TL;DR
This paper investigates the energy efficiency of two strategies for increasing LTE network capacity: deploying more macro/micro base stations or enabling user-deployed femto base stations. Contrary to previous research, the study finds that macro-micro deployment can be as, or even more, energy efficient than femto deployment, especially when considering the total societal energy cost.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As mobile data traffic explodes, so does the energy consumption of cellular networks, leading to increased operational costs, environmental concerns, and a strain on global energy resources. To meet this demand, operators are exploring ways to boost network capacity. One promising approach is the deployment of femto base stations – small, low-power, user-installed devices that can supplement macro network coverage. Previous studies suggested that femto deployments offer significant energy savings compared to simply adding more macro or micro base stations. However, these studies often used simplified models that neglected crucial factors like network coverage constraints and detailed physical and traffic layer specifications. This paper aims to provide a more realistic comparison by evaluating the energy consumption of macro-micro versus femto deployments in a plausible LTE network scenario, considering these overlooked aspects.
Methods
The authors employ a detailed simulation-based approach to compare two capacity-adding strategies:
- Macro-micro deployment: Operators deploy additional, redundant macro and micro base stations in areas with high traffic.
- Femto deployment: Publicly accessible femto base stations are deployed by home users to augment the macro network.
The simulation models a realistic LTE deployment in a mid-size metropolitan area, incorporating:
- Realistic network topology: Based on operator data, including macro, micro, and femto base stations.
- Detailed physical and traffic layer models: Accounting for signal propagation, interference, traffic types (web and video), and user association policies to ensure quality of service.
- Heterogeneous devices: Modeling different energy profiles for base stations and mobile terminals.
- Energy consumption models: Capturing the dependency of power consumption on immediate traffic load, with different "energy proportionality" levels for devices.
Key metrics used for comparison include operator energy consumption, total societal energy consumption, and energy consumption per unit of network capacity, all normalized by the network's maximum achievable traffic intensity (capacity).
Datasets
The study utilizes operator trace files containing real-world traffic data to model session arrivals, types, and serving sectors. This data is used to replicate session-arrival sequences and inform traffic modeling. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing operator data was used to build a realistic simulation environment.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Femto vs. Macro-Micro: No Clear Winner for Operators: Contrary to prior research, this study found no significant difference in operator energy consumption between macro-micro and femto deployment strategies. This suggests that operators might not gain a substantial energy advantage by solely relying on femto deployments.
- Societal Energy Cost Favors Macro-Micro: When considering the total energy consumption (including mobile terminals and the entire network infrastructure), macro-micro deployment can be more energy efficient in some scenarios. This highlights the importance of a holistic, societal perspective on energy efficiency.
- Femto's Limited Impact on Mobile Terminals: While femto deployments do positively affect mobile terminal energy consumption (due to better signal quality), the effect is not significantly larger than that of macro-micro deployments.
- Energy Proportionality is Key: The potential for energy savings by making macro and micro base stations more "energy proportional" (i.e., their power consumption scales more directly with traffic load) is much higher than the savings achievable through femto deployment alone. This suggests that investing in more efficient hardware might be more impactful than solely focusing on deployment strategies.
- Linearity Assumption Challenged: The study notes that the linear relationship between the number of deployed femto base stations and the number of served sessions, assumed in some prior work, holds only for low penetrations. At higher penetrations, this relationship becomes sub-linear.
Key Results
- Capacity Gain: Both macro-micro deployment (adding class B base stations) and the deployment of 300 femto base stations provided a similar capacity increase (around 19% improvement).
- Operator Energy Consumption (Eo): For the scenarios studied, the difference in operator energy consumption between macro-micro and femto deployments was less than 7%, and often negligible.
- Operator Energy per Unit Capacity (Eco): Femto deployment showed a slight advantage (around 7% more efficient) in Eco, but this was deemed negligible given other factors.
- Total Energy per Unit Capacity (Ect): In some cases, macro-micro deployment was found to be more energy efficient from a societal perspective. The gain from femto deployment was only significant in highly energy-proportional (and likely unrealistic) energy models.
- Mobile Terminal Energy: The difference in mobile terminal energy consumption between the two strategies was not significant.
Limitations and Future Work
- 2D Model Constraint: The 2D simulation model limited the number of femto base stations that could be realistically deployed, preventing the study of very high penetration scenarios. A 3D model would allow for more femto cells.
- Uplink Traffic Ignored: The study focused primarily on downlink traffic, assuming uplink traffic was of secondary importance. Future work should incorporate uplink traffic.
- Static Users: Users were modeled as static, meaning the effects of inter-cell handovers were not considered. Incorporating realistic mobility models is a key area for future research.
- Joint Deployment: The paper did not consider the joint deployment of class B and femto base stations, focusing on comparing each strategy individually.
- On/Off Strategies: While mentioned as a potential for further energy savings, the study did not fully explore the impact of on/off scheduling for femto base stations.
- Adaptive Power Control and Cooperation: The study did not consider advanced techniques like adaptive power control or base station cooperation, which could further enhance energy efficiency and capacity.
Summary updated