Emerging new global soil governance structure in agrifood systems: Taking the “4 per 1,000” initiative as an example

Li Li, Xiaojing Song, Yang Liu, Li ChaiFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Food systems are responsible for 21% to 37% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. While soil degradation threatens food security across 40% of the Earth's land surface, healthy soils offer a significant opportunity for carbon sequestration. The "4 per 1,000" initiative, launched at COP21, proposes that an annual 0.4% increase in soil organic carbon (SOC) could offset fossil fuel emissions and help limit global temperature increases. However, major emitters have yet to adopt the initiative at a national level. This paper reviews the current policy landscape and proposes a new governance framework based on a "soil carbon divide."

Introduction

Agriculture is central to the climate crisis, acting as both a major source of emissions and a potential solution. The "4 per 1,000" initiative posits that increasing the carbon stored in the world's topsoil by just 0.4% per year could theoretically halt the annual increase of atmospheric CO2. Despite its potential, the initiative faces a significant "compliance gap," particularly among the world's largest GHG emitters.

The Compliance Gap in Global Soil Governance

Three primary hurdles prevent the widespread adoption of the "4 per 1,000" initiative:

  1. Soft Legal Power: Current international soil charters lack binding authority, making national participation voluntary and often deprioritized.
  2. Knowledge Mobilization: The diverse co-benefits of soil health—such as improved water quality and biodiversity—are not yet fully quantified or integrated into economic policy.
  3. The North-South Divide: Traditional geopolitical tensions often hinder a unified approach to soil as a global public good.

Methodology and the Soil Carbon Divide

To analyze this gap, the study employs a comparative analysis of national policies and global datasets from the World Bank, FAO, and IPCC. A key innovation is the calculation of a "sequestration target" for individual nations, determined by dividing annual fossil fuel emissions by national SOC stocks.

This metric reveals a distinct "Soil Carbon Divide." Countries are categorized not just by economic status, but by their inherent capacity to offset emissions through their land.

Soil carbon sink targets vs. GDP per capita, illustrating the divide between soil-rich and soil-poor nations.

As shown in the figure above, nations like Australia, Russia, and Canada are "soil carbon rich" relative to their emissions, facing targets well below the global average. Conversely, "soil carbon poor" nations such as China, India, the US, and the UK must implement much more aggressive strategies to meet the 0.4% goal. For instance, China’s required sequestration target ranges from 2.9% to 11.1%, far exceeding the 1.5% global average.

Policy Innovations: NCBDR and SALM

The authors propose a "New Common But Differentiated Responsibility" (NCBDR) framework. Under this model, developed "soil-poor" nations would provide financial and technological support, while developing nations focus on implementing sustainable practices.

Practical momentum can be gained through Sustainable Agricultural Land Management (SALM) methodologies. By quantifying soil-climate co-benefits and turning sequestration into a tradable asset under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, soil governance can transition from a voluntary initiative to a market-driven reality.

Key Results and Progress

  • China’s Unofficial Progress: While not a national signatory, China has increased its straw-to-field return rate to nearly 40% and invested 8 billion RMB in soil testing, significantly reducing CO2e emissions.
  • Economic Potential: Case studies, such as in West Bengal, India, demonstrate that verified soil carbon projects can generate millions in annual revenue for farming cooperatives while sequestering hundreds of thousands of tons of CO2e.

Conclusion

Bridging the compliance gap requires political willingness and institutional innovation. Future efforts should focus on precise spatial modeling to prove technical feasibility to policymakers and establishing "Soil Funds" to facilitate technology transfer between the Global North and South. Creating robust carbon trading platforms that reward smallholder farmers is essential for a truly global and equitable soil governance structure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Food systems emit 21%-37% of the global greenhouse gases (GHGs). Soil degradation, accelerated by global warming, poses a threat to over 40% of the land surfaces, threatening food security. Keeping soils alive and healthy could not only play a part in food security, but also in sequestrating GHGs for climate mitigation. In 2015, the “4 per 1,000” Initiative was launched in Paris COP21, indicating that a “4‰” annual growth rate of the soil organic carbon sequestration could hold the temperature increase within 1.5°C−2°C. However, major GHG emitting countries haven't signed the 4‰ Initiative at national level. Political willingness need to be encouraged though institutional innovations in the global soil governance (GSG). This article conducts a comprehensive policy review for the 4‰ Initiative and attempts to develop the concept of global soil governance from an aspect of New Common But Differentiated Responsibility. The SOC sink targets reveal that countries like China, India, the UK, the US, and France take more pains than those like Australia, Russia, and Canada. A new “soil carbon rich” and “soil carbon poor” divide is perceived, which needs to be taken into the GSG as a restructuring motivation for setting a more practical and integrated framework. In that sense, some developed countries face similar challenges as the developing countries do, but could contribute more in finance and technology. Bandwagon of applying sustainable agricultural land management (SALM) methodology in carbon markets implies that soil-climate co-benefits get greater practical momentum with quantified trading platforms, which may stimulate potentiality if embodied in Article 6 of the Paris Agreement .
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023emerging,
  author = {Li Li and Xiaojing Song and Yang Liu and Li Chai},
  title = {{Emerging new global soil governance structure in agrifood systems: Taking the “4 per 1,000” initiative as an example}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fsufs.2023.1104252},
}
Figure