Electron exchange coupling for single-donor solid-state spin qubits

Cameron Wellard, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg, F. Parisoli, Louise Olsen‐Kettle, Hsi‐Sheng Goan, John A.l. McIntosh, David N. JamiesonPhysical 2003 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Intervalley interference between degenerate conduction band minima has been shown to lead to oscillations in the exchange energy between neighboring phosphorus donor electron states in silicon. These same effects lead to an extreme sensitivity of the exchange energy on the relative orientation of the donor atoms, an issue of crucial importance in the construction of silicon-based spin quantum computers. In this article we calculate the donor electron exchange coupling as a function of donor position incorporating the full Bloch structure of the Kohn-Luttinger electron wave functions. It is found that due to the rapidly oscillating nature of the terms they produce, the periodic part of the Bloch functions can be safely ignored in the Heitler-London integrals, significantly reducing the complexity of calculations. We address issues of fabrication and calculate the expected exchange coupling between neighboring donors that have been implanted into the silicon substrate using an 15 keV ion beam in the so-called "top down" fabrication scheme for a Kane solid-state quantum computer. In addition, we calculate the exchange coupling as a function of the voltage bias on control gates used to manipulate the electron wave functions and implement quantum logic operations, and find that these gate biases can be used to both increase and decrease the magnitude of the exchange coupling between neighboring donor electrons.

Introduction: The Challenge of Donor-Based Architectures

In the pursuit of scalable quantum computing, silicon-based architectures—most notably the Kane proposal—stand out due to their compatibility with existing semiconductor manufacturing and the long coherence times of donor spins. In these systems, information is stored in the nuclear or electron spins of phosphorus donors embedded in a silicon crystal.

Schematic of the donor-based qubit device architecture.

As shown in Figure 1, the architecture utilizes metallic surface electrodes: A-gates for single-qubit addressing and J-gates to control the interaction between adjacent donors. To perform two-qubit logic operations, the electrons of neighboring donors must interact via exchange coupling ($J$). However, silicon's complex conduction band structure, characterized by six degenerate "valleys," introduces significant theoretical and practical hurdles. The resulting intervalley interference causes the exchange coupling to oscillate wildly based on the precise atomic-scale placement of the donors.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-faceted theoretical approach to model these interactions. They utilized Kohn-Luttinger wavefunctions within an effective mass formalism to account for the six conduction band minima. To calculate the exchange energy, the Heitler-London formalism was applied. A key finding of this work is that the rapidly oscillating periodic part of the Bloch functions averages to zero over the range of the exchange integrals, allowing for a significant simplification of the mathematical model without sacrificing accuracy.

To simulate realistic device conditions, the team used TCAD (Technology Computer-Aided Design) software to solve the 3D Poisson equation for the electrostatic potential generated by the A and J gates. They then performed direct diagonalization of the Hamiltonian using a large basis set (140 states) to observe how electron wavefunctions deform under external gate biases.

The Impact of Intervalley Interference

The study confirms that exchange coupling is extraordinarily sensitive to donor placement. Because of the interference between the six valleys, the coupling strength does not simply decay exponentially with distance; instead, it exhibits high-frequency oscillations.

Oscillatory exchange coupling versus donor separation.

As illustrated in Figure 6, moving a donor by just a few lattice spacings can change the exchange coupling by more than an order of magnitude. This sensitivity poses a major challenge for "top-down" fabrication methods like 15 keV ion implantation, which has a positional variance (straggling) of approximately 90-100 Å. The authors calculate that the probability of achieving a target "bare" exchange coupling of 50 $\mu$eV—necessary for high-speed gate operations—is only about 6% using current implantation techniques.

Gate Control as a Solution

The most promising result of this research is the demonstrated efficacy of the J-gate as a tuning mechanism. By applying a positive voltage to the J-gate, the electron wavefunctions are pulled toward each other, increasing their overlap and the resulting exchange coupling. For donors separated by ~200 Å, a 1V bias can increase the coupling by over two orders of magnitude (up to ~30 $\mu$eV).

Furthermore, the study highlights that 3D modeling is essential. Previous 1D approximations failed to capture how the electric field varies with the depth of the donors (typically 20 nm below the oxide). The gate biases can be used to not only increase the magnitude of $J$ but also shift the interference pattern, potentially compensating for the inherent randomness in donor placement.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the sensitivity of exchange coupling to atomic placement is a significant hurdle for donor-based silicon quantum computers, electrical gate tuning offers a viable path forward. However, the low yield predicted for ion implantation suggests that either "bottom-up" fabrication (using STM for atomic precision) or highly aggressive active gate tuning will be required for large-scale arrays. Future work may explore the use of uniaxial strain to suppress intervalley oscillations, further simplifying the control requirements for these promising spin-based qubits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intervalley interference between degenerate conduction band minima has been shown to lead to oscillations in the exchange energy between neighboring phosphorus donor electron states in silicon [B. Koiller, X. Hu, and S. Das Sarma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 027903 (2002); Phys. Rev. B 66, 115201 (2002)]. These same effects lead to an extreme sensitivity of the exchange energy on the relative orientation of the donor atoms, an issue of crucial importance in the construction of silicon-based spin quantum computers. In this article we calculate the donor electron exchange coupling as a function of donor position incorporating the full Bloch structure of the Kohn-Luttinger electron wave functions. It is found that due to the rapidly oscillating nature of the terms they produce, the periodic part of the Bloch functions can be safely ignored in the Heitler-London integrals as was done by Koiller, Hu, and Das Sarma, significantly reducing the complexity of calculations. We address issues of fabrication and calculate the expected exchange coupling between neighboring donors that have been implanted into the silicon substrate using an 15 keV ion beam in the so-called ``top down'' fabrication scheme for a Kane solid-state quantum computer. In addition, we calculate the exchange coupling as a function of the voltage bias on control gates used to manipulate the electron wave functions and implement quantum logic operations in the Kane proposal, and find that these gate biases can be used to both increase and decrease the magnitude of the exchange coupling between neighboring donor electrons. The zero-bias results reconfirm those previously obtained by Koiller, Hu, and Das Sarma.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wellard2003electron,
  author = {Cameron Wellard and Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg and F. Parisoli and Louise Olsen‐Kettle and Hsi‐Sheng Goan and John A.L. McIntosh and David N. Jamieson},
  title = {{Electron exchange coupling for single-donor solid-state spin qubits}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.68.195209},
}
Figure