Emergent Relational Order in LLM Agent Societies: From Collective Affect to Authority Stratification

Zhiyuan Ji, Xinyu Chen, Ziqi Dai, Shiyun Tang, Chunyu Wei, Yueguo ChenarXiv 2026 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces CAREB-MAS, a multi-agent framework demonstrating that complex, long-horizon social structures can spontaneously emerge from basic cognitive and emotional mechanisms in LLM agents. Without hardcoding culture-specific rules, the simulation successfully reproduces the "Differential Order Pattern"—an ego-centered, relationally graded social structure traditionally observed in rural societies. The findings show that non-Western sociological theories can be computationally tested, revealing how macro-level social order shifts from kin-centered integration to functional interdependence based purely on economic production structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional agent-based models (ABMs) rely on rigid, hand-coded rules that struggle to capture the complex co-evolution of emotion, ethics, authority, and long-term social structure. While recent LLM-based multi-agent simulations show promise in replicating short-term coordination or dyadic exchanges, they rarely probe long-horizon social stratification or test macro-level sociological theories—especially non-Western ones.

The authors tackle Fei Xiaotong's Differential Order Pattern, a foundational concept in Chinese sociology that describes rural society not as discrete groups, but as ego-centered concentric ripples of relational proximity where moral obligations and cooperation decay with social distance. The paper investigates whether this pattern is a fixed cultural artifact or an emergent property arising from general, cross-cultural micro-mechanisms under specific production constraints.

Figure 1: Schematic comparison of social organization: (a) discrete groups without relational gradation; (b) dif- ferential order, organized as ego-centered concentric layers of relational proximity.

Methods

The authors propose CAREB-MAS (Collective Affection–Reasoning–Emergence Based Multi-Agent Simulation), a framework that models an emotion–ethics–belief–action chain rather than relying on hardcoded institutional rules.

The agent architecture consists of several interconnected modules:

  • Empathy Core (EC): Grounded in Affect Control Theory, it decodes observed behaviors into a five-dimensional affective vector (evaluation, potency, activity, status-conferral, power-assertion).
  • Ethical Resonator (ER): Inspired by Durkheimian moral education, it aggregates these perceptions into moral judgments (approbatory, repressive, or restorative attitudes).
  • Social Identity Matrix (SIM): Tracks dynamically evolving trust and relational closeness on an ordinal scale.
  • A-BDI Decision Module: Extends the traditional Belief-Desire-Intention architecture by constraining rational choices with collective affect and social identity.

The simulation operates in a four-phase loop per round: (1) Community Detection (using the Louvain algorithm on the SIM network), (2) Public Deliberation (negotiation and labor proposals), (3) Division of Labor and Production, and (4) Preference-Weighted Distribution and Psychological Update.

Figure 2: Overview of CAREB-MAS. Left: agent-level cognitive architecture, from EC (Affect Control Theory) to ER (ethical judgment), SIM (Social Identity Theory), and A-BDI (Durkheimian affective constraint on action). Right: four-phase interaction loop: community formation, deliberation, division of labor, and production with psychological update.

Datasets

The paper does not use standard pre-existing datasets. Instead, it establishes a custom simulation environment consisting of 18 LLM agents simulated over 30 rounds. The population includes two kin-based clans (6 members each) and 6 unaligned "proself" agents. The framework was evaluated across three distinct LLM families to ensure robustness: DeepSeek-V3 (primary), GPT-4o-mini, and Gemini-2.5-flash-lite.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure-Sensitive Emergence: The "Differential Order Pattern" is not just a unique cultural template but an emergent outcome of general social mechanisms sensitive to economic structures.
  • Mechanical vs. Organic Solidarity: By varying agent skills, the authors showed that symmetric resource endowments lead to kin-centered integration (resembling Durkheim's mechanical solidarity), while complementary endowments break down clan boundaries in favor of functional interdependence (organic solidarity).
  • The "Atlas Paradox": A fascinating decoupling occurs between coordination effort and authority. Agents who absorb the burden of stabilizing collective coordination ("holding up the sky") do not automatically gain decision authority; instead, durable power remains anchored in agenda control (proposing plans).
  • Guanxi as an Economic Buffer: High social identity (SIM) acts as an ethical commitment device. Agents with strong relational ties maintain community participation even during severe negative utility shocks, whereas low-SIM agents quickly defect when short-term incentives turn unfavorable.
Figure 4: Community match rates under utility shocks. F1/F2: family groups; Proself: unaligned agents. High- SIM relations maintain stable participation (solid lines) even when recent utility is low, whereas low-SIM ties (dashed lines) exhibit sharp decline. This stickiness is more pronounced in the complementary condition (B).

Key Results

  • Stable Division of Labor: Specialization emerged rapidly without centralized control. Global division lock-in scores reached 0.972 under symmetric skills and 0.985 under complementary skills.
  • Relational Decay of Cooperation: Cooperation strictly followed a relational gradient. Under symmetric skills, within-family proposals accounted for 34.2% of activity, family-to-proself was 34.3%, while cross-family proposals plummeted to just 6.9%.
  • Authority Stratification: OLS regression confirmed that proposal intensity strongly predicts emergent decision authority ($\beta = 0.820$ for symmetric, $\beta = 0.780$ for complementary, $p < 0.01$), dominating over sheer communication volume or accumulated wealth.
  • Architecture Dependency: Ablation studies showed that removing the social-cognitive modules (moving to a vanilla BDI baseline) caused a catastrophic collapse of the relational structure, proving the patterns are architecture-driven rather than simple LLM artifacts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scale Constraints: Due to the $O(N^2)$ computational complexity of updating relational matrices, the simulation was limited to 18 agents, restricting broader population-level claims.
  • Simplified Environment: The model lacks explicit institutional features like sanctioning, conflict-resolution mechanisms, or external environmental shocks (e.g., migration, resource scarcity).
  • Theoretical vs. Empirical Validation: Validation relied heavily on qualitative alignment with established anthropological and sociological theories rather than direct, fine-grained ethnographic calibration.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest scaling up the number of agents, introducing more complex social settings, and testing a wider variety of model families to mitigate potential training data priors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fei Xiaotong's Differential Order Pattern characterizes rural society as egocentric and relationally graded, with cooperation attenuating over social distance. Although often treated as culturally specific, its mechanistic basis remains under-operationalized, and prior LLM-based simulations have mainly addressed short-term coordination rather than long-horizon social structure. We propose CAREB-MAS, a multi-agent framework grounded in Affect Control Theory, Social Identity Theory, and Durkheimian collective affect. Agents reason through an emotion-ethics-belief chain and maintain dynamically evolving egocentric identities, while the macro environment specifies only individual production, preference-based allocation, and minimal interaction protocols. Across long-horizon simulations, agents spontaneously reproduce five core Differential Order phenomena: stable labor specialization, guanxi-based economic ethics, relational decay of cooperation, emergent relational authority, and clan-based center-periphery stratification. These patterns shift with production structure from kin-centered integration toward greater functional interdependence. Extensive experiment results support interpreting Differential Order as a structure-sensitive emergent outcome of general social mechanisms, with LLM-based multi-agent simulation providing an interdisciplinary framework for studying social structure and change.
BibTeX
@misc{ji2026emergent,
  author = {Zhiyuan Ji and Xinyu Chen and Ziqi Dai and Shiyun Tang and Chunyu Wei and Yueguo Chen},
  title = {{Emergent Relational Order in LLM Agent Societies: From Collective Affect to Authority Stratification}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2606.23764},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.23764},
}
Figure