Energy expenditure does not explain step length-width choices during walking

Stephen A. Antos, Konrad P. Körding, Keith E. GordonbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Healthy young adults typically adopt a preferred walking speed, step length, and step width that closely align with energetic optimality. However, humans can choose from a vast array of stepping patterns, each varying in metabolic cost and subjective preference. This study investigates whether these conscious preferences are dictated solely by metabolic energy expenditure. Using a two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) paradigm, fifteen participants compared different stepping patterns on an oversized treadmill. The researchers identified "indifference points"—stepping patterns that participants preferred equally. If energy minimization were the sole driver of gait choice, these equally preferred patterns should theoretically incur identical metabolic costs. However, the results demonstrated significant differences in energy expenditure across equally preferred patterns ($p < 0.001$). Notably, participants frequently preferred longer steps with higher metabolic costs over shorter, wider steps with lower costs. Furthermore, subjective perceptions of energy expenditure often failed to align with actual metabolic data. These findings suggest that factors beyond global energy minimization, such as local muscle comfort or stability, play a critical role in conscious gait selection.

Introduction

For decades, the "Energy Minimization Hypothesis" has served as a cornerstone of biomechanics. It posits that human movement is governed by an internal drive to conserve metabolic energy, leading us to naturally adopt the most efficient gait patterns. While this hypothesis accurately predicts our "baseline" walking behavior, it remains unclear whether energy is the primary metric used when we are forced to deviate from our natural stride.

This study from researchers at Northwestern University and the University of Pennsylvania challenges the assumption that energy is the sole component of our internal "utility function." By exploring how individuals choose between alternative walking patterns, the study seeks to determine if preference and efficiency are truly synonymous.

Methods

To test the relationship between preference and energy, the researchers recruited 15 healthy young adults for a series of trials on an oversized treadmill. To ensure precise control over gait, a projector displayed rectangular stepping targets on the treadmill belt, which participants were required to follow.

The Two-Alternative Forced-Choice (2AFC) Paradigm

The core of the experiment relied on a 2AFC method borrowed from psychophysics. Participants were presented with two distinct stepping patterns (e.g., a "Short & Narrow" pattern versus a "Long & Narrow" pattern) for 10 seconds each. After experiencing both, they were forced to choose the pattern they preferred. Using an adaptive staircase logic, the researchers adjusted the dimensions of the steps until the participant reached an "indifference point"—a state where they chose each pattern 50% of the time.

Metabolic and Subjective Assessment

Once these equally preferred patterns were identified, participants walked in each for six minutes while their oxygen consumption ($V\dot{O}_2$) was measured to calculate actual metabolic power (Watts/kg). Finally, participants were asked to rank the various patterns by their subjective preference and their perceived level of physical effort.

Key Insights

Preference vs. Efficiency

The study’s primary finding is that "equally preferred" does not mean "equally energetic." For nearly every participant, the metabolic costs of their indifference-point gaits were significantly different. This divergence proves that when humans make conscious decisions about how to move, they are weighing factors other than total caloric burn.

The Bias Toward Length

A consistent trend emerged regarding step dimensions: participants showed a marked preference for longer steps, even when those steps were the most metabolically expensive options. Conversely, wider steps were often disliked and ranked lower in preference, despite being more energy-efficient than the longer alternatives. This suggests a "Long Step Bias" where the perceived cost of taking wider steps outweighs the actual metabolic cost of taking longer ones.

Local Discomfort and Perception

Why would a person choose a more expensive gait? Participants reported that wider steps felt "uncomfortable" for their hip abductors. This indicates that "local" costs—discomfort in specific muscle groups—can override the "global" metabolic cost of the entire body. Furthermore, humans appear to be poor judges of their own efficiency; only 7 of the 15 participants could accurately rank the gaits from most to least energy-intensive.

Results

  • Metabolic Divergence: Metabolic power was not equal across equally preferred patterns ($p < 0.001$).
  • Cost Disparity: Longer steps required significantly more metabolic power than shorter steps ($p < 0.001$) and wider steps ($p < 0.001$), yet they remained equally preferred by the participants.
  • Individual Variation: Only one participant (S08) exhibited metabolic costs within a 10% range across all equally preferred gaits, highlighting that the disconnect between energy and preference is a near-universal trait.
  • Ranking Mismatch: Subjective rankings of preference and perceived effort did not align with objective metabolic measurements for the majority of the cohort.

Discussion and Implications

While this study demonstrates that energy isn't the only factor in gait choice, it leaves the door open for future research to define what those other factors are. The 10-second choice window suggests that initial preferences are driven by immediate sensations—like stability or joint pressure—rather than long-term metabolic efficiency, which takes minutes to register.

These findings have significant implications for the design of robotic exoskeletons and physical therapy protocols. If clinicians and engineers aim to encourage more efficient movement patterns, they must recognize that users may not naturally gravitate toward the most efficient option if it feels uncomfortable or unstable. Success in gait rehabilitation may require accounting for a user's conscious preferences and perceived comfort as much as their metabolic output.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Healthy young adults have a most preferred walking speed, step length, and step width that are close to energetically optimal. However, people can choose to walk with a multitude of different step lengths and widths, which can vary in both energy expenditure and preference. Here we further investigate step length-width preferences and their relationship to energy expenditure. In line with a growing body of research, we hypothesized that people’s preferred stepping patterns would not be fully explained by metabolic energy expenditure. To test this hypothesis we used a two-alternative forced-choice paradigm. Fifteen participants walked on an oversized treadmill. Each trial participants experienced two stepping patterns and then chose the pattern they preferred. Over time, we adapted the choices such that there was 50% chance of choosing one pattern over another (equally preferred). If people’s preferences are based solely on metabolic energy expenditure, then these equally preferred stepping patterns should have equal energy expenditure. We found that energy expenditure differed across equally preferred step length-width patterns (p &lt; 0.001). On average, longer steps with higher energy expenditures were preferred over shorter and wider steps with lower energy expenditures (p &lt; 0.001). We also asked participants to rank a set of shorter, wider, and longer steps from most preferred to least preferred, and from most energy expended to least energy expended. Only 7/15 participants had the same rankings for their preferences and perceived energy expenditure. Our results suggest that energy expenditure is not the only factor influencing a person’s conscious gait choices.
BibTeX
@misc{antos2021energy,
  author = {Stephen A. Antos and Konrad P. Körding and Keith E. Gordon},
  title = {{Energy expenditure does not explain step length-width choices during walking}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.11.439375},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure