Energy-Efficient User Association with Open Loop Power Control for Uplink Heterogeneous Cellular Networks

Tianqing Zhou, Yongming Huang, Luxi YangarXiv 2015 · OpenReview

Abstract

Energy reduction for wireless systems becomes more and more important due to its impact on the operation cost and global carbon footprint. In this paper, we investigate three kinds of energy-efficient association schemes under open loop power control for uplink heterogeneous cellular networks, which are formulated as a whole energy efficiency maximization problem, a sum energy efficiency maximization problem and a utility maximization problem respectively. The third case takes account of load balancing level and user's fairness in the energy-efficient association. Considering that the first problem is in a fractional mixed-integer form, we introduce an energy efficiency parameter to convert it into a parametric subtractive form, and then design an effective iterative algorithm to achieve the optimal solutions. As for the third problem, we first introduce a dual variable to decouple the constraint and then develop a distributed algorithm using dual decomposition. In addition, we also give the convergence proof for the proposed algorithms. In order to confirm the effectiveness of energy-efficient user association algorithms, we introduce other association rules for comparison, and investigate the influences of different parameters on the association performance of these association rules.

Introduction

As cellular networks evolve toward heterogeneous architectures (HCNs), traditional macro base stations (MBS) are increasingly supplemented by low-power pico base stations (PBS). While this density improves coverage, it complicates the user association process. Traditionally, users connect to the station with the strongest signal (Max-Power), which often leads to severe load imbalances and inefficient energy use. This paper shifts the focus from raw throughput to Energy Efficiency (EE), defined as the ratio of data transmitted to energy consumed (bits per Joule).

Network Model and Power Control

The study considers a two-tier uplink HCN where users are distributed across hexagonal cells containing both MBSs and PBSs. To manage computational complexity, the researchers employ Open Loop Power Control. In this model, a user's transmit power is determined primarily by pathloss—the signal attenuation over distance—rather than high-overhead closed-loop feedback. This approach is particularly effective in HCNs because the proximity of pico stations allows for significantly lower transmit power, saving device battery life.

The multi-tier network model featuring Macro Base Stations (MBS), Pico Base Stations (PBS), and mobile users.

Proposed Association Schemes

The paper develops three distinct mathematical frameworks to optimize user association:

  1. AMWEE (Maximizing Whole EE): This scheme optimizes the global network efficiency as a single ratio (Total Rate / Total Power). It uses an iterative algorithm to solve the fractional mixed-integer programming problem.
  2. AMSEE (Maximizing Sum EE): This approach focuses on the sum of individual users' efficiencies. It is computationally simpler, as users independently select the base station that maximizes their personal energy efficiency.
  3. EEAUF (Energy-Efficient Association with User Fairness): By utilizing a logarithmic utility function, this scheme ensures fair resource distribution. It employs dual decomposition to allow base stations and users to reach an optimal association distributedly, where a "dual variable" acts as a price to discourage connecting to overloaded stations.

Performance Evaluation

Numerical simulations based on 3GPP standards demonstrate the trade-offs between throughput and energy efficiency. While the throughput-focused MARA (Maximal Achievable Rate Association) scheme provides the highest raw data rates, it performs poorly in terms of energy consumption.

Performance comparison showing Average Energy Efficiency and Whole Energy Efficiency across different user and PBS densities.

As shown in the results, the AMWEE scheme consistently achieves the highest global (Whole) energy efficiency. Meanwhile, the EEAUF scheme successfully balances the load; using Jain’s Fairness Index, it maintains a score near 0.9, indicating highly equitable distribution even as user density increases. The results confirm that energy-efficient algorithms naturally offload traffic from the macro network to smaller cells, significantly reducing the overall carbon footprint of the network.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that energy-efficient user association, when paired with open-loop power control, offers a practical and effective way to manage modern HCNs. By prioritizing bits-per-Joule over bits-per-second, the proposed algorithms (AMWEE, AMSEE, and EEAUF) provide significant gains in battery life and network sustainability with manageable computational overhead.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy reduction for wireless systems becomes more and more important due to its impact on the operation cost and global carbon footprint. In this paper, we investigate three kinds of energy-efficient association schemes under open loop power control for uplink heterogeneous cellular networks, which are formulated as a whole energy efficiency maximization problem, a sum energy efficiency maximization problem and a utility maximization problem respectively. The third case takes account of load balancing level and user's fairness in the energy-efficient association. Considering that the first problem is in a fractional mixed-integer form, we introduce an energy efficiency parameter to convert it into a parametric subtractive form, and then design an effective iterative algorithm to achieve the optimal solutions. As for the third problem, we first introduce a dual variable to decouple the constraint and then develop a distributed algorithm using dual decomposition. In addition, we also give the convergence proof for the proposed algorithms. In order to confirm the effectiveness of energy-efficient user association algorithms, we introduce other association rules for comparison, and investigate the influences of different parameters on the association performance of these association rules.
BibTeX
@misc{zhou2015energy,
  author = {Tianqing Zhou and Yongming Huang and Luxi Yang},
  title = {{Energy-Efficient User Association with Open Loop Power Control for Uplink Heterogeneous Cellular Networks}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1511.08342},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1511.08342},
}
Figure