Energy-Efficient Backscatter-Assisted Coded Cooperative-NOMA for B5G Wireless Communications

Muhammad Asif, Asim Ihsan, Wali Ullah Khan, Ali Ranjha, Shengli Zhang, Sissi Xiaoxiao WuIEEE Trans. Green Commun. Netw 2022

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel framework for energy-efficient communication in future 5G (B5G) wireless networks by combining backscatter communication, cooperative Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA), and advanced channel coding. The approach optimizes power allocation and transmit power to maximize energy efficiency while addressing the challenges of imperfect successive interference cancellation (SIC) and poor channel conditions for distant users.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Future wireless networks, like Beyond 5th Generation (B5G), aim to connect billions of devices, leading to immense demands on spectrum and energy. Internet of Things (IoT) devices, often deployed in remote or challenging environments, have limited power and battery life, making traditional communication methods unsustainable. Backscatter Communication (BSC) offers a low-power solution by harvesting energy from ambient radio signals and reflecting them. Simultaneously, Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) enhances spectral efficiency by allowing multiple users to share the same frequency/code. However, combining these technologies presents challenges:

  • Energy Efficiency: Maximizing energy efficiency in such complex systems is crucial for sustainability.
  • Imperfect SIC: In NOMA, users decode signals sequentially. Imperfect Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the receiver leads to residual interference, degrading performance. This is particularly problematic in real-world scenarios where perfect SIC is difficult to achieve.
  • Far User Performance: Distant users in NOMA systems often suffer from poor channel conditions, further exacerbated by the lack of direct communication links with the base station (BS).
  • Cooperative Relay Errors: In cooperative NOMA, relay nodes can introduce errors that propagate, compromising overall system performance.

This paper tackles these issues by proposing an integrated system that leverages backscatter for coverage enhancement, NOMA for multiplexing, cooperative strategies for reliability, and advanced coding to mitigate errors, all while optimizing for energy efficiency under imperfect SIC conditions.

Methods

The authors introduce a multi-faceted approach:

  • Alternating Optimization Framework: To maximize energy efficiency (EE), they propose an alternating optimization framework. This framework iteratively optimizes three key parameters:
  • Transmit Power of the Source (BS): The power used by the base station to transmit signals.
  • Power Allocation Coefficients (PAC) for NOMA Users: How power is distributed among near and far users in the NOMA scheme.
  • Power of the Relay Node: The power used by the relay (near user) to retransmit signals. This optimization is performed while considering Quality of Service (QoS) requirements, power budgets, and cooperation constraints, specifically under imperfect SIC.

  • Dinkelbach Method: The fractional EE maximization problem is transformed into a tractable concave-convex fractional programming (CCFP) problem using the Dinkelbach method. This allows for efficient solution finding.

  • Successive Convex Approximation (SCA): The CCFP problem is further tackled using SCA, breaking it down into sub-problems that can be solved iteratively.
  • Lagrange Dual and Sub-gradient Methods: These mathematical techniques are employed to find optimal solutions for transmit power, PAC, and relay power within the sub-problems.
  • Jointly-Designed QC-LDPC Codes: To combat the performance degradation of the far user due to bad channels and potential error propagation from imperfect SIC and relaying, the paper proposes a novel framework of jointly-designed Quasi-Cyclic Low-Density Parity-Check (QC-LDPC) codes. These codes are designed to jointly decode the far user's data received from both the backscatter-aided source and the relay node, significantly improving error correction. The construction of these codes is based on a cyclic balanced sampling plan excluding contiguous units (CBSEC) framework.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors rely on simulations to evaluate their proposed system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of BSC, NOMA, and Cooperation: The paper demonstrates that combining backscatter communication, NOMA, and cooperative strategies can significantly enhance system performance, particularly for distant users who are often underserved.
  • Backscatter as a Coverage Enhancer: Backscatter tags are shown to be effective in extending coverage and improving signal quality for users with no direct line-of-sight to the BS, especially in scenarios with obstacles.
  • Imperfect SIC is a Major Hurdle: The research highlights the significant performance degradation caused by imperfect SIC, emphasizing the need for robust solutions that account for this practical limitation.
  • Joint Decoding for Far User Reliability: The proposed jointly-designed QC-LDPC codes are crucial for improving the Bit Error Rate (BER) of the far user by enabling joint decoding of signals from multiple sources (BS via backscatter and relay).
  • Low-Complexity Optimization: The alternating optimization framework, combined with Dinkelbach's method and SCA, provides an efficient way to solve a complex optimization problem, leading to a low-complexity algorithm.

Key Results

  • The proposed backscatter-enabled cooperative NOMA system (WBST) outperforms a system without backscatter (NBST) in terms of energy efficiency across various imperfect SIC parameter (η) values.
  • Energy efficiency increases with increasing transmit power of the source (Pt) and relay node (Pr(max)) up to a certain point, after which it saturates.
  • Higher values of the imperfect SIC parameter (η) lead to decreased energy efficiency, as expected, due to increased interference.
  • Circuit power (Pc) negatively impacts energy efficiency, as expected, since it increases overall power consumption.
  • The proposed jointly-designed QC-LDPC codes achieve excellent BER performance with only a few decoding iterations, demonstrating their effectiveness in error correction for the far user.
  • The convergence of the energy efficiency optimization algorithm is achieved within a small number of iterations (around 5), regardless of the SIC parameter value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical Convergence Analysis: While the paper mentions that the Dinkelbach transformation provides linear convergence for CCFP problems, a detailed theoretical convergence analysis of the proposed algorithm is not provided.
  • Benchmark Comparison: The authors note that finding a suitable benchmark for comparison is difficult due to the novelty of their framework, leading them to compare against a simplified NBST system.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests future work in exploring more advanced channel coding schemes, investigating different NOMA variants, and potentially incorporating machine learning for dynamic resource allocation in such complex systems. The development of more sophisticated benchmarks for comparison would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{asif2022energy,
  author = {Muhammad Asif and Asim Ihsan and Wali Ullah Khan and Ali Ranjha and Shengli Zhang and Sissi Xiaoxiao Wu},
  title = {{Energy-Efficient Backscatter-Assisted Coded Cooperative-NOMA for B5G Wireless Communications}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Green Commun. Netw.},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure