Electron Tomography Analysis of Thylakoid Assembly and Fission in Chloroplasts of a Single-Cell C4 plant, Bienertia sinuspersici

Keith Ka Ki, Wai-Tsun Yeung, Sang-Yun Han, Xiaohao Cai, Inhwan Hwang, Byung‐Ho KangScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses electron tomography to reveal the intricate process of thylakoid assembly and division within chloroplasts of the single-cell C4 plant Bienertia sinuspersici. The findings highlight a novel mechanism for thylakoid growth via inner envelope membrane invaginations and provide the first detailed visualization of thylakoid fission during chloroplast division, suggesting a specialized machinery for this process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a fundamental gap in our understanding of chloroplast biogenesis and division, specifically concerning the dynamic remodeling of thylakoid membranes. While C4 photosynthesis is known to involve specialized chloroplasts, the precise mechanisms by which these organelles grow and divide, particularly the partitioning of their complex internal thylakoid networks, remain poorly understood. Bienertia sinuspersici is a unique model system because its chlorenchyma cells develop two distinct types of chloroplasts (central and peripheral) that undergo significant structural changes during maturation. This provides an exceptional opportunity to observe chloroplast development and division in a context relevant to C4 photosynthesis, moving beyond studies on less differentiated proplastids. The authors aim to elucidate how thylakoids assemble and how this complex membrane system is successfully divided to ensure functional chloroplasts in daughter cells.

Methods

The core technique employed is electron tomography (ET), a powerful 3D imaging method that allows for high-resolution visualization of cellular ultrastructure. This was combined with transmission electron microscopy (TEM) for detailed 2D imaging.

  • High-pressure freezing and freeze substitution: This standard cryo-fixation technique was crucial for preserving the delicate thylakoid structures in a near-native state, minimizing artifacts from chemical fixation.
  • Electron Tomography (ET): Samples were subjected to ET to acquire tilt series of electron micrographs, which were then computationally reconstructed into 3D volumes. This allowed for detailed morphometric analysis of membranous compartments.
  • 3D Model Generation: Software was used to generate 3D models of thylakoid membranes and envelope membranes from the tomographic data, enabling visualization of complex spatial relationships.
  • Immunogold Labeling: This technique was used in conjunction with TEM to localize specific proteins (e.g., PsbP, a subunit of Photosystem II) within the chloroplast, providing insights into the molecular players involved in thylakoid remodeling during division.
  • Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopy: Used for initial observation of chloroplast distribution and chlorophyll autofluorescence across different developmental stages.

The novelty lies in the application of ET to visualize these dynamic processes in Bienertia chloroplasts, particularly the detailed depiction of thylakoid assembly via IEM invaginations and the first direct visualization of thylakoid fission during chloroplast division.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on direct observation of cellular structures using microscopy techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Thylakoid Assembly via Inner Envelope Membrane (IEM) Invaginations: The study provides strong evidence that chloroplast enlargement is not solely due to existing thylakoid growth but also involves invaginations from the inner envelope membrane. These invaginations appear to bud off and fuse with the existing thylakoid network, contributing new membrane material. This offers a novel perspective on how chloroplasts expand their photosynthetic capacity.
  • Differential Thylakoid Remodeling in Central vs. Peripheral Chloroplasts: As Bienertia cells mature, central chloroplasts (CCs) develop more elaborate grana stacks with increased layers, while peripheral chloroplasts (PCs) exhibit stretched grana stacks where the distinction between grana and stroma thylakoids becomes blurred. This structural dimorphism is directly linked to their distinct roles in C4 photosynthesis.
  • First Visualization of Thylakoid Fission: The paper presents the first detailed images of thylakoids being kinked, disrupted, and severed within the cleavage furrow of dividing chloroplasts. This observation strongly suggests the existence of a specialized thylakoid fission machinery, distinct from the envelope division machinery.
  • Dislocation of Photosystem II (PSII) Complexes During Fission: During thylakoid division, large complexes, hypothesized to be PSII, were observed to be dislocated from the disrupted grana stacks. Immunogold labeling experiments in Arabidopsis confirmed the absence of PSII components in the constricted division zone, supporting the idea that PSII is actively removed or repositioned before thylakoid severing.
  • Bienertia as a Model for Chloroplast Division Studies: The congregated arrangement of chloroplasts in the central cytoplasm of Bienertia chlorenchyma cells makes them an ideal system for observing and capturing dividing chloroplasts, overcoming challenges faced in other plant systems.

