Enabling SDN Experimentation with Wired and Wireless Resources: The SmartFIRE Facility

Kostas Choumas, Thanasis Korakis, Hyunwoo Lee, Donghyun Kim, Junho Suh, Ted Taekyoung Kwon, Pedro Martinez-Julia, Antonio F. Skarmeta, Taewan You, Loïc Baron, Serge Fdida, JongWon KimCloudcomp 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

The SmartFIRE project tackles the challenge of conducting complex network experiments that span diverse technologies like SDN, wired, and wireless networks. They've built an intercontinental federation of testbeds, SmartFIRE, that allows researchers to seamlessly access and combine these resources, paving the way for novel network architecture experimentation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern network research often requires experimenting with a combination of different network technologies. For instance, testing a new Software-Defined Networking (SDN) approach might involve not only programmable switches but also wireless access points and cloud infrastructure. However, existing experimentation platforms, or "testbeds," are typically specialized, focusing on either wired, wireless, or cloud environments. This fragmentation makes it difficult and time-consuming for researchers to set up experiments that span these different domains. The SmartFIRE project aims to bridge this gap by creating a federated infrastructure that integrates multiple specialized testbeds, allowing for seamless, intercontinental experimentation across these diverse networking fields.

Methods

The core of SmartFIRE is its federation framework, which integrates various existing testbeds. This framework leverages the Slice-based Facility Architecture (SFA), a standard approach for managing resources in federated environments. SFA uses the concept of a "slice" as the fundamental unit for mapping experimenters to resources, enabling different administrative domains to federate their resources without losing control.

To manage these federated resources, SmartFIRE employs SFA Aggregate Managers (AMs) for each testbed. These AMs translate SFA calls into testbed-specific commands via drivers. For instance, an OpenStack driver was developed to integrate cloud resources.

For experiment control and automation, SmartFIRE extends the Experiment Controller (EC) and Resource Controllers (RCs) from the OMF (Experiment Control: OMF) framework. OMF is a widely adopted tool for automating experiments, allowing users to describe network topologies and applications in a declarative language (OMF Experiment Description Language - OEDL). The EC orchestrates experiment execution by sending messages to RCs, which then control the underlying physical or logical resources. The OMF Measurement Library (OML) is used for collecting experimental data.

SmartFIRE also focuses on specific experimentation capabilities:

  • Information-Centric Networking (ICN) experimentation: This involves integrating wireless and SDN technologies to enable content retrieval based on content identifiers rather than location. They've developed an ICN-OMF framework that extends OMF to manage globally dispersed ICN nodes.
  • MOFI (Mobile Oriented Future Internet) experimentation: This focuses on identity-based network architectures for mobile environments. SmartFIRE orchestrates MOFI experimentation using the OMF framework.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the infrastructure and framework for experimentation rather than specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Federation is key to unlocking complex network research: The paper highlights that the real power comes from combining diverse resources. SmartFIRE's success lies in its ability to knit together disparate testbeds into a cohesive whole.
  • SFA provides a flexible and scalable foundation: The adoption of SFA demonstrates its effectiveness in enabling inter-domain resource sharing while maintaining administrative control.
  • OMF's extensibility is crucial: The paper emphasizes how extending OMF allows for sophisticated control and automation of experiments across heterogeneous and geographically distributed testbeds.
  • Enabling novel architectures: By providing access to integrated wired, wireless, and SDN resources, SmartFIRE directly supports research into emerging network paradigms like ICN and MOFI.
  • Intercontinental reach matters: The federation spans Europe and South Korea, enabling global-scale experimentation that was previously difficult to achieve.

Key Results

The paper presents SmartFIRE as a functional intercontinental federation of SDN, wireless, and cloud testbeds. It demonstrates the ability to orchestrate experiments across these heterogeneous resources. Specific use cases are mentioned, including ICN experimentation leveraging wireless and SDN, and MOFI experimentation. The paper highlights the successful integration of various testbeds (e.g., UTH's NITOS, SNU's ICN testbed, ETRI's MOFI testbed, KAIST's OpenWiFi+) into the SmartFIRE framework.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability and performance: While the paper describes the framework, detailed quantitative results on the scalability and performance of the federated system under heavy load are not extensively presented.
  • Complexity of federation: Managing a federation of diverse testbeds inherently involves complexities in terms of interoperability, security, and resource allocation. The paper touches upon these but doesn't delve into all the challenges.
  • Further development of OMF extensions: The paper mentions ongoing work on OMF and OML extensions for SmartFIRE objectives, suggesting that further refinement and feature additions are planned.
  • Broader adoption of new architectures: The success of SmartFIRE will ultimately depend on its adoption by the research community for conducting experiments on novel architectures like ICN and MOFI. Future work will likely involve showcasing more diverse and impactful use cases.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{choumas2015enabling,
  author = {Kostas Choumas and Thanasis Korakis and Hyunwoo Lee and Donghyun Kim and Junho Suh and Ted Taekyoung Kwon and Pedro Martinez-Julia and Antonio F. Skarmeta and Taewan You and Loïc Baron and Serge Fdida and JongWon Kim},
  title = {{Enabling SDN Experimentation with Wired and Wireless Resources: The SmartFIRE Facility}},
  booktitle = {Cloudcomp},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-38904-2\_29},
}
Figure