Empty the Shopping Cart? The Effect of Shopping Cart Item Sorting on Online Shopping Cart Abandonment Behavior

Dan Jiang, Guangling Zhang, Lu WangJ. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the order of items in an online shopping cart affects whether a customer abandons their purchase. They found that sorting items chronologically (ascending order) can reduce abandonment by mitigating choice overload, a key insight for e-commerce platforms aiming to increase conversion rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online shopping cart abandonment is a significant issue for e-commerce businesses, with a substantial percentage of added items never being purchased. While previous research has explored various factors influencing this behavior, there's a notable gap in understanding how the post-decision-making stage, specifically the arrangement of items within the shopping cart itself, impacts abandonment. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the effect of item sorting on abandonment, focusing on the psychological mechanisms of forgetfulness and choice overload.

Methods

The authors employed a mixed-methods approach, combining qualitative interviews with quantitative experiments.

  • Exploratory Study (Study 1): Qualitative interviews were conducted with consumers to understand their shopping cart abandonment behavior and identify potential reasons. This study aimed to establish the universality of the phenomenon and explore initial hypotheses.
  • Laboratory Experiments (Study 2 & 3):
    • Study 2: A between-group experiment manipulated the sorting order of items in a shopping cart (ascending vs. descending by time added) to test its effect on abandonment. It also investigated the mediating roles of forgetfulness and choice overload.
  • Study 3: This experiment further tested the main effect of sorting and the mediating role of choice overload, while also introducing a "target task" vs. "non-target task" condition to explore how goal-directed shopping influences the sorting effect.

The experiments involved participants browsing a simulated online store, adding items to a cart, and then their abandonment behavior was measured. They used established scales to measure choice overload and forgetfulness.

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed as distinct datasets. The studies utilized:

  • Qualitative Interview Data: Collected from 38 participants who had experience with online shopping cart abandonment.
  • Experimental Data: Generated from participants in controlled laboratory settings (Study 2: 108 participants, Study 3: 262 participants) who interacted with simulated online shopping environments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Shopping Cart as a Multifunctional Tool: Consumers increasingly use shopping carts not just for immediate purchase but also for comparison, information collection, and even entertainment, leading to more complex abandonment behaviors.
  • Sorting Matters, Even Post-Decision: The order in which items appear in the shopping cart, even after they've been added, can significantly influence whether a customer completes a purchase.
  • Choice Overload is a Key Mediator: Ascending order sorting (where the most recently added items appear first) appears to reduce choice overload, making it easier for consumers to make a final decision.
  • Forgetfulness is Less Influential (in this context): While forgetfulness is a known factor, the experiments suggest it plays a less significant role as a mediator compared to choice overload in the context of item sorting.
  • Targeted Shopping Amplifies Sorting Effects: When consumers have a specific goal (target task), the sorting order has a more pronounced effect on their purchase intention.

Key Results

  • Main Effect of Sorting (H1): Ascending order sorting (last item added at the top) led to fewer purchases (H1a), while descending order sorting (last item added at the end) led to more purchases (H1b). This was supported by Study 3.
  • Mediating Role of Choice Overload (H2b): Choice overload was found to be a significant mediator in the relationship between item sorting and shopping cart abandonment. Ascending order sorting reduced choice overload, thereby decreasing abandonment. This was supported by Study 2 and Study 3.
  • Mediating Role of Forgetfulness (H2a): The mediating effect of forgetfulness was not supported in the experiments.
  • Moderating Role of Opening Frequency (H3): The moderating effect of shopping cart opening frequency was not established.
  • Target Task vs. Non-Target Task (H4): In the context of targeted shopping, ascending order sorting significantly increased purchase intention compared to descending order. This suggests that for goal-oriented shoppers, a specific sorting order can be more impactful.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Generalizability: Study 2's sample of college students and its small sample size (N=108) limit generalizability. The use of a less popular book website in Study 2 might also affect the intensity of purchase behavior.
  • Experimental Setting vs. Real-World: The number of items used for choice overload manipulation (20) might not accurately reflect the scale of real-world shopping carts. The short recall period (24 hours) in Study 2 might have limited the assessment of forgetfulness.
  • Psychological Ownership: The study did not find support for psychological ownership as a mediator, potentially due to the experimental setup and the nature of online vs. offline shopping carts.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Investigate online and offline integration of shopping carts.
  • Explore more sorting methods beyond chronological order.
  • Conduct A/B tests on e-commerce platforms to validate findings in real-world scenarios.
  • Examine the impact of reduced shopping cart functions or direct checkout flows.
  • Further explore intermediary and adjustment mechanisms for abandonment behavior.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jiang2021empty,
  author = {Dan Jiang and Guangling Zhang and Lu Wang},
  title = {{Empty the Shopping Cart? The Effect of Shopping Cart Item Sorting on Online Shopping Cart Abandonment Behavior}},
  journal = {J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer16060111},
}
Figure