Energy-efficient time and energy resource allocation in non-selfish symbiotic cognitive relaying sensor network with privacy preserving for smart city

Ping Li, Yu Liu, Xiang Gao, Huibo Li, Peng GongEURASIP 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) serve as the foundational infrastructure for smart cities. However, their deployment is often constrained by three critical challenges: limited battery life of sensor nodes, spectrum scarcity, and inherent vulnerabilities to eavesdropping. Traditional Cognitive Radio (CR) models, while addressing spectrum scarcity, often operate on "selfish" principles where secondary users prioritize their own gains. This paper introduces a "non-selfish symbiotic" relaying scheme designed to optimize energy efficiency (EE) and data privacy for both primary and secondary users.

The Non-selfish Symbiotic Cognitive Relaying Scheme (NSCRS)

The proposed Non-selfish Symbiotic Cognitive Relaying Scheme (NSCRS) establishes a mutually beneficial relationship between a Primary User (PU) and secondary Cognitive Users (CUs). In this model, CUs act as relays for the PU. When a CU facilitates more efficient transmission for the PU than a direct link would allow, the PU "rewards" the CU with "incentive time" to transmit its own data.

Figure 1: System architecture of the proposed NSCRS, illustrating the interaction between PUs, CUs, the Access Point (AP), and potential eavesdroppers.

Technical Components

  1. Privacy Preserving via Artificial Noise (AN): To secure the network against eavesdroppers, an Access Point (AP) broadcasts artificial noise during the transmission phases. While the intended receiver can cancel this noise using shared Channel State Information (CSI), unauthorized listeners face a significantly degraded signal.
  2. Non-Orthogonal Amplify-and-Forward (NAF): The scheme utilizes NAF relaying, enabling multiple CUs to transmit signals simultaneously within the same frequency band, thereby enhancing spectral efficiency compared to traditional orthogonal methods.
  3. Resource Allocation Algorithms:
  4. Optimal Algorithm (OPA): An exhaustive search approach utilizing full, instantaneous CSI to determine the ideal balance of time and energy allocation.
  5. Partial CSI Algorithm (PPA): A suboptimal but practical alternative for slow-fading environments. It uses average CSI values to reduce communication overhead, making it suitable for low-power IoT devices.
Figure 2: Comparison of transmission methods between Conventional Cognitive Radio (CCR) and the proposed NSCRS, highlighting the allocation of incentive time.

Key Insights

  • Symbiosis as a Performance Driver: By framing the relationship as symbiotic, the authors demonstrate that the primary network's performance can be enhanced by integrating secondary users as relays.
  • Physical Layer Security: Integrating privacy at the physical layer via AP-generated noise provides a robust security mechanism without the computational overhead of complex encryption on every sensor node.
  • Efficiency of Partial CSI: The PPA algorithm achieves near-optimal energy efficiency with significantly reduced feedback requirements, a critical factor for practical WSN deployments.
  • Single Best Relay Optimality: Mathematical induction proves that selecting the single "best" CU for relaying is often more efficient than distributing energy across multiple relays, simplifying system implementation.

Results and Conclusion

Simulation results indicate that the NSCRS significantly outperforms Conventional Cognitive Radio (CCR), achieving an optimal energy efficiency of approximately 2.26 bits/s/Hz/J. While the OPA provides the theoretical performance ceiling, the PPA remains remarkably competitive, particularly as link quality improves.

The study concludes that the proposed resource allocation algorithms effectively maximize total energy efficiency while maintaining information privacy. Future work may extend this model to multi-hop scenarios and multi-user primary networks to better reflect the complex interference environments of modern urban centers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Energy efficiency and privacy preserving have become essential for the wireless sensor networks. In this paper, a joint energy and time resource allocation problem for the cognitive users (CUs) in a non-selfish symbiotic cognitive relaying scheme (NSCRS) is considered. We aim to maximize the total energy efficiency (EE) of the primary user and CUs with the consideration of information privacy under the total energy constraints of CUs. With full channel state information (CSI), an optimal energy and time resource allocation algorithm is proposed based on the exhaustive searching. Besides, in order to reduce the overhead of CSI feedback, a suboptimal algorithm, in which only the partial instantaneous CSI is required, is additionally proposed. Simulation results demonstrate the EE of primary and CUs in the NSCRS with consideration of information privacy can be greatly improved by the proposed algorithms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021energy,
  author = {Ping Li and Yu Liu and Xiang Gao and Huibo Li and Peng Gong},
  title = {{Energy-efficient time and energy resource allocation in non-selfish symbiotic cognitive relaying sensor network with privacy preserving for smart city}},
  booktitle = {EURASIP},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s13638-021-01903-9},
}
Figure