End-to-End Modelling and Simulation of NLOS Sub-6 GHz Backhaul via Diffraction for Internet Connectivity of Rural Areas

Muneer M. Al-Zu'bi, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Open J. Commun. Soc 2023 · DOI

This paper, published in the IEEE Open Journal of the Communications Society, provides a roadmap for bringing high-speed internet to the world’s most isolated regions by rethinking how we model wireless signals.

TL;DR

Researchers demonstrate that "bending" wireless signals over hills (diffraction) is a viable, low-cost alternative to expensive Line-of-Sight towers for rural internet. By identifying that industry-standard propagation models are surprisingly inaccurate for this use case, they propose a "rounded-obstacle" model that predicts performance with near-perfect accuracy, proving that 100+ Mbps speeds are achievable over 11 km without a clear line of sight.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Connecting the "next billion" people to the internet is largely a geography and economics problem. In rural areas, the traditional "rule of thumb" for microwave backhaul is that you must have a clear Line-of-Sight (LOS) between antennas. If a mountain or hill is in the way, engineers typically build massive towers or intermediate repeater stations—both of which are prohibitively expensive for low-income, sparsely populated regions.

The authors ask: Can we skip the repeaters and just use Non-Line-of-Sight (NLOS) links by exploiting diffraction? Diffraction occurs when electromagnetic waves hit an obstacle and "bend" into the shadow region. While this is known to happen, the industry lacked a validated, end-to-end framework to prove that these "bent" signals could actually carry the high-bandwidth data required for modern internet connectivity.

Methods

The study is divided into two major phases: model validation and end-to-end simulation.

  1. Model Comparison: The authors compared several terrain-based propagation models, including the industry-standard Irregular Terrain Model (ITM/Longley-Rice), the Terrain Integrated Rough Earth Model (TIREM™), and various Knife-Edge Diffraction models.
  2. The "Rounded-Obstacle" Approach: They implemented an improved model in MATLAB based on Recommendation ITU-R P.526. Unlike a simple "knife-edge" model that treats a hill like a paper-thin sheet, this model accounts for the physical radius of curvature of the hilltop.
  3. End-to-End Simulation: Using the IEEE 802.11ac (Wi-Fi 5) standard as a baseline, they simulated a full communication chain—from data encoding and modulation (up to 256-QAM) to signal amplification and reception—using the technical specifications of commercial-grade hardware (Cambium PTP550E).

Datasets

  • Terrain Data: The study utilized the SRTM (Shuttle Radar Topography Mission) 1 arc-second global Digital Elevation Model (DEM), which provides 30-meter resolution elevation data.
  • Validation Data: To check their math, the authors used real-world measured diffraction loss data from five distinct rural sites in Spain, where 5.8 GHz links were tested over single dominant blocking obstacles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Pessimism" of Standard Models: The most striking finding is that the ITM (Longley-Rice) model—the "gold standard" in many RF planning tools—is terrible for this specific scenario. It overestimated signal loss by an average of 24 dB. In practical terms, an engineer using ITM would wrongly conclude that a link is impossible, when it is actually quite functional.
  • Curvature Matters: Treating a hill as a "rounded obstacle" rather than a sharp "knife-edge" is the key to accuracy. The rounded model’s predictions matched real-world measurements with a negligible average error of only -0.01 dB.
  • Viability of Sub-6 GHz: While the industry is chasing millimeter-wave (5G) speeds, this paper highlights that the 5.8 GHz band is the "sweet spot" for rural areas. It’s high enough for good bandwidth but low enough to diffract effectively over terrain.

Key Results

  • Model Accuracy: The rounded-obstacle model achieved an RMSE of 2.7 dB, compared to 23-24 dB for ITM-based software.
  • Throughput: Simulations showed that an 11 km NLOS link can reliably deliver 100 to 175 Mbps. This is more than enough to provide high-quality internet to a small village or remote industrial site.
  • Reliability: The Packet Error Rate (PER) remained between 0 and 0.1, well within the acceptable limits for the IEEE 802.11ac standard.
  • Antenna Height: Increasing antenna height from 5m to 20m reduced diffraction loss and improved the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) by about 3.25 dB on average, offering a clear trade-off between tower cost and performance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current work focuses on a single dominant obstacle (one big hill). Real-world terrain can be more complex, with multiple obstacles or heavy foliage that adds "clutter loss."

Future research directions include:

  • Testing the feasibility of NLOS links at higher frequencies (above 6 GHz).
  • Evaluating performance over longer distances.
  • Incorporating interference modeling from other nearby wireless systems, which might be more prevalent as these rural networks grow.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{alzubi2023end,
  author = {Muneer M. Al-Zu'bi and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{End-to-End Modelling and Simulation of NLOS Sub-6 GHz Backhaul via Diffraction for Internet Connectivity of Rural Areas}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/ojcoms.2023.3330078},
}
Figure