Emergent Sasaki-Einstein geometry and AdS/CFT

Robert Berman, Tristan Collins, Daniel PerssonOpenReview 2023 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel mechanism for how the geometry of spacetime, specifically a Sasaki-Einstein metric, can emerge from a quantum state in a strongly coupled gauge theory, as predicted by the AdS/CFT correspondence. They achieve this by constructing a specific "canonical" quantum state in the gauge theory and showing that its properties, in the large N limit, precisely reproduce the desired geometric structure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A central tenet of the AdS/CFT correspondence is that a quantum theory of gravity in a higher-dimensional spacetime (like Anti-de Sitter space, AdS) is equivalent to a quantum field theory (CFT) living on its lower-dimensional boundary. A key challenge is to understand how the classical spacetime geometry, which is the vacuum solution in the gravitational theory, arises from the microscopic description in the CFT. In the context of minimal supersymmetry, the gravitational vacuum is described by a Sasaki-Einstein metric on a compact manifold $M$. The authors aim to show how this specific geometric structure emerges from a particular quantum state in the dual CFT, which is a four-dimensional superconformal gauge theory.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in constructing a specific quantum state, denoted $\Psi_N$, in the rank $N$ gauge theory. This state is "canonical" in the sense that it's defined without reference to any pre-existing background metric, relying instead on the symmetries of the gauge theory itself. They leverage the concept of BPS states in the gauge theory, which are particularly stable and can be represented by holomorphic polynomial functions on the "mesonic branch" of the gauge theory's moduli space. This moduli space is identified with a symmetric product of complex cones, $Y^N/S_N$.

The authors then define a probability measure, $d\mathbb{P}_N$, derived from the amplitude of $\Psi_N$. They show that in the limit where the rank of the gauge theory $N$ goes to infinity, this probability measure converges to the volume form of a Sasaki-Einstein metric on $M$. They also introduce a regularization parameter $\beta$ to study the convergence more rigorously, demonstrating that the Sasaki-Einstein metric emerges after analytic continuation in $\beta$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emergence of Geometry from Quantum States: The most significant insight is the demonstration that a specific geometric structure (Sasaki-Einstein metric) can arise dynamically from the properties of a quantum state in a dual field theory, rather than being an input.
  • Canonical State as the Key: The construction of a "canonical" BPS state $\Psi_N$, independent of background metrics, is crucial. This state encodes the essential information from the gauge theory's symmetries.
  • Large N Limit as the Bridge: The t'Hooft limit ($N \to \infty$) is identified as the crucial regime where the collective behavior of the quantum degrees of freedom in the CFT translates into a classical geometric structure.
  • Connection to Giant Gravitons: The paper provides a string theory interpretation of the canonical state $\Psi_N$ as a bound state or coherent state of "dual giant gravitons." This offers a new perspective on the intriguing duality of these objects.
  • K-stability and Stability: The authors connect the condition for the existence of a Sasaki-Einstein metric (K-stability) to the well-definedness of their canonical ensemble, suggesting a deep link between geometric stability and the existence of consistent quantum states.

Key Results

  • The paper proposes a specific canonical quantum state $\Psi_N$ in the rank $N$ gauge theory.
  • They derive a probability measure $d\mathbb{P}_N$ from this state.
  • They conjecture that in the large $N$ limit, this measure converges to the volume form of a Sasaki-Einstein metric on the manifold $M$.
  • A "Main Theorem" is presented, which rigorously proves this convergence for a $\beta$-deformed version of the measure, demonstrating that the Sasaki-Einstein metric emerges after analytic continuation.
  • Explicit finite $N$ approximations to the Sasaki-Einstein metric are obtained, expressed in terms of the canonical state $\Psi_N$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Quasi-Regular Case Assumption: The "Main Conjecture" is initially stated for the "quasi-regular" case of complex cones, although the authors mention that the general setting will be treated in forthcoming work.
  • Rigorous Proof of $Z_N < \infty$: While they argue that $Z_N < \infty$ (ensuring a finite norm for $\Psi_N$) is equivalent to the existence of a unique Sasaki-Einstein metric, proving the "if" direction (i.e., if a metric exists, then $Z_N < \infty$) is noted as challenging, except for the complex dimension two case.
  • Analytic Continuation: The rigorous proof of the main conjecture relies on analytic continuation in a regularization parameter $\beta$. The authors expect that this parameter is not fundamentally necessary and that the conjecture holds directly.
  • Future Work: The authors explicitly mention forthcoming work [29] that will detail the proof of the main theorem, address the general case, and explore the connection to K-stability and Gibbs stability more deeply. They also suggest that the case of complex dimension two might offer a direct proof of the main conjecture. The string theory interpretation of giant gravitons is also a significant area for further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider supergravity in five-dimensional Anti-De Sitter space AdS5 with minimal supersymmetry, encoded by a Sasaki-Einstein metric on a five-dimensional compact manifold M. Our main result reveals how the Sasaki-Einstein metric emerges from a canonical state in the dual CFT, defined by a superconformal gauge theory in four dimensional Minkowski space R^{3,1} in the t'Hooft limit where the rank N tends to infinity. We obtain explicit finite N−approximations to the Sasaki-Einstein metric, expressed in terms of a canonical (i.e. background free) BPS-state on the gauge theory side. We also provide a string theory interpretation of the BPS-state in question, which sheds new light on the previously noted intriguing duality of giant gravitons.
BibTeX
@misc{berman2023emergent,
  author = {Robert Berman and Tristan Collins and Daniel Persson},
  title = {{Emergent Sasaki-Einstein geometry and AdS/CFT}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2008.12004},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2008.12004},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}

Loading related content...

Figure