Empirical Research of the Relationship among Customer Satisfaction, Customer Loyalty and Business Performance in Banking Sector——Illustrated by Bank of Chin

Xin Xin, Wenchao Liu, Hong-li BaoAdvances 2014 · DOI

Abstract: Competition is increasing in the Chinese banking industry, and gaining higher customer satisfaction has become the primary focus of competition. Through empirical research, this study finds that Customer Satisfaction (CS) has a positive effect on Customer Loyalty (CL) and bank business performance (BP). Furthermore, CL acts as a partial mediator in the relationship between CS and various dimensions of bank performance.

Introduction

In the early 2010s, the Chinese banking industry faced a dual crisis: a surge of competition from foreign banks entering the market and a growing reputation for poor service. Local banks were often criticized for being overly "official," imposing unreasonable fees, and failing to treat customers as partners. While the theoretical link between "happy customers" and "better business" is widely accepted in Western marketing literature, there has been a lack of empirical evidence specifically within the unique regulatory and cultural context of China’s banking sector. This research seeks to prove that a "customers first" principle is a strategic necessity for survival, not just a platitude.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a three-part theoretical framework to analyze the "service-profit chain" within the Bank of China. The model identifies Customer Satisfaction (CS) as the independent variable, Customer Loyalty (CL) as the intermediary variable, and Business Performance (BP) as the dependent variable.

Conceptual model of the relationship between Customer Satisfaction, Loyalty, and Business Performance.

To measure these variables, the study utilized:

  • CS Index: Based on the China Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) model.
  • CL Metrics: Evaluated through repurchase intention, word-of-mouth reputation, and "premium acceptance" (willingness to pay more).
  • BP Dimensions: A weighted index based on 2006 SASAC guidelines, including profitability (Net Assets Yield), operating capacity (Total Asset Turnover), development ability (Net Profit Growth), and debt-paying ability (Asset-Liability Ratio).

The team performed correlation and regression analyses using a longitudinal dataset covering the years 2003 to 2012, sourced from official annual reports and authoritative financial databases.

Key Results

The empirical analysis confirmed strong positive relationships across the hypothesized paths. Customer Satisfaction showed a very high correlation with Loyalty ($r = 0.825$) and a significant correlation with overall Business Performance ($r = 0.658$).

Regression analysis results for the primary research variables.

As shown in the regression data, the impact of CS on Net Assets Yield (profitability) was particularly strong ($F = 55.065, p = 0.000$), suggesting that happy customers are significantly more profitable for the bank. A critical finding was the mediation effect: in multiple regression analysis, when Loyalty was added as a mediator, the direct effect coefficient of Satisfaction on Business Performance dropped from 0.880 to 0.280. This statistically proves that Loyalty carries much of the "weight" of Satisfaction's impact on the bottom line.

Discussion and Strategic Implications

The study highlights that Customer Loyalty (CL) is a partial mediator. While satisfaction can improve business performance directly, a large portion of that improvement occurs because satisfied customers become loyal ones. Loyal customers exhibit lower sensitivity to price premiums and are more likely to accept new products, which reduces the bank's marketing and recovery costs.

Interestingly, satisfaction and loyalty do not affect all business metrics equally. They have a strong positive impact on profitability and debt-paying ability, but the relationship with operating capacity (asset turnover) was found to be statistically insignificant in this specific model. The authors argue that for Chinese banks to survive, they must shed "official" habits and move toward a relationship-based model where the customer is treated as a partner rather than a transaction.

Limitations and Future Work

The research focuses exclusively on the Bank of China, and results might vary across other state-owned or private institutions. Additionally, as the data ends in 2012, the study does not account for the massive shift toward mobile banking and Fintech (like Alipay and WeChat Pay) that redefined customer loyalty in China shortly after publication. Future work could incorporate variables like "Service Quality" or "Brand Image" to further refine the satisfaction-loyalty chain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Competition is increasing in Chinese banking industry and gaining more customer satisfaction has become the focus of competition.Through empirical research, we found: CS has positive effect on customer loyalty in Chinese banking industry; CS has positive effect on bank's business performance and some dimensions; CL has positive effect on bank's business performance and some dimensions; CL has partial intermediary role in the influence of CS on the performance of banks and some dimensions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xin2014empirical,
  author = {Xin Xin and Wenchao Liu and Hong-li Bao},
  title = {{Empirical Research of the Relationship among Customer Satisfaction, Customer Loyalty and Business Performance in Banking Sector——Illustrated by Bank of Chin}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.2991/icassr-14.2014.15},
}
Figure