Elevation and Human Disturbance Interactively Influence the Patterns of Insect Diversity on the Southeastern Periphery of the Tibetan Plateau

Zhouyang Liao, Jinlu Zhang, Xuemei Shen, Mi Zhu, Xinlin Lan, Junming Cui, Yunfang Guan, Ying Zhang, Zhongjian Deng, Tiantian Tang, Fang Liu, Da‐Rong Yang, Yuan ZhangInsects 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that both elevation and human disturbance significantly impact insect diversity on the Tibetan Plateau, but their interaction is key to understanding these patterns. Insect diversity generally declines with elevation, but the optimal level of human disturbance shifts: low disturbance favors diversity at lower elevations, while moderate disturbance is better at higher elevations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biodiversity is declining globally, and insects, crucial for ecosystem services, are particularly threatened. While elevation and human disturbance are known drivers of biodiversity, most research treats them independently or focuses on single insect groups. This paper addresses the critical need to understand how these two factors interact to shape insect diversity patterns, especially in biodiverse regions like the southeastern Tibetan Plateau, to inform effective conservation strategies.

Methods

The researchers established 50 one-kilometer transects across five distinct elevation gradients (1600-3800m) in the Hengduan Mountains. Human disturbance intensity was classified into three levels (low, moderate, high) using the Integrated Disturbance Index. Insect samples were collected using a sweeping method and identified to family level. Statistical analyses included:

  • Generalized Linear Models (GLMs): To investigate the relationship between insect abundance and elevation/disturbance.
  • Multi-model Inference: To compare four models (elevation only, disturbance only, additive effects, and interactive effects) to determine the best explanatory model for insect diversity.
  • Redundancy Analysis (RDA): To visualize and analyze the similarity of insect communities across different elevation and disturbance gradients.
  • Heatmap Analysis: To examine the responses of different insect taxonomic groups to the combined effects of elevation and disturbance.

Datasets

The study utilized field-collected insect data from 50 transects across the southeastern periphery of the Tibetan Plateau. This dataset, comprising 5141 insects from 13 orders and 80 families, represents a novel compilation for this specific region, focusing on the interplay of elevation and human disturbance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interaction is Crucial: Simply looking at elevation or disturbance alone misses a significant part of the picture. The combined effect is more than the sum of its parts.
  • Elevation's Downward Trend: Insect diversity generally decreases as you go higher up the mountain, likely due to harsher climate conditions.
  • Disturbance's Shifting Role: The "sweet spot" for human disturbance changes with altitude. Low disturbance is best at lower elevations, but moderate disturbance becomes more beneficial at higher elevations. This suggests that at higher altitudes, some level of disturbance might create needed habitat heterogeneity.
  • Taxa Respond Differently: Not all insects are the same! Some groups, like Hymenoptera (bees and wasps), show remarkable adaptability and can maintain high diversity even in challenging high-elevation, disturbed areas, while others prefer more stable, lower-elevation habitats.

Key Results

  • A negative correlation was found between insect diversity and elevation.
  • Moderate human disturbance showed a positive impact on insect diversity to some extent when considered alone.
  • The model incorporating the interaction between elevation and human disturbance provided the best explanatory power for insect diversity patterns (R² = 0.33), significantly outperforming models that considered only elevation or disturbance.
  • Below ~2200m, insect richness was highest under low disturbance. Above ~2200m, moderate disturbance led to higher richness than low disturbance. High disturbance consistently resulted in the lowest richness across all elevations.
  • Heatmap analysis revealed distinct responses of insect groups to elevation-disturbance combinations, with Hymenoptera showing notable adaptability to high elevations and moderate disturbance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their study provides valuable insights, the complexity of insect communities means that further research is warranted. They suggest:

  • Expanding Geographical Scope: To understand broader patterns.
  • Incorporating More Environmental Variables: Beyond just elevation and disturbance, factors like microclimate, soil type, and vegetation structure could offer deeper explanations.
  • Adapting Sampling Methods: To better capture the diversity of different insect groups.
  • Long-Term Studies: To track changes over time and understand the dynamic nature of these interactions.

The study also highlights the need for more comprehensive and long-term research, especially in biodiversity hotspots, to inform effective conservation and management strategies in the face of global change.

Summary updated

Abstract

The maintenance of biodiversity and ecological balance heavily relies on the diversity of insects. In order to investigate the impacts of elevation and human disturbance, as well as their interactions on insect diversity, we conducted an intensive survey of insects in the Hengduan Mountain Range, which is situated on the southeastern periphery of the Tibetan Plateau in China. A total of 50 line transects were established in this study to investigate the impact of elevation and human disturbance on insect diversity and distribution patterns. Designed insect surveys were conducted at various elevations and levels of human disturbance, and statistical methods such as generalized linear modeling and redundancy analysis were employed for data analysis. The results of this study indicated a negative correlation between insect diversity and elevation. Additionally, moderate disturbance was found to have a positive impact on insect diversity to some extent. The explanatory power of the model for the distribution of insect diversity could be improved if elevation and human disturbance were included as an interaction effect into the model, and there were differences in the effects of human disturbances on insect diversity at different elevation levels. The highest insect diversity was observed under low disturbance conditions below elevation of ~2200 m, whereas above this threshold, insect diversity was the highest under moderate disturbance compared to low disturbance. The response of different insect taxa to the interactions of elevation and human disturbance varied. The findings imply that when formulating strategies for managing insect diversity, it is crucial to thoroughly consider the interaction of environmental factors and disturbance response of individual insect taxa.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liao2024elevation,
  author = {Zhouyang Liao and Jinlu Zhang and Xuemei Shen and Mi Zhu and Xinlin Lan and Junming Cui and Yunfang Guan and Ying Zhang and Zhongjian Deng and Tiantian Tang and Fang Liu and Da‐Rong Yang and Yuan Zhang and Yuan Zhang and Yuan Zhang},
  title = {{Elevation and Human Disturbance Interactively Influence the Patterns of Insect Diversity on the Southeastern Periphery of the Tibetan Plateau}},
  booktitle = {Insects},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/insects15090669},
}
Figure