Empirical evidence for a recent slowdown in irrigation-induced cooling

C. Bonfils, David B. LobellProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides empirical evidence that widespread irrigation has significantly cooled daytime temperatures, particularly in California, acting as a counterforce to greenhouse gas warming. However, this cooling effect is slowing as irrigation expansion plateaus, suggesting future warming may accelerate without this natural buffer.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The impact of land-use changes on regional climate is crucial for accurate climate projections and informing land-use policy. While urbanization's warming effect is well-studied, the influence of irrigation, which covers a similar land area, has been less clear. Previous studies have yielded conflicting results, often due to simplifying assumptions or a lack of detailed temporal and spatial data. This paper aims to quantify the historical impact of irrigation on temperature trends, specifically addressing whether irrigation has masked or attenuated greenhouse gas-induced warming.

Methods

The authors employed a statistical approach using detailed spatial and temporal datasets to quantify the net impact of irrigation on local and regional climate. They computed temperature differences (d(t)) between intensively irrigated areas and reference regions with low irrigation. By analyzing trends in these differences over time, they isolated the effect of irrigation from broader climate forcings. They also examined the spatial dependence of these trends across different irrigation levels to understand the localized effects.

Datasets

  • Irrigation Datasets: Time-series of irrigated area in California from USDA censuses (since 1889), interpolated between census years. A high-resolution (5' x 5') gridded dataset of current irrigation fraction (CIF) was also used.
  • Temperature Datasets: Four observational gridded datasets for spatial and temporal climate variations in daily average (Tave), nighttime minimum (Tmin), and daytime maximum temperatures (Tmax), as well as diurnal temperature range (DTR), over California for the 1915-2000 period:
  • UW (University of Washington) dataset
    • PRISM dataset
    • CRU2.0 dataset
    • CRU2.1 dataset
    • Data for other regions (Nebraska, Eastern China, Indo-Gangetic Plains, Aral Sea Basin, Thailand) were primarily from PRISM and CRU2.1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Irrigation as a Cooling Agent: The most striking finding is the empirical confirmation that irrigation significantly cools daytime temperatures. This cooling effect is substantial enough to counteract some of the warming expected from greenhouse gases.
  • Diurnal Asymmetry: The cooling effect is primarily observed during the day (Tmax), with negligible impact on nighttime temperatures (Tmin). This suggests that increased evapotranspiration and soil moisture during daylight hours lead to a greater partitioning of energy into latent heat (cooling) rather than sensible heat (warming).
  • Rate Matters, Not Just Presence: The rate of irrigation expansion, rather than its mere presence, appears to be the primary driver of the net cooling effect. This implies that as irrigation expansion slows or stabilizes, its cooling influence diminishes.
  • Future Warming Acceleration: The stabilization of irrigated areas in California and projected slowdowns globally suggest that the buffering effect of irrigation on warming will decrease. This could lead to a more rapid warming in agricultural regions in the future.
  • Regional Variability: While the cooling effect is evident in California, the paper also explores other regions, highlighting that the impact can vary based on local climate, irrigation practices, and the presence of other confounding factors like aerosols.

Key Results

  • California Cooling: Irrigation expansion in California between 1915 and 1979 was associated with a significant cooling of summertime daytime temperatures, estimated at -0.15 to -0.25°C per decade. This translates to an overall cooling of 2.0 to 3.3°C since the introduction of irrigation.
  • Net Cooling: The net cooling effect of widespread irrigation (where CIF > 50%) on average temperature (Tave) was found to be significant, ranging from -0.06 to -0.19°C per decade.
  • DTR Reduction: Irrigation also led to a significant decline in the diurnal temperature range (DTR), ranging from -0.13 to -0.20°C per decade.
  • Other Regions: Similar cooling effects in Tmax were observed in Thailand and the Aral Sea basin. In Nebraska, results corroborated previous findings of cooling in irrigated areas. However, in Pakistan-India and Eastern China, the attribution of temperature changes to irrigation was less clear due to confounding factors like aerosols.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Methodological Limits: The authors acknowledge that their method might underestimate the cooling effect. This is due to potential biases from meteorological stations in irrigated areas influencing gridded datasets and reference regions potentially being cooler than they would be without irrigation. They also note that accounting for broader impacts like moisture advection and cloudiness feedbacks would require more complex trend analyses.
  • Irrigation Technique Variability: The study notes that soil moisture, a key factor in irrigation's cooling effect, depends on irrigation techniques (e.g., flood vs. drip irrigation), which have evolved over time. This variability might not be fully captured by current datasets.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research should involve trend analyses that account for station-level adjustments for irrigation effects and explore the impact of irrigation on broader-scale climate through moisture advection and cloudiness feedbacks. Understanding the interplay between irrigation, urbanization, and greenhouse gas forcing remains a critical area for future climate projection refinement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the influence of past land use changes on climate is needed to improve regional projections of future climate change and inform debates about the tradeoffs associated with land use decisions. The effects of rapid expansion of irrigated area in the 20th century has remained unclear relative to other land use changes, such as urbanization, that affected a similar total land area. Using spatial and temporal variations in temperature and irrigation extent observed in California, we show that irrigation expansion has had a large cooling effect on summertime average daily daytime temperatures (-0.14 degrees C to -0.25 degrees C per decade), which corresponds to an estimated cooling of -1.8 degrees C to -3.2 degrees C since the introduction of irrigation practices. Irrigation has negligible effects on nighttime temperatures, leading to a net cooling effect of irrigation on climate (-0.06 degrees C to -0.19 degrees C per decade). Stabilization of irrigated area has occurred in California since 1980 and is expected in the near future for many irrigated regions. The suppression of past human-induced greenhouse warming by increased irrigation is therefore likely to slow in the future, and a potential decrease in irrigation may even contribute to a more rapid warming. Changes in irrigation alone are not expected to influence broad-scale temperatures, but they may introduce large uncertainties in climate projections for irrigated agricultural regions, which provide approximately 40% of global food production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bonfils2007empirical,
  author = {C. Bonfils and David B. Lobell},
  title = {{Empirical evidence for a recent slowdown in irrigation-induced cooling}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0700144104},
}
Figure