Energy dissipation of nanoconfined hydration layer: Long-range hydration on the hydrophilic solid surface

Bongsu Kim, Soyoung Kwon, Hyosik Mun, Sangmin An, Wonho JheScientific 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper quantifies the energy dissipation of nanoconfined water layers on hydrophilic surfaces using atomic force microscopy. They reveal that these "hydration layers" extend much further than previously thought, influencing nanoscale phenomena like friction and self-assembly.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of water confined to nanoscale spaces is crucial for many fields, from materials science to biology. Hydrophilic surfaces, common in nature and technology, attract water molecules to form a "hydration water layer" (HWL). While the mechanical properties (elasticity and viscosity) of these layers have been studied, their energy dissipation – how they absorb and release energy during dynamic processes – remains poorly understood. This lack of understanding hinders our ability to characterize nanoscale viscoelastic materials and predict phenomena like friction, adhesion, and self-assembly at the nanoscale. Previous studies often relied on simplified models or were limited by the tip geometry of AFM, making it difficult to probe the full extent of HWL effects.

Methods

The researchers employed a Quartz Tuning-Fork (QTF) based Amplitude Modulation Atomic Force Microscopy (AM-AFM) in a non-contact tapping mode. This technique allows for sensitive measurements of mechanical properties like elasticity and damping. They specifically used a flattened fused quartz tip interacting with an atomically flat mica substrate. This setup creates a well-defined nanoconfined space for the hydration layer.

The core of their method involves:

  • Measuring effective elasticity ($k_{int}$) and damping coefficient ($b_{int}$): These are derived from the tip's amplitude and phase shifts during oscillation.
  • Developing a theoretical model for energy dissipation ($E_{dis}$): Based on a viscoelastic hydration-force model, they derived an explicit expression for energy dissipation.
  • Comparing experimental data with theoretical predictions: This allowed them to validate their model and extract key parameters.
  • Varying relative humidity (RH): This was crucial for understanding how the hydration layer's properties change with water availability.

A key innovation is the use of a flattened tip, which provides a large interaction area (~120 nm²) compared to sharp tips. This allows for probing the HWL over a wider surface, revealing its long-range effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements obtained using the described AFM setup under controlled humidity conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Long-Range Hydration: The most striking finding is that the hydration water layer on hydrophilic surfaces extends significantly further than previously believed, up to ~3.5 nm (approximately 12 water layers). This challenges earlier assumptions that HWLs are only a few molecular layers thick.
  • Energy Dissipation as a Probe: Energy dissipation ($E_{dis}$) proves to be a more sensitive indicator of HWL extent than elasticity or damping alone. It allows for a clearer determination of the HWL's dominant region.
  • HWL Thickness Determination: By analyzing the energy dissipation, the researchers could unambiguously determine the HWL thickness to be around 6 layers of water molecules on each surface (tip and substrate).
  • Humidity Dependence and Collapse: While the HWL is present across a range of RH, at lower RH, the attractive Laplace pressure (due to capillary forces) becomes dominant, causing the "weakly bound" layers of the HWL to collapse. Only the "tightly bound" layers remain at very short distances.
  • Implications for Nanoscale Phenomena: The long-range nature of HWL suggests it plays a significant role in phenomena like friction, adhesion, and self-assembly of nanoparticles, especially in ambient conditions where capillary forces are also present.

Key Results

  • The average dissipation energy of nanoconfined HWL was measured to be approximately 1 eV at a tapping amplitude of ~0.1 nm.
  • The HWL was found to extend up to ~3.5 nm at high RH (66-76%), corresponding to about 12 water layers in total. This implies ~6 layers per surface.
  • At lower RH (< 34%), the HWL's effective range was reduced to ~2.5 nm due to the dominance of Laplace pressure.
  • The experimental energy dissipation data showed excellent agreement with their derived theoretical model, validating the viscoelastic hydration-force model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Tip Geometry: While the flattened tip is a significant improvement, the SEM image of the flattened tip doesn't provide nanometric details of its roughness. However, the authors infer it's atomically flat based on previous measurements.
  • Complexity of Interplay: The paper acknowledges that the interplay between HWL and capillary forces is complex, especially in the intermediate region where both contribute. Further investigation into this interplay is suggested.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest their findings provide crucial insights for understanding nanoparticle self-assembly, friction, and collision in nanoscale systems. They highlight the importance of considering the long-range HWL interaction, especially when particle sizes approach the nanometer scale. The study also opens avenues for exploring HWL behavior on different types of surfaces and in various liquid environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The hydration water layer (HWL), a ubiquitous form of water on the hydrophilic surfaces, exhibits anomalous characteristics different from bulk water and plays an important role in interfacial interactions. Despite extensive studies on the mechanical properties of HWL, one still lacks holistic understanding of its energy dissipation, which is critical to characterization of viscoelastic materials as well as identification of nanoscale dissipation processes. Here we address energy dissipation of nanoconfined HWL between two atomically flat hydrophilic solid surfaces (area of ~120 nm(2)) by small amplitude-modulation, noncontact atomic force microscopy. Based on the viscoelastic hydration-force model, the average dissipation energy is ~1 eV at the tapping amplitude (~0.1 nm) of the tip. In particular, we determine the accurate HWL thickness of ~6 layers of water molecules, as similarly observed on biological surfaces. Such a long-range interaction of HWL should be considered in the nanoscale phenomena such as friction, collision and self-assembly.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2014energy,
  author = {Bongsu Kim and Soyoung Kwon and Hyosik Mun and Sangmin An and Wonho Jhe},
  title = {{Energy dissipation of nanoconfined hydration layer: Long-range hydration on the hydrophilic solid surface}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1038/srep06499},
}
Figure