Electroweakino Searches: A Comparative Study for LHC and ILC (A Snowmass White Paper)

M. Berggren, Tao Han, Jenny List, S. Padhi, Shufang Su, T. TanabearXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We present a systematic and comparative study of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC) regarding electroweakino searches within the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). Adopting a general bottom-up approach, we scan parameter regions for Bino-, Wino-, and Higgsino-like lightest supersymmetric particles (LSPs). Our analysis indicates that electroweakino signals from pair production and subsequent decay to $Wh$ ($h \to b\bar{b}$) final states can yield a 95% C.L. exclusion sensitivity for mass scales $M_2, \mu \sim 250\text{--}400$ GeV at the 14 TeV LHC with 300 fb⁻¹. Combining all decay channels, this exclusion reach extends to $M_2, \mu \sim 480\text{--}700$ GeV. Conversely, the ILC is capable of discovering electroweakinos immediately upon crossing the kinematical threshold, allowing for high-precision studies of their properties.

Introduction

Supersymmetry (SUSY) remains a leading candidate for physics beyond the Standard Model, offering solutions to the hierarchy problem and providing viable dark matter candidates. While the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has set stringent limits on "colored" SUSY particles like squarks and gluinos—often pushing their masses above 1 TeV—the "electroweak" sector remains a critical frontier. This sector consists of charginos and neutralinos, collectively known as electroweakinos. These particles are expected to be lighter than their colored counterparts but are significantly more challenging to detect due to their lower production cross-sections and complex background environments.

The Challenge of Electroweakino Detection

Electroweakinos do not interact via the strong force, leading to production rates much lower than those of squarks or gluinos. Furthermore, many theoretically motivated SUSY models predict "compressed spectra," where the mass differences between new particles are small. In such scenarios, decay products are often too soft (low energy) to be easily distinguished from Standard Model backgrounds at a hadron collider like the LHC.

Methodology: A Bottom-Up Approach

To evaluate the discovery potential of future experiments, this study employs a "bottom-up" scan of the MSSM parameter space. The scan focuses on four fundamental variables: $M_1$ (Bino mass), $M_2$ (Wino mass), $\mu$ (Higgsino mass), and $\tan \beta$ (the ratio of Higgs vacuum expectation values). Based on the composition of the Lightest Supersymmetric Particle (LSP), the physics is categorized into six distinct scenarios.

Overview of the six electroweakino decay scenarios (AI-CII) based on the composition of the Lightest Supersymmetric Particle (LSP).

For the LHC simulations, the authors modeled a 14 TeV center-of-mass energy with 300 fb⁻¹ of integrated luminosity using MADGRAPH and PYTHIA for event generation, and Delphes for detector simulation. The ILC was modeled as a 500 GeV $e^+e^-$ collider, utilizing Initial State Radiation (ISR) tagging to identify events with small mass splittings.

Comparative Results: LHC vs. ILC

LHC Reach and the Role of the Higgs

A key innovation in this study is the use of the Higgs boson as a discovery tool. With the Higgs mass known to be 125 GeV, the decay channel $NLSP \to LSP + h$ (where $h \to b\bar{b}$) provides a "standard candle" for identifying electroweakino decay chains. At the 14 TeV LHC, the combined analysis of various channels (tri-leptons, opposite-sign dileptons, and $Wh$) allows for a 95% C.L. exclusion of Wino- or Higgsino-like scales up to 480–700 GeV. For a definitive $5\sigma$ discovery, the reach is approximately 320–500 GeV.

ILC Precision and Compressed Spectra

The ILC offers a complementary environment. While the LHC provides a higher energy reach for specific signatures, it is often "blind" to compressed scenarios. The ILC can discover electroweakinos essentially up to its kinematic threshold ($\sqrt{s}/2 \approx 250$ GeV). More importantly, the clean environment of a lepton collider allows for the measurement of masses and couplings with $O(1\%)$ precision. This level of accuracy is essential for reconstructing the underlying parameters of the SUSY Lagrangian, a task that is nearly impossible at the LHC.

Conclusion

The search for electroweakinos requires a multi-faceted experimental approach. While the LHC will continue to push the energy frontier, reaching up to ~800 GeV with High-Luminosity upgrades, the ILC is indispensable for precision measurements and exploring compressed mass regions. The synergy between these two machines is vital for a complete understanding of the electroweak sector in the MSSM.

Summary updated

Abstract

We make a systematic and comparative study for the LHC and ILC for the electroweakino searches in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model. We adopt a general bottom-up approach and scan over the parameter regions for all the three cases of the lightest supersymmetric particle being Bino-, Wino-, and Higgsino-like. The electroweakino signal from pair production and subsequent decay to Wh (h to b\bar b) final state may yield a sensitivity of 95% C.L. exclusion (5sigma discovery) to the mass scale M_2, mu ~ 250-400 GeV (200-250 GeV) at the 14 TeV LHC with an luminosity of 300 fb^{-1}. Combining with all the other decay channels, the 95% C.L. exclusion (5sigma discovery) may be extended to M_2, mu ~ 480-700 GeV (320-500 GeV). At the ILC, the electroweakinos could be readily discovered once the kinematical threshold is crossed, and their properties could be thoroughly studied.
BibTeX
@misc{berggren2013electroweakino,
  author = {M. Berggren and Tao Han and Jenny List and S. Padhi and Shufang Su and T. Tanabe},
  title = {{Electroweakino Searches: A Comparative Study for LHC and ILC (A Snowmass White Paper)}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1309.7342},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1309.7342},
}
Figure