Electronic Structure, Optical Properties, and Photoelectrochemical Activity of Sn-Doped Fe2O3 Thin Films

Chengming Tian, Weiwei Li, Yuktsun Lin, Zhenzhong Yang, Le Wang, Yingge Du, Haiyan Xiao, Liang Qiao, J. Y. Zhang, Lei Chen, Dongchen Qi, Judith L. MacManus‐Driscoll, Kelvin H. L. ZhangThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how tin (Sn) doping affects the electronic structure, optical properties, and photoelectrochemical (PEC) performance of hematite (Fe₂O₃) thin films. They found that a small amount of Sn doping (0.2%) significantly boosts PEC water splitting activity by improving conductivity and charge separation, while higher doping levels are detrimental. This work sheds light on the mechanism behind Sn doping's effectiveness, crucial for developing efficient solar water splitting technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solar water splitting, a promising route to sustainable hydrogen production, relies on efficient semiconductor photoelectrodes. Hematite (α-Fe₂O₃) is an attractive candidate due to its abundance, stability, and favorable bandgap. However, its poor electrical conductivity and sluggish oxygen evolution kinetics limit its performance. While tin (Sn) doping is known to enhance Fe₂O₃'s PEC activity, the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. This study aims to elucidate the relationship between Sn doping, the electronic and optical properties of Fe₂O₃, and its resulting PEC performance, particularly focusing on the optimal doping concentration and the reasons for performance degradation at higher levels.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize Sn-doped Fe₂O₃ thin films:

  • Pulsed Laser Deposition (PLD): This technique was used to grow highly crystalline, well-controlled epitaxial Sn-doped Fe₂O₃ thin films on Al₂O₃ substrates. This controlled growth is crucial for understanding fundamental properties.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Used to determine the crystal structure and epitaxial relationship of the films.
  • UV-Visible Spectroscopy: To measure optical absorption properties.
  • Van der Pauw Method: For electrical resistivity and conductivity measurements as a function of temperature.
  • X-ray Photoemission Spectroscopy (XPS) and X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS): To probe the electronic structure, chemical states, and valence band/conduction band features.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) + U Calculations: To complement experimental findings and provide theoretical insights into the electronic structure and the origin of observed phenomena.
  • Photoelectrochemical (PEC) Measurements: Including linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) under simulated solar illumination and Mott-Schottky analysis to evaluate PEC activity, flat-band potentials, and carrier concentrations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental synthesis and characterization of novel materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Optimal Sn Doping is Crucial: The most striking finding is that only a small amount of Sn doping (0.2%) significantly enhances PEC activity. This highlights a delicate balance where too much doping can be detrimental, a common theme in semiconductor doping.
  • Small Polaron Hopping (SPH) Dominates Conduction: Sn doping dramatically improves conductivity, but the mechanism is identified as SPH, not simple band conduction. This implies that charge transport occurs via hopping of localized charge carriers (polarons), influenced by lattice distortions.
  • Localized Fe²⁺ Gap State: The introduction of a localized Fe²⁺-like gap state at the top of the valence band is identified as the key feature enabling SPH conduction. This state is created by the Sn⁴⁺ dopant, which donates an electron, reducing neighboring Fe³⁺ to Fe²⁺.
  • Band Bending and Space Charge Layer Trade-off: Increased Sn doping leads to a larger band bending potential, which aids charge separation. However, it also significantly reduces the width of the space charge layer, potentially limiting the number of photogenerated carriers within this critical region. This presents a fundamental trade-off in optimizing PEC performance.
  • Fermi Level Shift: As expected for n-type doping, the Fermi level (E_f) shifts towards the conduction band minimum with increasing Sn concentration.

Key Results

  • Conductivity Enhancement: Sn doping substantially increases the n-type conductivity of Fe₂O₃.
  • Reduced Activation Energy: The activation energy for SPH conduction is significantly reduced from ~0.52-0.7 eV for undoped Fe₂O₃ to 0.14 eV for 0.2% Sn-doped films.
  • Optimal PEC Activity at 0.2% Sn: The photocurrent density at 1.4 V vs. RHE is enhanced from 0.23 mA/cm² for undoped Fe₂O₃ to 0.52 mA/cm² for 0.2% Sn-doped films. Higher Sn concentrations (0.8% and 3%) lead to a decrease in PEC activity.
  • Increased Band Bending: 0.2% Sn doping results in a larger band bending potential (ΔΦ) compared to undoped Fe₂O₃, facilitating charge separation.
  • Reduced Space Charge Layer Width: Higher Sn doping (3%) drastically reduces the space charge layer width from 34 nm to 8 nm.
  • Sn Solubility Limit: The solubility of Sn in Fe₂O₃ is limited to approximately 3% atomic ratio, beyond which a SnO₂ secondary phase forms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solubility Limit: The formation of a SnO₂ secondary phase at higher doping levels limits the effectiveness of Sn as a dopant within the Fe₂O₃ lattice.
  • Trade-off in Space Charge Layer: The study highlights a trade-off between increased band bending and reduced space charge layer width. Future work could explore strategies like gradient Sn doping to create an additional electric field, potentially overcoming this limitation.
  • Carrier Dynamics: The authors suggest that further systematic studies on photoexcited charge carrier dynamics, linking electronic structure to PEC activity, would yield valuable insights. This could involve techniques like transient absorption spectroscopy to understand how the Fe²⁺ states influence carrier behavior.
  • Doping Engineering: The findings provide insights into doping engineering for simple, stable systems like Fe₂O₃ to achieve more efficient solar water splitting. This could inspire similar investigations into other metal oxide semiconductors.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p>Hematite (Fe2O3) is a well-known oxide semiconductor suitable for photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting and industry gas sensing. It is widely known that Sn doping of Fe2O3 can enhance the device performance, yet the underlying mechanism remains elusive. In this work, we determine the relationship between electronic structure, optical properties, and PEC activity of Sn-doped Fe2O3 by studying highly crystalline, well-controlled thin films prepared by pulsed laser deposition (PLD). We show that Sn doping substantially increases the n-type conductivity of Fe2O3, and the conduction mechanism is better described by a small-polaron hopping (SPH) model. Only 0.2% Sn doping significantly reduces the activation energy barrier for SPH conduction from at least 0.5 eV for undoped Fe2O3 to 0.14 eV for doped ones. A combination of X-ray photoemission, X-ray absorption spectroscopy, and DFT calculations reveals that the Fermi level gradually shifts toward the conduction band minimum with Sn doping. A localized Fe2+-like gap state is observed at the top of the valence band, accounting for the SPH conduction. Interestingly, different from the literature, only 0.2% Sn doping in Fe2O3 significantly improves the PEC activity, while more Sn decreases it. The improved PEC activity is partially attributed to an increased band bending potential which facilitates the charge separation at the space charge region. The reduced activation energy barrier for SPH will facilitate the transport of photoexcited carriers for the enhanced PEC, which is of interest for further carrier dynamics study. </p>
BibTeX
@article{tian2020electronic,
  author = {Chengming Tian and Weiwei Li and Yuktsun Lin and Zhenzhong Yang and Le Wang and Yingge Du and Haiyan Xiao and Liang Qiao and J. Y. Zhang and Lei Chen and Dongchen Qi and Judith L. MacManus‐Driscoll and Kelvin H. L. Zhang},
  title = {{Electronic Structure, Optical Properties, and Photoelectrochemical Activity of Sn-Doped Fe<sub>2</sub>O<sub>3</sub> Thin Films}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.0c02875},
}
Figure