Enablers of Physician Prescription of a Long-Term Asthma Controller in Patients with Persistent Asthma

Francine M. Ducharme, Alexandrine J. Lamontagne, Lucie Blais, Roland Grad, Kim Lavoie, Simon Bacon, Martha L. McKinney, Eve Desplats, Pierre ErnstCanadian 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study surveyed Quebec physicians to understand what encourages them to prescribe long-term asthma controller medications for patients with persistent asthma. The findings highlight that physicians are generally willing to prescribe these controllers, and their intention is driven by recognizing persistent symptoms, aiming for long-term control, and feeling comfortable initiating treatment. Key enablers for improved prescription include better training, decision-support tools, and resources that boost patient adherence and physician confidence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Asthma management guidelines emphasize guided self-management, which includes prescribing long-term controller medications for persistent asthma. However, studies show that a significant portion of patients with persistent asthma do not use these medications daily, leading to frequent exacerbations and preventable hospitalizations. While patient factors play a role, physician behavior is also a critical component. Previous research has identified barriers to guideline adherence, but few have specifically focused on the enablers – the factors that facilitate the prescription of long-term asthma controllers, particularly inhaled corticosteroids (ICS). This paper aims to fill that gap by identifying what motivates physicians to prescribe these essential medications and what resources they believe would help them do so more effectively.

Methods

The researchers conducted a mailed survey of randomly selected physicians in Quebec. The survey included a 102-item questionnaire that presented physicians with one of four clinical vignettes depicting a poorly controlled adult or child with asthma. Physicians were asked about their intended management for the patient in the vignette and their endorsement of various enablers for prescribing long-term controllers. The study employed a stratified sampling procedure based on physician specialty (family medicine, pediatrics, emergency medicine) to ensure representation. Statistical analyses included bivariate and multivariate logistic regression to identify determinants of physician intention to prescribe long-term ICS.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a custom-designed questionnaire administered to a sample of Quebec physicians.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physician Willingness is High, but Nuance Exists: A large majority of physicians (86%) indicated they would prescribe a long-term controller for the hypothetical patient, suggesting a general alignment with guidelines. However, the determinants of this intention reveal important psychological and practical factors at play.
  • Beyond Just Symptoms: The Importance of Goals and Comfort: The strongest predictors of prescribing intention were not just recognizing persistent symptoms, but also having a clear goal of achieving long-term control and, crucially, feeling comfortable initiating long-term ICS therapy. This suggests that interventions need to address both clinical recognition and physician confidence.
  • A Multifaceted Approach to Support: Physicians strongly endorsed a range of resources and interventions to support their practice. These fall into several categories:
  • Patient-Centric Resources: Asthma education, lung function testing, and accessible asthma clinics were highly valued for improving patient adherence and physician comfort.
  • Professional Support: Specialist opinions and collaboration with paramedical healthcare professionals (nurses, respiratory therapists) were seen as vital for guiding patients and enhancing physician confidence.
  • Information and Tools: Decision-support tools, pharmacy reports on dispensed medications, and specific training sessions were also highly endorsed, indicating a need for practical aids and knowledge enhancement.
  • The Role of Risk Perception: While comfort in initiating ICS was a key determinant, the study also noted that lower hesitation regarding the risk-benefit ratio of prescribing long-term ICS was inversely related to comfort. This suggests that addressing physician concerns about potential risks is as important as building their confidence.

Key Results

  • High Prescription Intention: 86% of surveyed physicians reported they would prescribe a long-term controller (predominantly ICS) for the patient in their clinical vignette.
  • Key Determinants of Intention:
    • Recognition of persistent symptoms: OR 2.67
    • Goal of achieving long-term control: OR 5.31
    • High comfort level in initiating long-term ICS: OR 2.33
  • Strongly Endorsed Enablers (≥60%): Decision tools, pharmacy reports, reminders, and specific training were highly endorsed to support optimal management.
  • Enablers for Adherence and Comfort: Physicians strongly endorsed asthma education, lung function testing, specialist opinion, accessible asthma clinics, and paramedical healthcare professionals to improve patient adherence and physician comfort with long-term ICS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Overrepresentation of Female Physicians and Shorter Practice Durations: The sample had a slightly higher proportion of female physicians and those in practice for a shorter period, which might mean findings reflect more recent training and guidelines.
  • Social Desirability Bias: Physicians might have reported what they believe is the desired response rather than their actual behavior, potentially overestimating actual ICS use. The study attempted to mitigate this by using a range of response options and reversing question order.
  • Quebec-Specific Context: The study was conducted in Quebec, where there is free access to medical care, subsidized drug plans, and free asthma education. These factors might influence physician behavior and the generalizability of findings to other healthcare systems.
  • Representation of Family Physicians: The study included a large proportion of family physicians, reflecting their significant role in asthma management in Quebec, but this might not be representative of other countries.

Future work should focus on implementing and evaluating interventions based on these identified enablers. This includes developing and testing training programs, decision-support tools, and resource pathways that enhance physician knowledge, skills, and confidence, while also improving patient adherence and physician comfort with long-term ICS prescription. The authors suggest that computerised systems to identify delays in accessing resources could also be a valuable implementation target.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective. We aimed to identify key enablers of physician prescription of a long-term controller in patients with persistent asthma. Methods. We conducted a mailed survey of randomly selected Quebec physicians. We sent a 102-item questionnaire, seeking reported management regarding one of 4 clinical vignettes of a poorly controlled adult or child and endorsement of enablers to prescribe long-term controllers. Results. With a 56% participation rate, 421 physicians participated. Most (86%) would prescribe a long-term controller (predominantly inhaled corticosteroids, ICS) to the patient in their clinical vignette. Determinants of intention were the recognition of persistent symptoms (OR 2.67), goal of achieving long-term control (OR 5.31), and high comfort level in initiating long-term ICS (OR 2.33). Decision tools, pharmacy reports, reminders, and specific training were strongly endorsed by ≥60% physicians to support optimal management. Physicians strongly endorsed asthma education, lung function testing, specialist opinion, accessible asthma clinic, and paramedical healthcare professionals to guide patients, as enablers to improve patient adherence to and physicians' comfort with long-term ICS. Interpretation. Tools and training to improve physician knowledge, skills, and perception towards long-term ICS and resources that increase patient adherence and physician comfort to facilitate long-term ICS prescription should be considered as targets for implementation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ducharme2016enablers,
  author = {Francine M. Ducharme and Alexandrine J. Lamontagne and Lucie Blais and Roland Grad and Kim Lavoie and Simon Bacon and Martha L. McKinney and Eve Desplats and Pierre Ernst},
  title = {{Enablers of Physician Prescription of a Long-Term Asthma Controller in Patients with Persistent Asthma}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1155/2016/4169010},
}
Figure