Abstract: In 1960, researchers at Keio University utilized then-novel electron microscopy (EM) techniques to explore the ultrastructure of immune cells within human palatine tonsils. By developing a refined "ultrathin slice" method, the study provided early visual evidence of the internal machinery of plasma cells and lymphocytes. The findings linked the presence of extensive intracytoplasmic sacs (rough endoplasmic reticulum) to protein synthesis and antibody production, distinguishing the functionally active plasma cell from the structurally simpler lymphocyte.
Introduction
The mid-20th century marked a pivotal transition in histology as researchers moved beyond the limitations of light microscopy. While the role of palatine tonsils in immunity was recognized, the "resolving power" of traditional microscopes could not reveal the cellular mechanisms responsible for antibody production. This 1960 study sought to bridge this gap by applying electron microscopy to human tonsil tissue, a task previously hindered by technical difficulties in fixation and sectioning.
Methods and Technical Innovation
The researchers employed a state-of-the-art "ultrathin slice" protocol to prepare human tissues for EM. Key steps included:
- Fixation: Tissues were fixed in 2% osmic acid with a phosphate buffer (pH 7.4), later improved with saccharose to maintain isotonicity and prevent tissue rupture.
- Embedding and Polymerization: Samples were dehydrated in ethanol and embedded in a methacrylate monomer mixture (methyl and n-butyl methacrylate), then polymerized at 50–55°C.
- Sectioning: Ultra-thin sections were achieved using a Shimazu-type microtome with glass knives, which offered superior precision over traditional metal blades.
- Imaging: Observations were conducted using a Hitachi type H-S 5 electron microscope.
Clinical Samples
The study utilized clinical samples obtained from pediatric patients at Keio University Hospital. Specifically, palatine tonsils were removed from five children, aged 6 to 9, who were undergoing treatment for tonsillar hypertrophy. The clinical profiles of these subjects provided the baseline for the pathological investigation.
Key Insights into Cellular Ultrastructure
The EM observations provided several breakthroughs in understanding immune cell morphology:
- The Protein "Factory": Plasma cells were found to be densely packed with "intracytoplasmic sacs"—now identified as the rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER). The authors correctly hypothesized that these structures were the primary sites for protein (antibody) synthesis.
- Russel Bodies: The study offered a morphological explanation for Russel bodies, suggesting they form when these sacs become engorged with synthesized proteins and fuse, eventually displacing the cell nucleus.
- Nuclear Patterns: The "spoke-wheel" nuclear pattern often seen in plasma cells under light microscopy was revealed by EM to be an aggregation of fine granules on the inner surface of the nuclear membrane.
- Functional Differentiation: Comparing cell types showed that while lymphocytes were more numerous, plasma cells possessed a far more complex Golgi apparatus and RER, marking them as the specialized "factories" of the tonsil.
Results
The study documented specific measurements and structures:
- Granule Size: Granules lining the intracytoplasmic sacs in plasma cells were measured at approximately 20–25 nm in diameter.
- Lymphocyte Simplicity: Lymphocytes exhibited a high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio but lacked the extensive sac system of plasma cells, containing only scattered mitochondria and granules.
- Organelle Detail: The researchers successfully imaged centrioles near the Golgi area and documented cristae mitochondriales, confirming that the energy-producing structures in tonsil cells were consistent with other human tissues.
Limitations and Conclusion
Despite its successes, the study faced significant technical hurdles. The authors noted that "beautiful micrographs are very difficult to obtain constantly" due to potential fixation artifacts, particularly regarding the Golgi apparatus. Furthermore, they acknowledged the challenge of inferring dynamic biological functions from static EM images. Nevertheless, this work laid a critical foundation for immunopathology, providing some of the first high-resolution glimpses into the cellular basis of human immunity.
Summary updated