TL;DR
This paper explores how "encountering product information" – seeing unexpected but relevant product suggestions – can positively influence planned purchases by sparking customer inspiration. It finds that this effect is amplified when recommendation systems offer low explainability, encouraging deeper user engagement and decision-making.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In the realm of e-commerce, recommendation systems have traditionally focused on "precision prediction" to show users exactly what they're looking for. However, this can lead to a "filter bubble" and decision paralysis due to an overwhelming number of similar options. This paper addresses the challenge of how to leverage "information encountering" (IE) – the serendipitous discovery of unexpected information – to enhance the customer experience and drive purchasing decisions, particularly for planned purchases. While previous research has touched on how unexpected encounters can lead to impulse buys, this study specifically investigates their impact on planned purchases and the underlying psychological mechanisms.
Methods
The researchers conducted three experimental studies to investigate their hypotheses.
- Study 1: A between-groups experiment simulated a realistic purchasing scenario to establish the main effect of encountering product information (EPI) on focal product purchase intention. Participants were either shown relevant learning machines (control) or learning machines plus unexpected but related products from their past browsing/purchase history.
- Study 2: This study aimed to confirm the mediating role of customer inspiration and rule out novelty as an alternative explanation. It used a between-groups design where participants browsed simulated e-commerce pages. Decision-making time was recorded to measure purchase delay (an indicator of purchase intention), and measures for customer inspiration and novelty were collected.
- Study 3: This experiment investigated the moderating role of "explainability" in recommender systems. Participants were exposed to encountering product information under conditions of either high or low explainability (e.g., "Recommended for you" vs. "Recommended for you based on your browsing history"). This study examined the impact on customer inspiration and purchase intention.
Datasets
The studies did not use pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, they relied on:
- Simulated e-commerce scenarios: Participants were directed to browse simulated e-commerce platform pages.
- Participant-generated data: In Study 1, participants submitted their own past browsing or purchase history to personalize the "encountering product information."
- Behavioral tracking: Camtasia Studio software was used to record participants' browsing and decision-making times.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Serendipity for Planned Purchases: Contrary to a focus on impulse buys, encountering unexpected but relevant product information can actually help customers make planned purchases more efficiently. It acts as a "flash of insight" that clarifies choices.
- Customer Inspiration is Key: The positive effect of encountering product information on planned purchases is mediated by "customer inspiration." This means that seeing these unexpected items sparks creativity and new ideas, which then drives the purchase decision.
- Low Explainability Boosts Inspiration: Recommendation systems that are less transparent about why they are showing certain products (low explainability) are more effective at generating customer inspiration. This encourages users to think more deeply and make connections, rather than passively accepting a recommendation.
- Beyond Novelty: While encountering unexpected items can create a sense of novelty, this novelty itself doesn't drive the purchase decision. It's the inspiration sparked by the unexpectedness that matters.
Key Results
- Study 1: Encountering product information significantly increased focal product purchase intention compared to not encountering it.
- Study 2: Participants exposed to encountering product information significantly reduced their decision-making time (indicating faster purchase decisions). Customer inspiration was found to be a significant negative mediator for decision-making delays. Novelty did not act as a significant mediator.
- Study 3: A low degree of explainability in recommender systems amplified the positive impact of encountering product information on both customer inspiration and focal product purchase intention, especially in an "information encountering" (IE) context. Specifically, purchase intention was significantly higher with low explainability in the IE condition.
Limitations and Future Work
- Planned vs. Unplanned Consumption: The study primarily focused on planned purchases. Future research could explore how encountering product information influences the decision between planned and unplanned purchases, and how the content of the encountered information interacts with these decisions.
- Additional Mediating Mechanisms: While customer inspiration was identified as a mediator, other mechanisms might also play a role, such as how encountering information helps customers identify desired products more efficiently or reject competing ones faster.
- Diverse Sources of Encountering Information: The study focused on algorithm-generated encountering information. Future work could investigate the impact of information encountered from user profiles or social sharing, which are becoming increasingly common.
- Customer Protection: While the study highlights benefits for platforms, encountering information can also enhance customer protection by breaking free from filter bubbles and expanding horizons.
Summary updated