Emerging magnetism and anomalous Hall effect in iridate–manganite heterostructures

John Nichols, Xiang Gao, Shinbuhm Lee, Tricia L. Meyer, J. W. Freeland, Valeria Lauter, Di Yi, Jian Liu, D. Haskel, Jonathan R. Petrie, Er‐Jia Guo, Andreas Herklotz, Dongkyu Lee, Thomas Z. Ward, Gyula Eres, M. R. Fitzsimmons, Ho Nyung LeeNature Communications 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have created novel heterostructures by layering SrMnO3 (a 3d antiferromagnetic insulator) and SrIrO3 (a 5d paramagnetic metal). They discovered that the interface between these materials exhibits surprisingly strong coupling, leading to emergent ferromagnetism and a significant anomalous Hall effect, phenomena absent in the individual parent compounds. This work opens up new avenues for exploring exotic quantum phenomena and potential spintronic applications at 3d-5d interfaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transition metal oxides (TMOs) are known for their rich physics arising from the interplay of charge, spin, orbital, and lattice degrees of freedom. While interfacial coupling between TMOs can tune these properties, studies on heterostructures involving both 3d and 5d TMOs are relatively scarce, and strong interfacial coupling in such systems has not been well-established. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the interfacial properties of SrMnO3 (SMO, a 3d TMO) and SrIrO3 (SIO, a 5d TMO). Specifically, it aims to understand if and how the strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in 5d materials, combined with the strong Coulomb repulsion in 3d materials, can lead to novel emergent phenomena at their interface, which are not present in the bulk constituents.

Methods

The researchers synthesized atomic-scale heterostructures of [(SrMnO3)m/(SrIrO3)n]z using pulsed laser epitaxy. They employed a suite of advanced characterization techniques to probe the magnetic and electronic properties:

  • Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID): Used for macroscopic magnetic property measurements, including magnetization versus magnetic field (M(H)) and magnetization versus temperature (M(T)) to identify magnetic ordering and Curie temperatures.
  • X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS) and X-ray Magnetic Circular Dichroism (XMCD): These techniques were crucial for elemental-specific characterization. By analyzing the spectra at the Mn and Ir L-edges, the researchers could determine the oxidation states and magnetic moments of individual elements, providing insights into charge transfer and interfacial magnetism.
  • Polarized Neutron Reflectometry (PNR): This technique allowed for depth-resolved magnetic profiling, revealing the distribution of magnetic moments within the heterostructure layers.
  • DC-transport measurements: Used to investigate the electronic properties, including sheet resistance (Rs) and Hall resistance (Rxy), to understand conductivity and the anomalous Hall effect.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements performed on synthesized samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emergent Interfacial Ferromagnetism: The most striking finding is the emergence of ferromagnetism at the SMO/SIO interface, which is completely absent in the bulk parent materials. This suggests that the interface acts as a unique magnetic entity.
  • Strong Interfacial Coupling: The observed ferromagnetism and anomalous Hall effect are attributed to an "enormously strong" interfacial coupling between the 3d and 5d TMOs. This coupling is strong enough to overcome the intrinsic magnetic order of the parent materials.
  • Charge Transfer Driven Magnetism: XAS and XMCD data reveal a significant charge transfer from SIO to SMO layers. This charge transfer is identified as the driving mechanism behind the interfacial ferromagnetism.
  • Role of Spin-Orbit Coupling (SOC): While Mn is the dominant magnetic ion, the study highlights the crucial role of SOC in the Ir ions. The XMCD results suggest that Ir also contributes to the ferromagnetism, with a significant orbital contribution due to strong SOC, which is unusual for Ir ions in their nominal oxidation states.
  • Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) as a Signature: The presence of a strong anomalous Hall effect, particularly its hysteresis loop and temperature dependence, serves as a direct consequence and clear indicator of the emergent interfacial ferromagnetism.
  • 3d-5d Interfaces as a New Playground: The work establishes that low-dimensional interfaces between 3d and 5d materials, where both strong Coulomb repulsion (U) and strong spin-orbit coupling (ξ) are present, can host technologically relevant physical phenomena that are unattainable in bulk materials.

Key Results

  • Magnetization: Symmetric superlattices with thin layers (e.g., M1I1) exhibited the largest magnetic response. The Curie temperature (Tc) was highest for M1I1, reaching ~190 K.
  • Oxidation States: XAS/XMCD indicated a reduction in Mn oxidation state (lower than Mn⁴⁺) and an enhancement in Ir oxidation state (higher than Ir⁴⁺) relative to their bulk values, consistent with charge transfer of approximately 0.5 electron/hole per unit cell.
  • Magnetic Moments: PNR measurements on an asymmetric sample (M1I10) revealed a magnetic depth profile with Mn moments of ~85 emu/cm³ (0.54 μB/Mn) and Ir moments of ~9 emu/cm³ (0.06 μB/Ir). XMCD analysis for M1I1 showed spin and orbital contributions for Ir (0.013 μB and 0.057 μB, respectively) and for Mn (0.9 μB and 0.3 μB, respectively).
  • Anomalous Hall Effect: A significant anomalous Hall effect was observed, characterized by a large hysteresis loop at low temperatures, which directly correlated with the magnetic hysteresis of the samples. The Hall response above Tc was linear, indicating n-type carriers, while below Tc, it became nonlinear and showed a hysteresis loop.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Oxidation State Estimates: While the trend of charge transfer is clear, the absolute values of oxidation states derived from peak shifts have relatively large uncertainties, although their relative uncertainties are smaller.
  • Discrepancy in Ir Moment Alignment: A discrepancy was noted between XMCD (Ir moments antiparallel to Mn in M1I1) and PNR (Ir moments parallel to Mn in M1I10) regarding the alignment of Ir moments. This suggests a critical SIO thickness where the Ir moments might realign, warranting further investigation.
  • Resistive Shorting Effect: The measured transverse conductivity (σxy) was significantly lower than theoretical predictions. The authors attribute this to the SIO layers acting as a "resistive short" for the voltage leads during Hall measurements, which reduces the measured σxy.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that these 3d-5d heterostructures are a prototypical system for investigating interfacial coupling between strong U and strong SOC, opening avenues for potential spintronics applications. They also highlight the opportunity to study magnetism in multivalent Ir ions, which could stimulate further theoretical and experimental studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Strong Coulomb repulsion and spin-orbit coupling are known to give rise to exotic physical phenomena in transition metal oxides. Initial attempts to investigate systems, where both of these fundamental interactions are comparably strong, such as 3d and 5d complex oxide superlattices, have revealed properties that only slightly differ from the bulk ones of the constituent materials. Here we observe that the interfacial coupling between the 3d antiferromagnetic insulator SrMnO3 and the 5d paramagnetic metal SrIrO3 is enormously strong, yielding an anomalous Hall response as the result of charge transfer driven interfacial ferromagnetism. These findings show that low dimensional spin-orbit entangled 3d-5d interfaces provide an avenue to uncover technologically relevant physical phenomena unattainable in bulk materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nichols2016emerging,
  author = {John Nichols and Xiang Gao and Shinbuhm Lee and Tricia L. Meyer and J. W. Freeland and Valeria Lauter and Di Yi and Jian Liu and D. Haskel and Jonathan R. Petrie and Er‐Jia Guo and Andreas Herklotz and Dongkyu Lee and Thomas Z. Ward and Gyula Eres and M. R. Fitzsimmons and Ho Nyung Lee},
  title = {{Emerging magnetism and anomalous Hall effect in iridate–manganite heterostructures}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms12721},
}
Figure