Elektron und Gravitation. I

Hermann WeylZeitschrift f�r Physik 1929 · DOI

This foundational 1929 paper by Hermann Weyl, "Electrons and Gravitation. I," is a landmark in theoretical physics. It is the birth of the modern concept of gauge invariance and provides the mathematical bridge that allows us to describe quantum particles (spinors) within the curved spacetime of General Relativity.

TL;DR

Weyl introduces the "tetrad" (axis-cross) formalism to incorporate Dirac’s electron into General Relativity, discovering that the electromagnetic field is not a property of gravity, but a necessary consequence of the local phase symmetry of the electron's wave function. This work laid the cornerstone for the Standard Model of particle physics by establishing gauge invariance as a fundamental symmetry of nature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In 1929, physics faced a massive rift. Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) described gravity through the geometry of spacetime, while Dirac’s new equation described the electron as a quantum wave function ($\psi$). However, these two theories didn't speak the same language. GR used tensors, which are fine for describing "large" objects, but spinors (the mathematical objects representing electrons) do not fit into the standard tensor framework of GR.

Furthermore, Einstein was attempting to unify gravity and electricity through a theory called "teleparallelism." Weyl sought a more natural connection. He also wanted to address a perceived flaw in Dirac’s theory: it used four components for the wave function, which Weyl felt predicted "twice too many energy levels." He aimed to see if a simpler, two-component theory could work.

Methods

Weyl employs several novel mathematical and physical approaches:

  • The Tetrad Formalism (Normal Axis-Crosses): Instead of relying solely on the metric tensor ($g_{\mu\nu}$), Weyl attaches a local, orthogonal coordinate system (an "axis-cross") to every point in spacetime. This allows him to define how a spinor transforms as it moves through curved space.
  • Two-Component Spinor Theory: He explores a version of the wave function with only two components. He notes that this requires giving up left-right symmetry (parity), a bold move that predated the experimental discovery of parity violation by decades.
  • Local Gauge Invariance: Weyl generalizes his earlier (1918) ideas about "gauge" (scale) invariance. He realizes that if the physics must remain the same even if we change the phase of the wave function ($e^{i\lambda}$) independently at every point in space, we are forced to introduce a vector potential. This potential turns out to be exactly the electromagnetic field.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a purely theoretical work focused on the mathematical foundations of field theory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Loosening" of Spacetime: Weyl argues that we should be able to rotate our local reference frames (the axis-crosses) independently at different points. This "loosening" of the connection between points is what necessitates the existence of the electromagnetic field to "compensate" for these changes.
  • Electricity as a Matter Phenomenon: Weyl explicitly rejects Einstein's teleparallelism. He concludes that electricity is a phenomenon that accompanies the wave-field of matter, not the gravitational field itself.
  • Symmetry and Conservation: He demonstrates that the symmetry of the energy-impulse tensor is a direct consequence of the theory's invariance under rotations of the local axis-crosses.
  • Mass from Gravity: Weyl suggests that mass might not be a fundamental constant in the Dirac equation but could instead emerge from the interaction between the wave field and the gravitational field.

Key Results

  • Derivation of Maxwell’s Equations: Weyl shows that the Maxwell equations and the conservation of electric charge follow directly from the requirement of gauge invariance.
  • Spinors in Curved Space: He provides the first consistent mathematical framework for defining the covariant derivative of a spinor, allowing quantum mechanics to be calculated in a gravitational field.
  • Gravitational Action Density: He reformulates the action for gravitation ($g$) using the tetrad field, showing it differs from the standard scalar curvature ($r$) only by a divergence, making them equivalent for the laws of motion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parity Violation: Weyl’s two-component theory eliminates the symmetry between left and right. He acknowledges that if nature is truly symmetric, a second pair of components (returning to Dirac’s four-component model) would be necessary.
  • Quantization: The paper deals with "classical" field equations. Weyl notes that the full physical meaning—especially regarding the behavior of particles and light—will only emerge once these equations are quantized.
  • The Proton Problem: Weyl mentions that a complete theory must eventually incorporate the proton as a separate wave field with its own gauge invariance, potentially leading to a "two-fold gauge invariance."

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{weyl1929elektron,
  author = {Hermann Weyl},
  title = {{Elektron und Gravitation. I}},
  booktitle = {Zeitschrift f�r Physik},
  year = {1929},
  doi = {10.1007/bf01339504},
}
Figure