Energy-efficient Buffer-aided Optimal Relay Selection Scheme with Power Adaptation and Inter-relay Interference Cancellation

Xiaorong Xu, Liang Li, Yingbiao Yao, Xianyang Jiang, Sanqing HuKSII 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Energy-efficient Buffer-aided Optimal Relay Selection Scheme" that significantly improves wireless communication efficiency. By intelligently selecting relay pairs, adapting power levels, and canceling interference, the scheme achieves better outage performance, reduced latency, and lower energy consumption compared to existing methods, making it ideal for green cooperative communications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of mobile data traffic has led to a staggering increase in energy consumption by wireless communication networks. This paper addresses the critical challenge of reducing this energy footprint while simultaneously enhancing network performance, specifically focusing on cooperative relaying systems. Traditional cooperative relaying often faces a tradeoff between energy efficiency and reliable data transmission (outage probability). Furthermore, existing relay selection schemes often overlook the impact of relay buffer states and inter-relay interference (IRI), which can degrade performance. This work aims to bridge this gap by proposing a scheme that optimizes energy consumption, minimizes outage probability, and mitigates interference, all while leveraging the benefits of buffer-aided relaying and mimicking full-duplex (FD) communication for improved spectral efficiency.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposed "Energy-efficient Buffer-aided Optimal Relay Selection Scheme." This scheme operates in two main steps:

  1. Optimal Relay Pair Selection: The system intelligently selects a pair of relays: an "optimal receive relay" and an "optimal transmit relay." This selection is based on a multi-criteria approach considering:
  2. Energy Consumption: Minimizing the power used by relays.
  3. Buffer State: The current occupancy of the relay's buffer.
  4. Outage Probability: The likelihood of communication failure.
  5. Channel Quality: The strength of the communication links. This selection process aims to mimic Full-Duplex (FD) relaying by allowing reception and transmission within the same time slot, thereby enhancing spectral efficiency.

  6. Power Adaptation and Inter-Relay Interference (IRI) Cancellation: The scheme incorporates power adaptation to adjust relay transmission power based on the selected relay pair and channel conditions. Crucially, it also implements mechanisms to cancel inter-relay interference, which is a significant issue in systems with multiple relays operating simultaneously.

To analyze the system's performance, the authors employ:

  • Markov Chain Model: This model is used to track the evolution of relay buffer states over time, allowing for the analysis of system steady-state outage probability.
  • Theoretical Framework: The paper derives expressions for system steady-state outage probability and achievable diversity order.
  • Performance Analysis: The average packet transmission delay and power reduction are analyzed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation-based numerical results, rather than evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Buffer State is Key: The paper highlights that effectively utilizing relay buffer states is crucial for improving system performance, not just for storing data but for informing relay selection decisions.
  • Mimicking FD with HD: By carefully selecting relay pairs and coordinating their operations, buffer-aided Half-Duplex (HD) relays can effectively mimic the performance of Full-Duplex (FD) relays, achieving higher spectral efficiency without the hardware complexity of true FD systems.
  • Holistic Optimization: The proposed scheme moves beyond optimizing a single metric (like outage probability or energy consumption) and instead considers a holistic approach that balances energy efficiency, outage behavior, and delay performance.
  • IRI is a Major Hurdle: The paper explicitly addresses and proposes a solution for inter-relay interference, a common challenge in multi-relay systems that can significantly degrade performance.
  • Power Adaptation for Efficiency: Adapting transmit power based on channel conditions and relay roles (receive vs. transmit) is shown to be a powerful tool for both energy saving and interference management.

Key Results

  • Superior Outage Performance: Numerical results demonstrate that the proposed scheme significantly outperforms existing methods (like max-max relay selection, max-link relay selection, buffer state relay selection, and Successive Opportunistic Relaying) in terms of outage probability, especially at higher Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNRs).
  • Reduced Packet Latency: The scheme achieves lower average packet delay compared to other relay selection schemes, attributed to its ability to mimic FD relaying and reduce the number of time slots required for packet delivery.
  • Significant Power Reduction: The proposed scheme shows greater power reduction compared to buffer state relay selection, indicating its enhanced energy efficiency. This reduction increases with SNR and the number of relays.
  • Buffer Size Impact: Increasing buffer size generally leads to reduced outage probability, as it provides more available links. The proposed scheme's performance approaches that of systems with infinite buffer sizes even with finite buffers.
  • Relay Number Impact: Increasing the number of relays also leads to improved outage performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The analysis relies on several assumptions, including Rayleigh flat fading, AWGN, and i.i.d. channel coefficients. Real-world scenarios might involve more complex channel models.
  • Complexity: While the scheme aims for efficiency, the optimal relay selection process itself might introduce some computational overhead at the Cluster Head (CH).
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research could explore the performance of the proposed scheme in more complex network topologies, with different fading environments, and potentially with more advanced interference cancellation techniques. The authors also implicitly suggest that exploring the impact of mobility on the proposed scheme would be a valuable direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2016energy,
  author = {Xiaorong Xu and Liang Li and Yingbiao Yao and Xianyang Jiang and Sanqing Hu},
  title = {{Energy-efficient Buffer-aided Optimal Relay Selection Scheme with Power Adaptation and Inter-relay Interference Cancellation}},
  booktitle = {KSII},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3837/tiis.2016.11.008},
}
Figure