed which decides on the optimal active energy for arbitrage and uses the remaining converter capacity for reactive power compensation, which is shown to increase end-user profit. Numerical results indicate that storage could be profitable, even considering battery degradation, under some but not all of the studied contracts. For the cases in which it is not, we propose the best-suited contract. Results presented here can be naturally applied whenever the tariff structure satisfies the hypothesis considered in this work.
BibTeX
@misc{hashmi2020energy,
  author = {Md Umar Hashmi and José Horta and Diego Kiedanski and Ana Busic and Daniel Kofman},
  title = {{Energy storage applications for low voltage consumers in Uruguay}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.04192},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.04192},
}
Figure