Emergency Medicine Curriculum Utilizing the Flipped Classroom Method: Environmental Emergencies

Daniel Bachmann, Sarah Gartner, Andrew J. King, Nicholas Kman, Mary Jo Bowman, Michael BarrieJournal of Education and Teaching in Emergency Medicine 2019 · DOI

Abstract

This curriculum, developed and implemented at The Ohio State University Emergency Medicine Residency, addresses the educational gap in managing environmental emergencies. By transitioning from traditional passive lectures to an active "flipped classroom" model, the program aims to enhance learner engagement and knowledge retention for critical but infrequent clinical scenarios. The curriculum utilizes pre-directed self-study followed by Socratic small-group discussions, showing significant improvements in perceived educational quality among residents.

Introduction

Traditional medical education has long relied on the "Grand Rounds" format—large-group, passive lectures that often fail to engage mature learners effectively. This pedagogical approach is particularly ill-suited for complex, high-stakes topics like environmental emergencies, which include hypothermia, high-altitude sickness, radiation exposure, and envenomation.

While environmental emergencies account for approximately 4.9% of all Emergency Department visits in the United States, they are frequently under-emphasized in undergraduate medical education. Because these cases are relatively rare in daily practice, emergency physicians must maintain "de facto expertise" to manage them when they do occur. This paper details a curricular shift designed to foster intellectual curiosity and practical application over rote memorization.

Methodology: The Flipped Classroom Model

The curriculum at The Ohio State University (OSU) utilizes a "flipped classroom" approach, which reallocates the time spent on basic knowledge acquisition and higher-order synthesis. The model consists of two distinct phases:

1. Self-Directed Learning

Prior to scheduled classroom sessions, residents are provided with a curated list of resources. These include peer-reviewed journal articles, podcasts, and Free Open Access Medical education (FOAM) blog posts. This phase allows learners to acquire foundational knowledge at their own pace.

2. Active Small-Group Sessions

Classroom time is reserved for 45–60 minute interactive sessions. To ensure high levels of engagement, groups are limited to 20 learners. Faculty facilitators employ the Socratic Method, guiding residents through real-life case studies and targeted prompts. This phase focuses on the synthesis and application of the pre-read material to clinical decision-making.

The curriculum is structured on an 18-month cycle, ensuring that every resident in the three-year program encounters the core content twice.

Curricular Content and Mapping

The curriculum is divided into five distinct modules, each provided as a detailed appendix:

  • Module A: Cold Injury and Hypothermia
  • Module B: Heat-Related Illness
  • Module C: Barotrauma and Altitude-Related Illness
  • Module D: Electrical, Radiation, and Submersion Injuries
  • Module E: Bites and Stings

To ensure educational rigor, the content was mapped directly to the American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM) model curriculum and specific Emergency Medicine Milestones, such as Patient Care 1 (Emergency Stabilization) and Patient Care 4 (Differential Diagnosis).

Results and Learner Engagement

Evaluation data collected from longitudinal surveys of resident cohorts (approximately 50 residents per cycle) indicates a clear preference for the flipped classroom model.

Key findings include:

  • Perceived Quality: Only 26% of residents rated traditional "grand rounds" sessions as good or excellent. In contrast, 60.9% gave the flipped classroom small groups the same high rating.
  • Teaching Effectiveness: Residents rated the teaching methods with an average score exceeding 4.5 out of 5.
  • Qualitative Feedback: Learners noted that the opportunity to remain fully engaged through active questioning made complex topics "more difficult to forget" compared to passive listening.

Discussion and Clinical Insights

The active learning format allows for the exploration of critical clinical nuances that might be glossed over in a standard lecture. For example:

  • Reverse Triage in Lightning Strikes: The curriculum emphasizes that in mass casualty incidents involving lightning, rescuers should prioritize those in respiratory or cardiac arrest—a reversal of standard protocols—because these patients have a high potential for recovery with immediate intervention.
  • The "Afterdrop" Phenomenon: In treating hypothermia, the modules highlight the physiological danger of "core temperature afterdrop," where cold peripheral blood returning to the core can cause cardiac instability during rewarming.

Furthermore, the transition requires a shift in faculty roles from "sage on the stage" to "guide on the side." Success depends on faculty training in Socratic questioning to maintain productive, evidence-based discussions.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the curriculum has been highly successful at OSU, several limitations exist. The current scope focuses exclusively on the Emergency Department setting, omitting pre-hospital (EMS) management. Additionally, as a single-center study, the results may reflect specific institutional cultures.

Future research should focus on multi-center implementation to validate these satisfaction levels across diverse programs. Most importantly, further study is needed to determine if the flipped classroom model leads to improved long-term knowledge retention, better performance on ABEM qualifying exams, and enhanced clinical outcomes in real-world environmental emergencies.

Conclusion

The transition to a flipped classroom model for environmental emergencies represents a significant advancement in Emergency Medicine residency training. By prioritizing active engagement and clinical application, this curriculum provides a robust framework for preparing residents to manage high-stakes, infrequent clinical encounters with confidence and expertise.

Summary updated

Abstract

Audience: This curriculum created and implemented at The Ohio State University Emergency Medicine Residency was designed to educate our emergency medicine (EM
BibTeX
@article{bachmann2019emergency,
  author = {Daniel Bachmann and Sarah Gartner and Andrew J. King and Nicholas Kman and Mary Jo Bowman and Michael Barrie},
  title = {{Emergency Medicine Curriculum Utilizing the Flipped Classroom Method: Environmental Emergencies}},
  journal = {Journal of Education and Teaching in Emergency Medicine},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5070/m542043477},
}
Figure