Empowerment or detriment: a study on the impact of ESG rating discrepancies on green investors decision-making

Xinyu Li, Huilin Peng, Keying LongJournal of Applied Economics and Policy Studies 2025 · DOI

This paper, published in the Journal of Applied Economics and Policy Studies (2025), explores the messy world of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) ratings and how their inconsistencies affect investment.

TL;DR

Contrary to the idea that conflicting ESG ratings create "noise" that confuses the market, this study finds that ESG rating discrepancies actually attract green investors. This "information effect" suggests that rating divergence provides a multi-dimensional view of a company’s sustainability, prompting sophisticated investors to dig deeper, especially when corporate transparency is low.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

ESG ratings are notoriously unstandardized. One agency might give a company an "A" for its carbon footprint, while another gives it a "C" because of labor practices. This lack of consensus is known as ESG rating divergence.

Most existing literature views this divergence as a negative—a "noise effect" that increases financing costs and stock volatility. However, the authors of this paper ask a different question: Could this disagreement actually be a signal? For "green investors"—institutional investors who prioritize environmental and social responsibility—does a wide range of ratings provide incremental information that helps them make better decisions, or does it simply drive them away?

Methods

The authors employ a rigorous econometric approach to test their hypothesis:

  • Divergence Measurement: They constructed two indicators of ESG rating divergence ($ESGU1$ and $ESGU2$) based on the standard deviation of standardized rankings across six different rating agencies.
  • Green Investor Identification: They manually screened the "investment goals" and "investment scope" of funds in the CSMAR database for keywords like "environmental protection," "low carbon," and "sustainability" to identify a distinct group of green investors.
  • Regression Analysis: The study uses an OLS (Ordinary Least Squares) model to examine the relationship between rating divergence and the number of green investors, controlling for variables like company size, leverage ($Lev$), and profitability ($ROE$).
  • Robustness Checks: To ensure the results weren't accidental or due to reverse causality, they used:
  • Instrumental Variables (IV): Using lagged ESG divergence.
  • Propensity Score Matching (PSM): Comparing similar companies with high vs. low divergence.
  • Alternative Models: Logit and Tobit regressions to account for the distribution of investor data.

Datasets

The study focuses on the Chinese market, specifically:

  • Sample: A-share listed companies in China from 2009 to 2022 (25,295 observations).
  • ESG Ratings: Data sourced from six major agencies: Bloomberg, Wind, Sino-Securities, FTSE Russell, SynTao Green Finance, and SusallWave (MSCI is also cited as a source).
  • Financial Data: Sourced from the China Stock Market & Accounting Research (CSMAR) database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Information Effect" Wins: The data supports the "information effect" over the "noise effect." Discrepancies between agencies suggest that different raters are capturing different facets of a firm's ESG performance. This diversity of perspective reduces information asymmetry for green investors.
  • The Transparency Paradox: The positive impact of rating divergence is significantly stronger for companies with low information transparency (e.g., those not audited by "Big Four" firms). When a company doesn't disclose much, the disagreement between external raters becomes a vital proxy for understanding the firm's hidden risks and opportunities.
  • The "Underdog" Signal: The effect is more pronounced for companies with lower overall ESG ratings. For high-performing "ESG stars," divergence is often just a minor disagreement over the degree of excellence. For lower-rated firms, divergence can signal "hidden gems" or specific areas of improvement that green investors find attractive.

Key Results

  • Positive Correlation: ESG rating discrepancies significantly increase the entry of green investors. A one-unit increase in ESG rating discrepancy leads to a roughly 16.5% to 23.5% increase in the number of green investors (depending on the model and controls used).
  • Statistical Significance: The results remained robust at the 1% significance level across multiple testing methods, including IV and PSM.
  • Heterogeneity: In the "Low Transparency" group, the coefficient for divergence was 0.203, while it was statistically insignificant for high-transparency firms. Similarly, for "Low ESG" firms, the coefficient was 0.357, compared to a non-significant result for high-ESG firms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Focus: The study is limited to Chinese A-share companies. The "information effect" might behave differently in markets with more mature ESG disclosure mandates (like the EU).
  • The Need for Standardization: While the authors find that divergence can be useful, they still conclude that the lack of unified standards is a problem. They recommend that the government push for a unified ESG disclosure framework to reduce the "cost" of processing these discrepancies.
  • Investor Sophistication: The paper assumes green investors have the "information processing and searching abilities" to handle rating discrepancies. Future research could look at whether individual (retail) investors are similarly "empowered" or if they are instead "detrimented" by the confusion.

Summary updated

Abstract

As global attention to sustainable development increases, ESG evaluation systems have gradually become a key basis for sustainable investment decisions. However, the current indicator systems across different ESG rating agencies remain unstandardized, resulting in significant discrepancies in evaluation outcomes. Against this backdrop, this paper selects A-share listed companies from 2009 to 2022 as the research sample, utilizing ESG rating data from six agenciesBloomberg, Wind, Sino-Securities, FTSE Russell, SynTao Green Finance, and Minglangto construct multiple indicators of ESG rating discrepancies. Focusing on the perspective of ESG rating discrepancies, the study investigates their impact on green investors decision-making. The results show that ESG rating discrepancies can attract green investors, and the economic significance of this effect is evident, indicating the existence of an information effect within ESG discrepancies. Further analysis reveals that the information effect of rating discrepancies is more pronounced when listed companies exhibit lower information transparency and lower ESG rating levels. These findings provide strategies and recommendations for the construction of unified ESG rating standards, corporate sustainable development, and green investment practices.
BibTeX
@article{li2025empowerment,
  author = {Xinyu Li and Huilin Peng and Keying Long},
  title = {{Empowerment or detriment: a study on the impact of ESG rating discrepancies on green investors decision-making}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Economics and Policy Studies},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.54254/2977-5701/2025.23458},
}
Figure