Key Results

  • Chloroplast numbers and sizes significantly increase during the maturation of Bienertia chlorenchyma cells, particularly between the 3rd and mature stages.
  • ET revealed that thylakoid volume increases more rapidly than chloroplast volume, indicating active thylakoid biogenesis.
  • Invaginations from the IEM were observed to contribute to thylakoid assembly, forming precursors that integrate into the thylakoid network.
  • Mature central chloroplasts (CCs) typically have grana stacks with 2-11 layers, while mature peripheral chloroplasts (PCs) show stretched grana stacks.
  • Dividing chloroplasts exhibit kinked and severed thylakoids at the division site, with grana stacks being disrupted.
  • Immunogold labeling in Arabidopsis showed the absence of PSII components in the constricted division zone of dividing chloroplasts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Thylakoid Fission Machinery: While the study provides strong visual evidence for thylakoid fission and PSII dislocation, the precise molecular components and mechanisms of the thylakoid fission machinery remain to be fully elucidated. The authors speculate on the involvement of dynamin-related proteins (like FZL) and coordination with envelope division machinery.
  • Mitochondrial Association: The paper notes the vital role of mitochondria in NAD-ME type C4 photosynthesis in Bienertia and suggests that further characterization of mitochondria associated with the tightly packed CCs is needed.
  • Generalizability of Findings: While the study provides detailed insights into Bienertia, further investigations using similar cryo-preservation and ET techniques in other plant species are warranted to assess the generalizability of the observed thylakoid assembly and fission mechanisms.
  • Chemical Fixation Artifacts: The authors acknowledge that chemical fixation might not fully preserve transient and fragile subcellular structures, suggesting that high-pressure freezing is crucial for capturing such events. However, even with cryo-preservation, some aspects of the dynamic process might be challenging to capture completely.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Bienertia sinuspersici is a single-cell C4 plant species of which chlorenchyma cells have two distinct groups of chloroplasts spatially segregated in the cytoplasm. The central vacuole encloses most chloroplasts at the cell center and confines the rest of the chloroplasts near the plasma membrane. Young chlorenchyma cells, however, do not have large vacuoles and their chloroplasts are homogenous. Therefore, maturing Bienertia chlorenchyma cells provide a unique opportunity to investigate chloroplast proliferation in the central cluster and the remodeling of chloroplasts that have been displaced by the vacuole to the cell periphery. Chloroplast numbers and sizes increased, more notably, during later stages of maturation than the early stages. Electron tomography analyses indicated that chloroplast enlargement is sustained by thylakoid growth and that invaginations from the inner envelope membrane contributed to thylakoid assembly. Grana stacks acquired more layers, differentiating them from stroma thylakoids as central chloroplasts matured. In peripheral chloroplasts, however, grana stacks stretched out to a degree that the distinction between grana stacks and stroma thylakoids was obscured. In central chloroplasts undergoing division, thylakoids inside the cleavage furrow were kinked and severed. Grana stacks in the division zone were disrupted, and large complexes in their membranes were dislocated, suggesting the existence of a thylakoid fission machinery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ki2019electron,
  author = {Keith Ka Ki and Wai-Tsun Yeung and Sang-Yun Han and Xiaohao Cai and Inhwan Hwang and Byung‐Ho Kang},
  title = {{Electron Tomography Analysis of Thylakoid Assembly and Fission in Chloroplasts of a Single-Cell C4 plant, Bienertia sinuspersici}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-56083-w},
}

Loading related content...

Figure