Emergent inequality and endogenous dynamics in a simple behavioral\n macroeconomic model

Yuki M. Asano, Jakob J. Kolb, Jobst Heitzig, J. Doyne FarmerarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Standard macroeconomic models assume that households are rational in the sense that they are perfect utility maximizers, and explain economic dynamics in terms of shocks that drive the economy away from the stead-state. Here we build on a standard macroeconomic model in which a single rational representative household makes a savings decision of how much to consume or invest. In our model households are myopic boundedly rational heterogeneous agents embedded in a social network. From time to time each household updates its savings rate by copying the savings rate of its neighbor with the highest consumption. If the updating time is short, the economy is stuck in a poverty trap, but for longer updating times economic output approaches its optimal value, and we observe a critical transition to an economy with irregular endogenous oscillations in economic output, resembling a business cycle. In this regime households divide into two groups: Poor households with low savings rates and rich households with high savings rates. Thus inequality and economic dynamics both occur spontaneously as a consequence of imperfect household decision making. Our work here supports an alternative program of research that substitutes utility maximization for behaviorally grounded decision making.

Introduction: Beyond the Rational Agent

Traditional macroeconomic models, such as the Ramsey-Cass-Koopmans (RCK) framework, typically rely on the "representative rational agent." This hypothetical household is assumed to be a perfect calculator, maximizing long-term utility to determine the optimal balance between consumption and savings. In such models, the economy remains in a stable steady state unless disturbed by external "shocks," such as technological shifts or global crises.

However, empirical evidence from behavioral economics suggests that human decision-making is "boundedly rational." Real-world agents are often myopic, rely on simple heuristics, and are deeply influenced by their social networks. This paper explores whether macroeconomic phenomena like business cycles and wealth inequality can emerge naturally from these simple behavioral rules, rather than as responses to external shocks.

Methodology: Social Learning and Imitation

The researchers developed an agent-based version of the RCK model, replacing the single rational agent with a network of $N$ heterogeneous households. Instead of complex utility maximization, households follow a simple "imitate-the-best" heuristic: periodically, a household observes its neighbors and adopts the savings rate of the individual with the highest current consumption.

The primary control variable in this model is the social interaction time ($\tau$), representing the average interval between updates. The production of goods is governed by a standard Cobb-Douglas function, but the capital accumulation driving this production is determined entirely by the behavioral savings decisions of the agents. The model was tested across various network topologies, including random and small-world networks, to assess how social structure influences economic outcomes.

The Critical Transition and the Poverty Trap

A key finding of the model is the existence of a sharp phase transition based on the frequency of social interaction. When households update their savings rates too frequently (low $\tau$), they become excessively myopic. Seeing a neighbor with high current consumption leads them to immediately copy a low savings rate, preventing the accumulation of capital. This behavior traps the entire economy in a low-output "poverty trap."

Figure 1: The transition from a poverty trap to an oscillatory regime as interaction time $\tau$ increases.

As $\tau$ increases beyond a critical threshold ($\tau_c \approx 250$), the economy escapes this trap. Surprisingly, in this high-$\tau$ regime, the aggregate economy approaches the theoretical "Golden Rule" of optimal savings ($s_{gold} = 0.5$). Even though individual agents are simple copycats, the system collectively behaves as if it were a farsighted, rational optimizer.

Endogenous Business Cycles and Inequality

Above the critical threshold, the model produces two striking emergent features: spontaneous inequality and irregular business cycles. The population splits into two distinct classes: "rich" households with high savings rates and "poor" households with low savings rates. This inequality is not an input of the model but an emergent property of the social learning process.

Figure 2: Time evolution and distribution of savings rates, capital, and output, showing emergent business cycles and wealth inequality.

Furthermore, the model generates endogenous oscillations in GDP that resemble real-world business cycles. These cycles are driven by the internal logic of the system: rich households eventually increase their consumption, which is then copied by others. This leads to a depletion of aggregate capital and a subsequent recession, until the cycle resets. This suggests that macroeconomic instability can be an inherent property of human social behavior.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that complex macroeconomic dynamics—including inequality and business cycles—can emerge from very simple behavioral heuristics. While the model is conceptual and uses a simplified production function, it aligns qualitatively with historical data from OECD countries, where savings rates often rise during recessions before a recovery. By substituting perfect utility maximization with behaviorally grounded decision-making, this work provides a new lens through which to understand the inherent instability of modern economies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Standard macroeconomic models assume that households are rational in the\nsense that they are perfect utility maximizers, and explain economic dynamics\nin terms of shocks that drive the economy away from the stead-state. Here we\nbuild on a standard macroeconomic model in which a single rational\nrepresentative household makes a savings decision of how much to consume or\ninvest. In our model households are myopic boundedly rational heterogeneous\nagents embedded in a social network. From time to time each household updates\nits savings rate by copying the savings rate of its neighbor with the highest\nconsumption. If the updating time is short, the economy is stuck in a poverty\ntrap, but for longer updating times economic output approaches its optimal\nvalue, and we observe a critical transition to an economy with irregular\nendogenous oscillations in economic output, resembling a business cycle. In\nthis regime households divide into two groups: Poor households with low savings\nrates and rich households with high savings rates. Thus inequality and economic\ndynamics both occur spontaneously as a consequence of imperfect household\ndecision making. Our work here supports an alternative program of research that\nsubstitutes utility maximization for behaviorally grounded decision making.\n
BibTeX
@misc{asano2019emergent,
  author = {Yuki M. Asano and Jakob J. Kolb and Jobst Heitzig and J. Doyne Farmer},
  title = {{Emergent inequality and endogenous dynamics in a simple behavioral\textbackslash\{\}n macroeconomic model}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1907.02155},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.02155},
}
Figure