Electronic-Structure-Driven Magnetic and Structure Transitions in Superconducting NaFeAs Single Crystals Measured by Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy

C. He, Yiting Zhang, B. P. Xie, Xiangfeng Wang, L. X. Yang, Bo Zhou, F. Chen, Masashi Arita, K. Shimada, H. Namatame, M. Taniguchi, X. H. Chen, Jiangping Hu, D. L. FengPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The electronic structure of NaFeAs is studied with angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy on high quality single crystals. Large portions of the band structure start to shift around the structural transition temperature and smoothly evolve as the temperature lowers through the spin density wave transition. Moreover, band folding due to magnetic order emerges slightly above the structural transition. Our observation provides direct evidence that the structural and magnetic transitions share the same origin and could both be driven by the electronic structure reconstruction in Fe-based superconductors instead of Fermi surface nesting. We did not observe any sign of a gap in the superconducting state, which is likely related to weakened superconductivity in the presence of the spin density wave.

The "Identity Crisis" of Iron-Based Superconductors

In the field of high-temperature superconductivity, iron-based pnictides are known for a complex series of phase transitions. As these materials cool, they typically undergo a structural transition (lattice distortion) and a magnetic transition (forming a Spin Density Wave, or SDW) before reaching the superconducting state. In many compounds, these transitions occur simultaneously, making it difficult to isolate the underlying physics. NaFeAs is a unique "laboratory" because these transitions are separated: the structural transition occurs at $T_S = 54$ K and the magnetic transition at $T_N = 39$ K. This separation allows researchers to probe the electronic state in the intermediate regime to determine whether the lattice, the magnetism, or a deeper electronic mechanism is the primary driver.

Mapping the Electronic Landscape with ARPES

To investigate this, researchers employed Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES) on high-quality NaFeAs single crystals. ARPES measures the energy and momentum of electrons ejected from the material by high-energy photons, effectively mapping the "band structure"—the allowed energy states for electrons.

Figure 1: ARPES intensity maps and energy-momentum dispersions of NaFeAs at 10 K, identifying the complex band structure near the Fermi level.

The study achieved high energy (9 meV) and angular (0.3°) resolution, allowing for the detection of subtle band shifts. By comparing experimental results with theoretical Local Density Approximation (LDA) calculations, the team found that electrons in NaFeAs are "heavy," with experimental bands being 5.4 to 6.5 times narrower than predicted, indicating strong electron-electron correlations.

The Electronic Engine of Phase Transitions

The most significant insight from the ARPES data is that large portions of the band structure—including states deep below the Fermi level—begin to shift precisely at the structural transition temperature ($T_S$). This suggests that the electronic system is the primary "engine" driving the physical changes in the material, rather than just reacting to them.

Furthermore, the data challenges the long-standing "Fermi surface nesting" theory. Nesting suggests that instabilities arise when specific parts of the Fermi surface match up. However, the observed reconstruction involves the entire band structure, and no characteristic "nesting gap" was found at the Fermi level. Additionally, "band folding"—a hallmark of magnetic order—was observed starting at $T_S$, well above the official magnetic transition at $T_N$. This implies that short-range magnetic fluctuations are already reorganizing the electronic structure before long-range magnetic order is established.

Quantifying the Shift

The researchers tracked the evolution of specific bands as a function of temperature. A key result is the behavior of the $eta$ band, which shifts downward by approximately 16 meV as the material cools.

Figure 4: Temperature evolution of the electronic states, showing band shifts that begin at the structural transition ($T_S$) and evolve through the magnetic transition ($T_N$).

Crucially, about 12 meV of this shift occurs before the magnetic transition begins. Calculations show that this shift is far too large to be explained by the minor (0.36%) distortion of the crystal lattice alone. The smooth evolution of these changes from $T_S$ downward confirms that the structural and magnetic transitions share a common electronic origin.

Implications and Future Directions

This work provides compelling evidence that electronic structure reconstruction, rather than Fermi surface nesting or simple lattice effects, drives the phase transitions in the "111" family of iron-based superconductors. While this scenario is clear for NaFeAs, other families like the "1111" series (e.g., LaOFeAs) remain challenging to measure due to surface effects. Future research will focus on the universality of this mechanism and the specific microscopic interactions—likely local magnetic exchange—that cause the bands to shift in this characteristic manner.

Summary updated

Abstract

The electronic structure of NaFeAs is studied with angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy on high quality single crystals. Large portions of the band structure start to shift around the structural transition temperature and smoothly evolve as the temperature lowers through the spin density wave transition. Moreover, band folding due to magnetic order emerges slightly above the structural transition. Our observation provides direct evidence that the structural and magnetic transitions share the same origin and could both be driven by the electronic structure reconstruction in Fe-based superconductors instead of Fermi surface nesting. We did not observe any sign of a gap in the superconducting state, which is likely related to weakened superconductivity in the presence of the spin density wave.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2010electronic,
  author = {C. He and Yiting Zhang and B. P. Xie and Xiangfeng Wang and L. X. Yang and Bo Zhou and F. Chen and Masashi Arita and K. Shimada and H. Namatame and M. Taniguchi and X. H. Chen and Jiangping Hu and D. L. Feng},
  title = {{Electronic-Structure-Driven Magnetic and Structure Transitions in Superconducting NaFeAs Single Crystals Measured by Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.105.117002},
}
Figure