Energy-Efficient UAV Communications With Directional Antennas: Tilting Effect Modeling and Trajectory Optimization

Xiaojun Yuan, Xinhong Dai, Bin Duo, Xiaojun Yuan 0002, Marco Di RenzoIEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing energy efficiency in UAV communications by accounting for the "tilting effect" – the natural instability of UAV flight. By developing a novel model for this effect and proposing an iterative optimization algorithm, the authors demonstrate a significant improvement in both energy efficiency and communication performance compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are increasingly used for wireless communication due to their agility and ability to provide line-of-sight links. To enhance transmission efficiency and reduce interference, directional antennas are often employed. However, a critical factor often overlooked is the "tilting effect" of the UAV's fuselage, which is essential for horizontal movement but introduces instability. This tilting causes the directional antenna's beam to deviate from its intended target, negatively impacting communication performance and potentially increasing energy consumption due to compensatory maneuvers. Existing research often assumes a perfectly stable UAV, neglecting this crucial aspect. This paper aims to bridge this gap by modeling the tilting effect and incorporating it into the trajectory optimization process to maximize energy efficiency.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-faceted approach:

  • Tilting Effect Modeling: They first establish a relationship between the UAV's flight status (velocity, acceleration) and its tilting effect using force analysis. This model quantifies how flight dynamics influence antenna orientation.
  • Energy Efficiency Maximization Problem Formulation: An optimization problem is formulated to maximize the UAV's energy efficiency (EE) by jointly optimizing its trajectory and communication parameters, explicitly considering the tilting effect and a directional antenna model.
  • Approximate Radiation Pattern: The complex, non-convex directional antenna radiation pattern is approximated by a simpler, convex lower bound. This simplification is crucial for making the optimization problem tractable.
  • Successive Convex Approximation (SCA) Technique: To handle the remaining non-convexities in the problem, an iterative algorithm based on SCA is developed. This technique progressively approximates non-convex functions with convex ones, allowing for the iterative optimization of the UAV's trajectory and other parameters.
  • Propulsion Energy Consumption Model: A generalized propulsion energy consumption model is adopted, which accounts for the UAV's velocity and acceleration, further contributing to the realistic optimization of energy usage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulated data generated based on the proposed models and parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Tilting Effect is Crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes that neglecting the UAV's tilting effect leads to suboptimal energy efficiency and communication performance. This instability is not just a minor nuisance but a significant factor that needs to be addressed in trajectory design.
  • Smoother Trajectories for Better Performance: Considering the tilting effect encourages smoother UAV trajectories. This steadier flight path not only mitigates the negative impact of antenna beam deviation but also reduces compensatory maneuvers, leading to lower propulsion energy consumption.
  • Approximation is Key to Tractability: The development of an approximate, convex lower bound for the directional antenna's radiation pattern is a critical enabler for solving the complex optimization problem. This highlights the importance of mathematical simplification in tackling real-world engineering challenges.
  • Energy Efficiency vs. Achievable Rate Trade-off: The results suggest that while maximizing achievable rate is important, optimizing for energy efficiency, especially when considering the tilting effect, leads to more sustainable and practical UAV operations.

Key Results

  • Improved Energy Efficiency: The proposed MEE-TE (Maximizing Energy Efficiency with Tilting Effect) scheme achieved substantially higher EE compared to benchmark schemes (MEE-ITE, MAR-TE, MAR-ITE). For instance, Fig. 15 shows MEE-TE consistently outperforming others across varying antenna element numbers.
  • More Stable Trajectories: Visualizations (Figs. 6-9) demonstrate that the optimized trajectories considering the tilting effect are smoother and less erratic, leading to a more steady flight.
  • Better Antenna Directivity: Figs. 10 and 11 show that the average angular deviation of the antenna beam (αk) is significantly lower with the MEE-TE scheme, indicating better alignment with the ground users.
  • Reduced Instantaneous Power Consumption: Fig. 12 illustrates that considering the tilting effect leads to lower instantaneous power consumption, especially when compared to schemes that prioritize high acceleration for rate maximization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Accuracy: While the approximate radiation pattern fits well within the half-power beamwidth, its accuracy for very narrow beams or extreme angles might be a limitation. The paper acknowledges this by using the original pattern for final validation.
  • Computational Complexity: The proposed algorithm's computational complexity is noted as O((3KN + 5N)3.5 log(1/€)), which can be high for a large number of users (K) and time slots (N).
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research could explore more advanced antenna models, consider dynamic environmental factors like wind, and investigate multi-UAV systems with cooperative trajectory optimization. The authors also mention that the optimized trajectory is highly related to a defined minimum achievable rate (Rm), suggesting further exploration of this parameter's impact.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yuan2025energy,
  author = {Xiaojun Yuan and Xinhong Dai and Bin Duo and Xiaojun Yuan and Marco Di Renzo},
  title = {{Energy-Efficient UAV Communications With Directional Antennas: Tilting Effect Modeling and Trajectory Optimization}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2025.3545454},
}
Figure