Endothelial heparan sulfate is necessary but not sufficient for control of vascular smooth muscle cell growth

David S. Ettenson, Edward W.y. Koo, James L. Januzzi, Elazer R. EdelmanJournal of Cellular Physiology 2000 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while endothelial cells (ECs) consistently produce heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPGs) that inhibit vascular smooth muscle cell (vSMC) growth, the overall effect of EC-conditioned medium on vSMC proliferation depends on non-proteoglycan (non-PG) proteins. These non-PG proteins, whose nature varies with EC density, interact with HSPGs to either enhance inhibition (from postconfluent ECs) or promote stimulation (from subconfluent ECs), explaining the density-dependent regulation of vSMC growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The arterial wall's health relies on a delicate balance between endothelial cells (ECs) and underlying vascular smooth muscle cells (vSMCs). In a healthy state, ECs maintain vSMCs in a quiescent growth phase. However, injury to the endothelium, such as during angioplasty, can disrupt this balance, leading to vSMC migration, proliferation, and the development of intimal hyperplasia, a key factor in restenosis. Previous research identified heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPGs) produced by ECs as crucial inhibitors of vSMC growth. However, a puzzling observation was that conditioned medium from subconfluent ECs, despite producing HSPGs, paradoxically stimulated vSMC growth, unlike the inhibitory effect of medium from postconfluent ECs. This raised questions about whether the HSPGs themselves were different, or if other factors were at play. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by investigating the roles of both HSPGs and other components in EC-conditioned medium in regulating vSMC growth.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of cell culture techniques and biochemical analyses.

  • Cell Culture: Bovine aortic endothelial cells (ECs) and vascular smooth muscle cells (vSMCs) were cultured under different density conditions (subconfluent vs. postconfluent).
  • Conditioned Medium Collection: ECs were cultured to achieve either subconfluent or postconfluent states, and their secreted medium was collected. Some cultures were metabolically labeled with 35S to track proteoglycan production.
  • Fractionation: Conditioned medium was separated into proteoglycan (PG) and non-proteoglycan (non-PG) fractions using anion-exchange chromatography (Source 30Q column). This technique separates molecules based on their charge.
  • Biochemical Characterization:
    • Enzymatic Digestion: Fractions were treated with specific enzymes (heparinase/heparitinase I, chondroitinase ABC) to identify the type of glycosaminoglycan (GAG) side chains present in the proteoglycans.
  • Protein Digestion: Fractions were treated with proteinase K or heat to assess the role of proteins in their biological activity.
  • GAG Quantification: The dimethylmethylene blue (DMB) assay was used to quantify total GAGs and specifically heparan sulfate.
  • vSMC Growth Assay: The biological activity of the conditioned medium and its fractions was tested by adding them to serum-starved vSMCs and measuring vSMC proliferation after 3 days.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from cell cultures and biochemical assays.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HSPGs are Consistently Inhibitory: A key finding is that HSPGs produced by ECs are inhibitory to vSMC growth, regardless of whether the ECs are subconfluent or postconfluent. This challenges the idea that subconfluent ECs produce a different, non-inhibitory form of HSPG.
  • Non-PG Proteins are the Key Modulators: The density-dependent switch between vSMC stimulation and inhibition is driven by the non-proteoglycan (non-PG) protein fraction of the conditioned medium.
  • Synergistic Interaction: The full stimulatory or inhibitory effects are only achieved when non-PG proteins and HSPGs are present together. HSPGs alone are insufficient to achieve the maximal effects seen with unfractionated conditioned medium.
  • Density-Dependent Non-PG Proteins: The nature of the non-PG proteins differs between subconfluent and postconfluent ECs, leading to their distinct effects when combined with HSPGs. Postconfluent non-PG proteins enhance HSPG's inhibitory action, while subconfluent non-PG proteins promote HSPG's stimulatory potential.
  • Complex Regulatory Mechanism: This suggests a sophisticated autocrine/paracrine regulatory system where ECs fine-tune vSMC behavior through the dynamic interaction of HSPGs with density-dependent non-PG proteins.

