Emerging negative impact of warming on summer carbon uptake in northern ecosystems

Tao Wang, Dan Liu, Shilong Piao, Yilong Wang, Xiaoyi Wang, Hui Guo, Xu Lian, J. F. Burkhart, Philippe Ciais, Mengtian Huang, Ivan A. Janssens, Yue Li, Yongwen Liu, Josep Peñuelas, Shushi Peng, Hui Yang, Yitong Yao, Yi Yin, Yutong ZhaoNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Warming temperatures in northern ecosystems, once thought to boost summer carbon uptake, are now having a negative impact. This shift is primarily driven by a decline in vegetation's positive response to temperature, suggesting a fundamental change in how these critical ecosystems regulate atmospheric CO2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The northern hemisphere's carbon cycle is a crucial component of the global climate system, with its ecosystems acting as significant carbon sinks. While much research has focused on how temperature influences spring and autumn carbon uptake, the impact on summer carbon uptake has remained less clear. This is a critical knowledge gap because summer is when vegetation productivity is highest and terrestrial ecosystems typically draw down the most atmospheric CO2. Understanding this summer response is vital for predicting how these ecosystems will respond to ongoing climate change and whether they will continue to mitigate rising CO2 levels or exacerbate them. The paper aims to clarify the relationship between summer warming and carbon uptake in northern ecosystems and investigate if this relationship has changed over time.

Methods

The researchers utilized atmospheric CO2 concentration data from the Point Barrow, Alaska monitoring station (1979-2012) to infer summer carbon uptake. They calculated "summer CO2 drawdown" (SCD) as a proxy for this uptake, specifically measuring the CO2 concentration difference between early July and late August. To account for other environmental factors, they employed partial correlation analyses, controlling for precipitation and cloudiness. A key aspect of their methodology was the decadal analysis, comparing the periods 1979-1995 and 1996-2012 to identify temporal shifts in the temperature-uptake relationship. They also used satellite-derived vegetation indices (NDVI) as a proxy for vegetation productivity and analyzed other datasets like solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF), net primary productivity (NPP), and gross primary productivity (GPP) to explore the underlying mechanisms. Robustness tests were conducted using different SCD calculation methods and spatially weighted climate data based on atmospheric transport models.

Datasets

  • Atmospheric CO2 concentration data: Daily records from the Barrow, Alaska monitoring station (NOAA Earth System Research Laboratory) for 1979-2012.
  • Terrestrial temperature data: Gridded monthly climate data (CRU TS4.0 dataset and WATCH forcing data) for areas north of 50°N.
  • Precipitation and Cloudiness data: Gridded monthly climate data (CRU TS4.0 dataset and WATCH forcing data) for areas north of 50°N.
  • Satellite-derived NDVI: From the GIMMS group (1981-2014).
  • Solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF): Dataset for 2001-2012.
  • Satellite-derived Net Primary Productivity (NPP): A 30-year global dataset (1982-2011).
  • Gross Primary Productivity (GPP): A global product based on flux-tower data, satellite remote sensing, and meteorological data (1982-2011).
  • Root-zone soil moisture and evapotranspiration: From the GLEAM v3.0a dataset.
  • Sea ice extent data: Derived from the Sea Ice Index Version 3 dataset.
  • Simulated Net Biome Production (NBP): From the MACC atmospheric CO2 inversion system (1979-2011) and nine process-based ecosystem models (Trendy project).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The paradigm shift: The long-held assumption that warming temperatures are beneficial for summer carbon uptake in northern ecosystems is being challenged. The study reveals a significant negative correlation emerging in recent decades.
  • Decadal divergence: The relationship isn't static. While the earlier period (1979-1995) showed a weak or non-significant correlation, the later period (1996-2012) exhibited a strong negative correlation, indicating a fundamental change.
  • Vegetation's fading response: The primary driver of this shift appears to be the weakening positive response of summer vegetation activities (like photosynthesis) to temperature. What once boosted uptake now contributes less, or even negatively, to it.
  • Implications for climate feedback: This emerging negative impact suggests that warming might not only reduce carbon sequestration but could potentially turn these ecosystems into carbon sources, accelerating climate change.

Key Results

  • Over the entire study period (1979-2012), there was a significant negative interannual correlation between summer CO2 drawdown (SCD) and terrestrial summer temperature north of 50°N (R = -0.46, P < 0.01). This means warmer years were associated with lower carbon uptake.
  • A decadal analysis revealed a significant shift:
  • 1979-1995: The correlation was weak and not statistically significant (R = -0.40, P = 0.14).
  • 1996-2012: The correlation became strongly negative and statistically significant (R = -0.65, P < 0.01).
  • The positive correlation between vegetation productivity proxies (NDVI) and temperature, which was strong in the earlier period (R = 0.82 ± 0.07), disappeared in the later period (R = 0.08 ± 0.19).
  • This loss of positive correlation was observed across large regions of eastern Siberia and Alaska, areas critical to the Barrow station's carbon footprint.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited direct flux data: The study relies on atmospheric CO2 concentration data as a proxy for carbon uptake. Direct measurements of net surface CO2 flux (e.g., from eddy covariance towers) are scarce in these high-latitude regions, limiting the ability to directly confirm these findings.
  • Model uncertainties: While ecosystem models were used, most failed to capture the observed loss of the positive correlation between NPP and temperature, highlighting limitations in current model representations of these processes.
  • Mechanisms still being explored: While the weakening vegetation response is identified as the primary driver, the exact reasons for this weakening (e.g., heat stress, non-linear photosynthesis responses, or soil moisture changes) require further investigation.
  • Future work: The authors emphasize the need for more in situ carbon cycle observations, the development of more mechanistic ecosystem models that accurately represent temperature-productivity relationships, and improved inverse models for assimilating CO2 concentration data. They also suggest that future warming could fundamentally alter high-latitude terrestrial carbon balances, potentially leading to increased CO2 release.

Summary updated

Abstract

Most studies of the northern hemisphere carbon cycle based on atmospheric CO<sub>2</sub> concentration have focused on spring and autumn, but the climate change impact on summer carbon cycle remains unclear. Here we used atmospheric CO<sub>2</sub> record from Point Barrow (Alaska) to show that summer CO<sub>2</sub> drawdown between July and August, a proxy of summer carbon uptake, is significantly negatively correlated with terrestrial temperature north of 50°N interannually during 1979-2012. However, a refined analysis at the decadal scale reveals strong differences between the earlier (1979-1995) and later (1996-2012) periods, with the significant negative correlation only in the later period. This emerging negative temperature response is due to the disappearance of the positive temperature response of summer vegetation activities that prevailed in the earlier period. Our finding, together with the reported weakening temperature control on spring carbon uptake, suggests a diminished positive effect of warming on high-latitude carbon uptake.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2018emerging,
  author = {Tao Wang and Dan Liu and Shilong Piao and Yilong Wang and Xiaoyi Wang and Hui Guo and Xu Lian and J. F. Burkhart and Philippe Ciais and Mengtian Huang and Ivan A. Janssens and Yue Li and Yongwen Liu and Josep Peñuelas and Shushi Peng and Hui Yang and Yitong Yao and Yi Yin and Yutong Zhao},
  title = {{Emerging negative impact of warming on summer carbon uptake in northern ecosystems}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-07813-7},
}
Figure