TL;DR
This study optimizes retrofits for a Chinese school canteen, comparing energy-saving and decarbonization strategies. It reveals that while energy-saving retrofits drastically reduce operational energy use, decarbonization retrofits are crucial for minimizing overall lifecycle environmental impact, even if they result in higher immediate energy consumption.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China's ambitious "3060" carbon neutrality goals necessitate significant reductions in the building sector's energy consumption and carbon emissions. While much research has focused on optimizing new constructions or retrofitting school teaching buildings, auxiliary facilities like school canteens, which have unique characteristics (large open spaces, high occupancy, and specific operational demands), have been largely overlooked. These buildings contribute significantly to campus energy use. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the distinct outcomes of energy-saving versus lifecycle decarbonization retrofits specifically for a school canteen, aiming to provide practical guidance for such retrofits in China.
Methods
The study employs a multi-stage approach:
- Building Modeling: The school canteen was modeled using SketchUp and then imported into EnergyPlus 23.1.0 for detailed energy performance simulation.
- Sensitivity Analysis: Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression was used to identify the most influential design variables (e.g., insulation materials, window types, PV system configurations) for optimization. This helped to reduce the dimensionality of the problem.
- Optimization: The Strengthened Elitist Genetic Algorithm (SEGA), an enhanced genetic algorithm known for its efficiency in handling complex, non-linear problems, was used to find optimal solutions for two distinct objectives:
- Energy-Saving Retrofit: Minimizing annual total primary energy consumption (TES).
- Decarbonization Retrofit: Minimizing lifecycle carbon emissions (E), encompassing construction, operation, and demolition stages.
Datasets
The study utilized standard Nanjing weather data provided by the EnergyPlus website for its simulations. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Energy-Saving vs. Decarbonization: A Fundamental Trade-off: The core insight is that optimizing solely for energy savings (reducing operational energy use) does not automatically lead to the lowest lifecycle carbon emissions. Conversely, a decarbonization strategy might increase operational energy consumption to achieve a lower overall environmental footprint.
- Canteen Specifics Matter: The unique characteristics of canteens (large spaces, high heat/moisture loads from food preparation) mean that generic retrofit strategies might not be optimal. This study highlights the need for tailored approaches.
- Lifecycle Perspective is Crucial: Focusing only on operational energy misses the significant carbon impact of material production and construction. Decarbonization retrofits explicitly account for this broader scope.
- PV System Design Differs: The optimal PV system configuration for energy-saving differs from that for decarbonization. The energy-saving scheme maximizes PV coverage to achieve net-zero energy, while the decarbonization scheme takes a more conservative approach, considering the embodied carbon of PV materials.
Key Results
- Energy-Saving Scheme: Achieved zero net energy consumption annually, generating a surplus of 20,625.2 kWh (15.05 kWh/m²). This was achieved with specific insulation thicknesses (40mm EPS for walls, 150mm PUR for roof), optimized window configurations (low-E glass, specific WWRs), and maximized PV coverage.
- Decarbonization Scheme: Achieved zero lifecycle carbon emissions, contributing a significant carbon reduction of 386,926.4 kg. However, this scheme resulted in a 28.83% higher lifecycle TES compared to the energy-saving scheme. The PV coverage was more conservative to account for embodied carbon.
- Sensitivity Analysis: Identified key variables like insulation thickness and window types as highly influential, while external wall insulation material had a smaller impact on energy-saving optimization.
Limitations and Future Work
- Thermal Comfort Definition: While daylighting was a constraint, thermal comfort conditions were not strictly defined, which is crucial for canteen environments. Future work should integrate more stringent thermal comfort standards.
- Holistic Optimization: The study optimized building envelopes and energy systems separately for each objective. Future research should adopt a holistic approach, optimizing the interactions between envelopes, energy systems, and internal controls for a more integrated outcome.
- Dynamic Building Envelopes: Advancements in smart building technologies and dynamic envelope designs (especially for light wells) could further enhance natural ventilation and daylighting, offering new avenues for future studies.
- Cost and Financing: The high initial costs of retrofit measures are a significant barrier for schools. Exploring financing models like public-private partnerships or government subsidies is recommended.
- Regional Specificity: The study's findings are specific to Nanjing's climate. Future work should explore region-specific approaches tailored to local conditions and renewable energy resources.
Summary updated