Elementary End of the Periodic Table

Yang‐Hui He, Stavros GaroufalidisinSTEMM 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel, back-of-the-envelope method to estimate the maximum possible atomic number (Zmax) by combining nuclear physics data with fundamental physics limits from quantum gravity. The authors predict that element 168, with an atomic weight of 411, could be the last element in the periodic table, a surprisingly close estimate to more complex theoretical calculations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The existence of a heaviest element, or a maximum atomic number (Zmax), is a fundamental question in physics. While experimental efforts push the boundaries of known elements, theoretical predictions have varied. Early models, like the liquid drop model, suggested limits around Z=100. Later, relativistic effects and more sophisticated nuclear models pushed this limit higher, with some estimates reaching around Z=173. This paper tackles the question of Zmax by seeking an absolute theoretical bound, one that arises from the most fundamental laws of physics, rather than solely from nuclear structure models. They aim to bridge the vast energy scales between nuclear physics and quantum gravity to find this ultimate limit.

Methods

The authors employ a "back-of-the-envelope" approach, inspired by Feynman's method for estimating the fine-structure constant. They combine two key pieces of information:

  1. Maximal Half-Lives of Transuranic Elements: They gather data on the longest-lived isotopes for known transuranic elements (Z=92 and above).
  2. Planck Time as a Fundamental Limit: They use the Planck time ($t_p$), the smallest meaningful unit of time in quantum gravity, as an absolute upper bound for the half-life of any element.

By plotting the natural logarithm of the maximal half-life ($\ln(\tau)$) against atomic number (Z), and similarly plotting atomic weight (W) against Z, they observe linear trends. They then extrapolate these linear fits to the Planck time limit to estimate Zmax.

Datasets

The paper utilizes publicly available data on the longest-lived isotopes of transuranic elements, from Uranium (Z=92) up to Oganesson (Z=118). This data is presented in Table I and forms the basis for their linear extrapolations. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Vast Scales: The most striking insight is the successful application of a quantum gravity limit (Planck time) to a nuclear physics problem (element stability). This interdisciplinary approach is presented as novel.
  • Linear Extrapolation Power: Despite the complexity of nuclear physics, the maximal half-life and atomic weight of heavy elements appear to follow surprisingly simple linear trends with respect to atomic number, at least within the observed range.
  • Planck Time as an Absolute Bound: The Planck time, derived from fundamental constants like G and ħ, provides a theoretically grounded upper limit that transcends specific nuclear models.
  • A Surprisingly Low Zmax: The estimate of Zmax ~ 168 is presented as "surprisingly low and reasonable," especially when compared to the potential limits suggested by purely relativistic nuclear models.

Key Results

The paper's primary quantitative results are:

  • Estimated Zmax: The authors estimate the end of the periodic table to be at atomic number Z = 168.
  • Estimated Atomic Weight: For Z=168, they predict the most stable isotope to have an atomic weight of W = 411.
  • Linear Fit Equations:
    • $\ln(\tau) \approx 195.68 - 1.76Z$
    • $W \approx 25.43 + 2.30Z$

These results are presented as being remarkably close to current best estimates from more sophisticated Hartree-Fock calculations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Back-of-the-Envelope" Nature: The authors acknowledge that their method is a "quick estimate" and not a rigorous derivation. The linear extrapolation, while visually compelling, might not hold true for extremely high atomic numbers beyond the current experimental reach.
  • Alternative Time Scales: The paper briefly mentions that using a nuclear physics-defined "existence" time scale (around $10^{-14}$ seconds) would yield a much lower Zmax (~129), highlighting the sensitivity to the chosen time limit.
  • Need for Sophisticated Methods: For more precise predictions, especially within the energy scales of nuclear physics, the authors state that "more sophisticated Hartree-Fock methods are needed."
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further exploration of the interplay between fundamental physics limits and nuclear structure could refine these predictions. The authors also mention similar extrapolations in the context of string theory landscapes, hinting at broader applications of their methodology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using the Planck scale as an absolute bound of half-life, we give a quick estimate, in the manner of Feynman's fine-structure method, of the highest possible atomic number. We find, upon simple extrapolation, that element 168 would constitute the end of the Periodic Table and its isotope with atomic weight 411, being the most stable. These are remarkably close to current best estimates obtained from sophisticated and much more involved Hartree-Fock calculations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2022elementary,
  author = {Yang‐Hui He and Stavros Garoufalidis},
  title = {{Elementary End of the Periodic Table}},
  booktitle = {inSTEMM},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.56725/instemm.v1is1.6},
}
Figure