Energy-Information Trade-Offs between Movement and Sensing

Malcolm A. MacIver, Neelesh A. Patankar, Anup ShirgaonkarPLoS 2010 · DOI

Abstract

While there is accumulating evidence for the importance of the metabolic cost of information in sensory systems, how these costs are traded-off with movement when sensing is closely linked to movement is poorly understood. For example, if an animal needs to search a given amount of space beyond the range of its vision system, is it better to evolve a higher acuity visual system, or evolve a body movement system that can more rapidly move the body over that space? How is this trade-off dependent upon the three-dimensional shape of the field of sensory sensitivity (hereafter, sensorium)? How is it dependent upon sensorium mobility, either through rotation of the sensorium via muscles at the base of the sense organ (e.g., eye or pinna muscles) or neck rotation, or by whole body movement through space? Here we show that in an aquatic model system, the electric fish, a choice to swim in a more inefficient manner during prey search results in a higher prey encounter rate due to better sensory performance. The increase in prey encounter rate more than counterbalances the additional energy expended in swimming inefficiently. The reduction of swimming efficiency for improved sensing arises because positioning the sensory receptor surface to scan more space per unit time results in an increase in the area of the body pushing through the fluid, increasing wasteful body drag forces. We show that the improvement in sensory performance that occurs with the costly repositioning of the body depends upon having an elongated sensorium shape. Finally, we show that if the fish was able to reorient their sensorium independent of body movement, as fish with movable eyes can, there would be significant energy savings. This provides insight into the ubiquity of sensory organ mobility in animal design. This study exposes important links between the morphology of the sensorium, sensorium mobility, and behavioral strategy for maximally extracting energy from the environment. An "infomechanical" approach to complex behavior helps to elucidate how animals distribute functions across sensory systems and movement systems with their diverse energy loads.

Introduction

In biological systems, movement (biomechanics) and sensing (neuroscience) are frequently studied as independent domains. However, for many organisms, sensing is physically coupled to movement. When an animal searches for prey beyond its immediate sensory range, it faces a fundamental trade-off: should it invest in higher sensory acuity or more efficient locomotion? This study, published in PLoS Computational Biology, investigates this "infomechanical" trade-off in the black ghost knifefish (Apteronotus albifrons). Specifically, the researchers examine why this species adopts a seemingly inefficient 30° head-down pitch during prey search—a posture that significantly increases hydrodynamic drag but optimizes the rate of prey encounter.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach to quantify the costs and benefits of the fish's hunting posture:

  • Empirical Drag Measurements: A high-fidelity urethane cast of a knifefish was towed in a specialized water tank (the GALCIT towtank) to measure drag forces across various angles (0° to 90°) and speeds.
  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): High-resolution simulations visualized flow patterns and wakes to explain the physical basis of the measured drag forces.
  • Sensory Modeling: The fish’s "sensorium"—the 3D volume where it can detect prey like Daphnia—was modeled as an elongated cuboid based on previous biological data.
  • Energetics Equation: A mathematical model ($E_{prey}$) was developed to calculate the energy required to find a single prey item, balancing the power needed to overcome drag against the volume of water scanned per unit of time (search rate).

Results and Discussion

The study reveals that the knifefish's posture is an energetically optimal strategy. While tilting from 0° to 30° increases drag by a factor of 2 to 4, it simultaneously increases the projected sensory area by 190%. This is analogous to turning a flashlight sideways to sweep a wider path.

The black ghost knifefish (A) and its modeled hunting posture (B), illustrating the 30° pitch used during prey search.

Despite the higher drag, the 30° posture results in a 40% energy saving per prey encounter compared to horizontal swimming. The benefit of this tilting strategy is strictly dependent on the elongated shape of the sensorium; a spherical sensory field would gain no search advantage from tilting, only increased drag.

Furthermore, "what if" scenarios suggest that if the fish could reorient its sensory field independently of its body—similar to how humans move their eyes—it would achieve massive energy savings. This provides a compelling evolutionary explanation for the ubiquity of movable sense organs (eyes, pinnae) in nature, as they decouple sensing from the high energetic cost of whole-body reorientation.

Conclusion

This "infomechanical" framework demonstrates that evolutionary strategies can favor seemingly inefficient hydrodynamics if the sensory gains outweigh the metabolic costs. The study highlights how intelligence and efficiency are distributed across an animal's morphology and its interaction with physical laws. Future applications of this work could inform the design of autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs) or assistive technologies where sensor mobility can be optimized for energy conservation.

Summary updated

Abstract

While there is accumulating evidence for the importance of the metabolic cost of information in sensory systems, how these costs are traded-off with movement when sensing is closely linked to movement is poorly understood. For example, if an animal needs to search a given amount of space beyond the range of its vision system, is it better to evolve a higher acuity visual system, or evolve a body movement system that can more rapidly move the body over that space? How is this trade-off dependent upon the three-dimensional shape of the field of sensory sensitivity (hereafter, sensorium)? How is it dependent upon sensorium mobility, either through rotation of the sensorium via muscles at the base of the sense organ (e.g., eye or pinna muscles) or neck rotation, or by whole body movement through space? Here we show that in an aquatic model system, the electric fish, a choice to swim in a more inefficient manner during prey search results in a higher prey encounter rate due to better sensory performance. The increase in prey encounter rate more than counterbalances the additional energy expended in swimming inefficiently. The reduction of swimming efficiency for improved sensing arises because positioning the sensory receptor surface to scan more space per unit time results in an increase in the area of the body pushing through the fluid, increasing wasteful body drag forces. We show that the improvement in sensory performance that occurs with the costly repositioning of the body depends upon having an elongated sensorium shape. Finally, we show that if the fish was able to reorient their sensorium independent of body movement, as fish with movable eyes can, there would be significant energy savings. This provides insight into the ubiquity of sensory organ mobility in animal design. This study exposes important links between the morphology of the sensorium, sensorium mobility, and behavioral strategy for maximally extracting energy from the environment. An "infomechanical" approach to complex behavior helps to elucidate how animals distribute functions across sensory systems and movement systems with their diverse energy loads.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maciver2010energy,
  author = {Malcolm A. MacIver and Neelesh A. Patankar and Anup Shirgaonkar},
  title = {{Energy-Information Trade-Offs between Movement and Sensing}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000769},
}
Figure