Energy flexibility from the consumer: Integrating local electricity and heat supplies in a building

Yang Zhang, Pietro Elia Campana, Ying Yang, Bengt Stridh, Anders Lundblad, Jinyue YanApplied Energy 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how integrating local electricity and heat supplies in a building can create a new source of energy flexibility for the electrical grid. By optimizing the building's energy system, they demonstrate significant potential for reducing operational costs and providing valuable grid services, even with fluctuating renewable energy sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing penetration of renewable energy sources like solar and wind power introduces variability and uncertainty into electrical grids. Maintaining a stable balance between electricity supply and demand is becoming a significant challenge. While demand-side management (DSM) and grid-level flexibility measures exist, there's a growing need for new ways to enhance grid stability. This paper focuses on a specific, under-explored area: how a single building, by intelligently managing its own electricity and heat consumption and generation, can act as a flexible resource for the broader energy system.

Methods

The core of this research utilizes Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) to optimize the building's energy system. This involves simultaneously determining the optimal capacities of various components (like heat pumps, electrical heaters, batteries, and hot water tanks) and their operational schedules over a year. The optimization objective is to minimize the Net Present Cost (NPC) of the system over its lifetime, considering investment, maintenance, replacement, electricity, and district heating costs.

To account for uncertainties in future energy prices and component costs, the study employs Sensitivity Analysis and Monte Carlo Simulations. Sensitivity analysis explores how variations in component investment costs affect the NPC and system configuration. Monte Carlo simulations, run 2000 times, assess the impact of energy cost uncertainties on the yearly operation cost.

A novel aspect is the introduction of two metrics to quantify flexibility: flexibility hours (the number of hours the building can modulate its electricity consumption) and flexibility energy (the amount of electricity consumption modulated). These are assessed by imposing constraints on electricity consumption (±30% of the reference) during specific "random hours" and re-optimizing the system.

Datasets

The study uses data for a Swedish office building in Västerås. This includes:

  • Electricity demand profiles: Based on a reference system with a PV installation.
  • District heating profiles: For the building's heat demand.
  • Energy cost parameters: Including DSO (Distribution System Operator) and ER (Energy Retailer) charges, spot market prices, and district heating prices for different seasons.
  • Component lifetimes and investment costs: Sourced from literature and market data.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data and established models were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Buildings as Active Grid Players: The research highlights that buildings are not just passive consumers but can actively contribute to grid stability by intelligently managing their energy use.
  • Economic Viability of Integration: Integrating local electricity and heat supplies can lead to significant cost savings (up to 22% reduction in NPC) compared to the reference system, even with the added complexity of new components.
  • District Heating's Role in Flexibility: While the optimized system initially favors electricity for heating due to cost, the district heating network becomes crucial when flexibility is required by the grid, demonstrating its value as a flexible energy source.
  • Flexibility has a Cost, but it's Manageable: Providing flexibility to the grid does increase yearly operation costs, but this increase is often marginal and can be offset by the economic benefits of optimized energy management and potential future revenue streams from flexibility services.
  • Component Selection Matters: The study shows that not all components are equally influential. Heat pump (HP) and hot water tank (HWT) investment costs, particularly the 'a' parameters (cost per unit capacity), have the most significant impact on the NPC and optimal system configuration.

Key Results

  • The optimized integrated system achieved a 22% lower Net Present Cost (NPC) compared to the reference system.
  • The yearly electricity exportation was reduced by 30%, leading to a self-consumption ratio increase from 43% to 61%.
  • The optimal system provided over 5200 flexibility hours per year, with the ability to modulate electricity consumption by up to 30%.
  • The highest flexibility energy reached over 15.7 MWh (36% of yearly electricity consumption).
  • Monte Carlo simulations indicated a 93% probability of the optimal system achieving a lower NPC than the reference system, even with future energy cost uncertainties.
  • In the optimal system, the district heating network was disconnected for the primary heat supply, indicating electricity-based heating (heat pump and electrical heater) was more economical under the studied conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local Economic Assumptions: The study's economic assumptions are specific to the Swedish context and may not be directly applicable elsewhere. Further studies across different regions are needed.
  • MILP Linearization: The use of MILP linearizes the system, which can introduce some errors. It also assumes perfect forecasting of demand and production, which is not realistic.
  • Thermal Inertia Ignored: The thermal inertia of the building, which could provide additional flexibility, was not included due to scope limitations and the reliance on historical heat demand data. Future work should explore this.
  • Market Value of Flexibility: The economic value of the provided flexibility is not accounted for, as the current market doesn't allow consumers to trade flexibility with the grid. Future studies could incorporate this.
  • DH Supply Constraints: Only flexibility requirements from the electricity grid were considered. Future research could include constraints from the DH supply (e.g., ramp rate) and explore flexibility transfer between networks via the consumer.
  • Centralized vs. Decentralized Integration: A detailed comparison between centralized and decentralized integration of multiple energy networks is suggested for future work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018energy,
  author = {Yang Zhang and Pietro Elia Campana and Ying Yang and Bengt Stridh and Anders Lundblad and Jinyue Yan},
  title = {{Energy flexibility from the consumer: Integrating local electricity and heat supplies in a building}},
  booktitle = {Applied Energy},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.apenergy.2018.04.041},
}
Figure