Abstract
We show that memory can be encoded in a model amorphous solid subjected to athermal oscillatory shear deformations, and in an analogous spin model with disordered interactions, sharing the feature of a deformable energy landscape. When these systems are subjected to oscillatory shear deformation, they retain memory of the deformation amplitude imposed in the training phase, when the amplitude is below a "localization" threshold. Remarkably, multiple persistent memories can be stored using such an athermal, noise-free, protocol. The possibility of such memory is shown to be linked to the presence of plastic deformations and associated limit cycles traversed by the system, which exhibit avalanche statistics also seen in related contexts.
Introduction
In classical physics, equilibrium systems are fundamentally "forgetful"—their current state is determined by thermodynamic variables, not their history. In contrast, non-equilibrium systems such as glasses, foams, and granular materials possess the capacity to retain "memory" of past stresses or deformations. While previous research on dilute non-Brownian suspensions demonstrated memory of a single deformation amplitude, these systems typically required external noise to store multiple memories, as larger amplitudes would otherwise erase smaller ones. This study investigates whether dense amorphous solids, characterized by complex energy landscapes, can store multiple persistent memories without such external noise.
Methodology
The researchers utilized two primary computational models to explore memory effects:
- Binary Mixture Lennard-Jones (BMLJ) Model: A standard representation of an amorphous solid consisting of 4,000 particles. Simulations employed Athermal-Quasi-Static (AQS) deformation, where the material is sheared in infinitesimal steps and energy is minimized at each step, effectively simulating behavior at absolute zero temperature.
- NK Model: A disordered spin model with $N$ spins and $K$ interactions, providing a generalized framework to test if memory is a universal property of disordered energy landscapes.
The experimental protocol consisted of a Training Phase, where the system underwent multiple cycles of oscillatory shear at a specific amplitude ($\gamma_{train}$), followed by a Reading Phase. In the reading phase, a single test cycle was applied at varying amplitudes ($\gamma$), and the Mean Squared Displacement (MSD) of particles was measured to detect signatures of the training history.
Mechanisms of Memory: Limit Cycles and Energy Landscapes
The ability of dense solids to "remember" is rooted in their navigation of a rugged potential energy landscape. Unlike simple systems where reversibility implies following the exact same path back and forth, dense solids achieve reversibility through limit cycles. During a shear cycle, particles undergo permanent "plastic" rearrangements. However, after training, these rearrangements become periodic; the system returns to its exact starting configuration at the end of each cycle.
As shown in Figure 2, the energy changes ($\Delta E$) during a cycle reveal the formation of these stable orbits. Training "sculpts" the landscape, guiding the system into a specific periodic path. This process is accompanied by "avalanches"—clusters of particle rearrangements whose sizes follow a power-law distribution, a characteristic shared with other disordered systems like magnetic materials and seismic faults.
Key Results: The Signature of Memory
The primary indicator of encoded memory is a distinct "kink" in the MSD curve. When the test amplitude $\gamma$ matches the training amplitude $\gamma_{train}$, the MSD remains near zero, indicating the system has returned to its trained state. Once the test amplitude exceeds $\gamma_{train}$, the MSD increases sharply as the system encounters new regions of the energy landscape it has not yet explored.
Crucially, these dense systems can store multiple memories simultaneously. Because different amplitudes can trigger distinct sets of plastic events that do not necessarily interfere, a smaller memory is not automatically erased by a larger one. This persistence without the need for added noise distinguishes dense amorphous solids from their dilute counterparts.
Discussion and Future Outlook
While this study provides a robust framework for understanding memory in athermal disordered systems, several challenges remain. The current "reading" protocol is destructive; once the material is sheared past its training amplitude to identify the kink, the original memory state is altered. Future work must focus on developing non-destructive reading methods. Additionally, extending these findings to finite temperatures is essential, as thermal fluctuations may eventually degrade the stability of encoded memories. Finally, the parallels between structural amorphous solids and disordered spin systems suggest that similar memory effects could be exploited in magnetic materials, potentially opening new avenues for information storage in complex media.
Summary updated