Key Results

  • Subconfluent EC-CM Stimulates vSMC Growth: Conditioned medium from subconfluent ECs stimulated vSMC growth by approximately 2.5-fold.
  • Postconfluent EC-CM Inhibits vSMC Growth: Conditioned medium from postconfluent ECs inhibited vSMC growth by approximately 2.6-fold.
  • HSPG Fractions are Similarly Inhibitory: When isolated, the proteoglycan (HSPG) fractions from both subconfluent and postconfluent EC-conditioned media inhibited vSMC proliferation by about 32%.
  • Non-PG Proteins Alone Have No Effect: The non-PG protein fractions, when added alone, had no significant effect on vSMC growth.
  • Combination Restores Full Effect:
    • Mixing postconfluent non-PG fractions with HSPG fractions (from either density) resulted in maximal inhibition, comparable to unfractionated postconfluent EC-CM.
  • Mixing subconfluent non-PG fractions with HSPG fractions (from either density) resulted in maximal stimulation, comparable to unfractionated subconfluent EC-CM.
  • Protein Nature of Non-PG Activity: The activity of the non-PG fractions was abolished by proteinase K or heat treatment, confirming their proteinaceous nature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Identity of Non-PG Proteins: The paper acknowledges that the precise identity of the crucial non-PG proteins responsible for modulating HSPG activity is still unknown and is a subject of ongoing research.
  • Clinical Translation: While the findings offer a deeper understanding of vascular homeostasis and injury, the authors suggest that identifying these non-PG proteins could lead to clinical applications for preventing restenosis. This might involve developing therapies that deliver these compounds, potentially in combination with HSPGs, to manage vascular injury.
  • Mechanism of Interaction: The exact molecular mechanisms by which non-PG proteins interact with HSPGs to mediate stimulation or inhibition are complex and warrant further investigation. The authors speculate on potential interactions with growth factors like TGF-β.

Summary updated

Abstract

The state of the endothelial cell (EC) determines the nature of its control of vascular smooth muscle cell (vSMC) biology. Conditioned medium from postconfluent ECs inhibits vSMC proliferation, whereas subconfluent conditioned medium from the same ECs has a stimulatory effect. We and others have identified confluent endothelial cells' production of heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG) as critical to vSMC growth control. The question that arises is whether the stimulation that is observed with subconfluent cells is from (1) aberrant HSPG production, (2) elaboration of noninhibitory species of HSPG, or (3) production of other factors, such as mitogens, which counteract the inhibitory HSPG to stimulate vSMCs. We studied the relative effects of conditioned medium produced by both subconfluent and postconfluent EC cultures on vSMC growth. Conditioned medium was fractionated into nonproteoglycan (non-PG) and proteoglycan (PG) components by anion-exchange chromatography. The PG fractionation profile and the antiproliferative activity of the HSPGs isolated from both subconfluent and postconfluent EC-conditioned media were similar. However, the HSPG fraction alone could not approach the inhibitory potential of unfractionated conditioned medium from postconfluent EC cultures. Non-PG proteins produced by the endothelial cultures had no effect on vSMC growth on their own. Yet, when they were mixed together with HSPG fractions, from either subconfluent or postconfluent EC cultures, the full growth effects were returned. Non-PG protein fractions from postconfluent cultures with HSPG fractions gave maximal inhibition of vSMC growth, whereas non-PG protein fractions from subconfluent EC cultures with HSPG fractions produced the maximal stimulation. Thus, whereas the net stimulatory or inhibitory effect on vSMC growth of EC-conditioned medium is density dependent, this effect does not result from a difference in the antiproliferative heparan sulfate component but rather from non-PG proteins that interact with the heparan sulfates.
BibTeX
@article{ettenson2000endothelial,
  author = {David S. Ettenson and Edward W.Y. Koo and James L. Januzzi and Elazer R. Edelman},
  title = {{Endothelial heparan sulfate is necessary but not sufficient for control of vascular smooth muscle cell growth}},
  journal = {Journal of Cellular Physiology},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.1002/(sici)1097-4652(200007)184:1<93::aid-jcp10>3.0.co;2-h},
}

Loading related content...

Figure