Emergence and evolution of an interaction between intrinsically disordered proteins

Greta Hultqvist, Emma Åberg, Carlo Camilloni, Gustav N. Sundell, Eva Andersson, Jakob Dogan, N. Celestine, Michele Vendruscolo, Per JemtheLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reconstructs the evolutionary history of a protein-protein interaction between two intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), CID and NCBD. They found that this interaction likely began as a weak, dynamic association and gradually strengthened over millions of years through a combination of sequence changes and structural optimization, demonstrating a plausible mechanism for the evolution of IDP interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are crucial for cellular functions, often mediating interactions with other proteins. However, their lack of stable 3D structure makes it challenging to understand how their interactions evolve at a molecular level. Unlike structured proteins, IDPs are more permissive to mutations, making it difficult to trace evolutionary changes. This paper addresses the fundamental question of how new protein-protein interactions involving IDPs emerge and evolve over evolutionary timescales, specifically focusing on the CID and NCBD domains.

Methods

The researchers employed an "evolutionary biochemistry" approach, which combines several key techniques:

  • Phylogenetic Reconstruction: They used sequence alignments of extant CID and NCBD domains from various species to build phylogenetic trees. This allowed them to infer the likely amino acid sequences of ancestral versions of these domains at different evolutionary nodes.
  • Protein Resurrection: The inferred ancestral protein sequences were synthesized and expressed in E. coli to produce the actual ancestral proteins in the lab.
  • Biophysical Characterization: The resurrected ancestral proteins, along with present-day variants, were subjected to a battery of biophysical experiments, including:
  • Isothermal Titration Calorimetry (ITC): To precisely measure the binding affinity (Kd values) between interacting CID and NCBD variants.
  • Circular Dichroism (CD) Spectroscopy: To assess the secondary structure propensity (e.g., helix formation) and global stability of the proteins under different conditions (e.g., in the presence of helix stabilizers like TFE or denaturants like urea).
  • Molecular Modeling and NMR Spectroscopy: To gain insights into the structural ensembles and dynamics of ancient and extant CID/NCBD complexes. They used NMR chemical shifts as restraints in molecular dynamics simulations to model the conformational landscape of these interactions.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available protein sequences from various species, obtained from databases like Ensembl, NCBI, and JGI Genome Portal. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing sequence data was used for phylogenetic analysis and reconstruction.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gradual Evolution of Affinity: The interaction between CID and NCBD didn't appear fully formed; it evolved from a weak, low-affinity complex (Kd ~ 5 µM) in early deuterostomes to a much tighter interaction (Kd ~ 200 nM) after vertebrate whole-genome duplications.
  • CID Emerged Later: The NCBD domain is ancient, present in the common ancestor of protostomes and deuterostomes, while the CID domain appeared later, after the divergence of these groups.
  • Dynamics and Structure Optimization: The strengthening of the CID/NCBD interaction wasn't just about sequence changes; it involved optimizing both direct interactions and modulating the dynamic properties of the disordered proteins.
  • Tolerance to Mutation: IDPs, particularly in interaction interfaces, exhibit remarkable tolerance to mutations. This plasticity allows for evolutionary adaptation without necessarily disrupting function, a key characteristic that likely facilitates the emergence of new interactions.
  • Multiple Ligands, Multiple Conformations: NCBD can interact with various partners (like p53TAD and IRF-3), potentially adopting different conformations. This suggests that the evolution of CID/NCBD interaction had to be compatible with these other interactions, imposing constraints on evolutionary pathways.

Key Results

  • The most ancient CID/NCBD complex (deuterostome/protostome ancestor) had a low affinity (Kd ~ 5 µM).
  • By the time of the first vertebrate whole-genome duplication (1R/2R), the affinity had increased significantly to ~200 nM, and this higher affinity was maintained in subsequent evolution.
  • Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that as affinity increased, conformational heterogeneity slightly decreased, suggesting a more refined interaction.
  • Experiments with reverse mutations in extant complexes showed a limited impact on affinity, highlighting the plasticity of IDP interactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Ancestral Sequences: For the oldest reconstructed NCBD variant (D/P NCBD), there were several positions with uncertain amino acid identities. The researchers addressed this by testing alternative residues, but it highlights the inherent challenges in reconstructing very ancient sequences.
  • Limited Scope: The study focused on a single protein-protein interaction. While it provides a strong model, generalizing these findings to all IDP interactions would require further studies.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest investigating how other protein-protein interactions have evolved and identifying general patterns. They also aim to understand how this molecular evolution might inform the design of drugs that mimic protein interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Protein-protein interactions involving intrinsically disordered proteins are important for cellular function and common in all organisms. However, it is not clear how such interactions emerge and evolve on a molecular level. We performed phylogenetic reconstruction, resurrection and biophysical characterization of two interacting disordered protein domains, CID and NCBD. CID appeared after the divergence of protostomes and deuterostomes 450-600 million years ago, while NCBD was present in the protostome/deuterostome ancestor. The most ancient CID/NCBD formed a relatively weak complex (<i>K</i><sub>d</sub>∼5 µM). At the time of the first vertebrate-specific whole genome duplication, the affinity had increased (<i>K</i><sub>d</sub>∼200 nM) and was maintained in further speciation. Experiments together with molecular modeling using NMR chemical shifts suggest that new interactions involving intrinsically disordered proteins may evolve via a low-affinity complex which is optimized by modulating direct interactions as well as dynamics, while tolerating several potentially disruptive mutations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hultqvist2017emergence,
  author = {Greta Hultqvist and Emma Åberg and Carlo Camilloni and Gustav N. Sundell and Eva Andersson and Jakob Dogan and N. Celestine and Michele Vendruscolo and Per Jemth},
  title = {{Emergence and evolution of an interaction between intrinsically disordered proteins}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.16059},
}
Figure