Electron Emission Regimes of Planar Nano Vacuum Emitters

Marco Turchetti, Yujia Yang, Mina R. Bionta, Alberto Nardi, Luca Daniel, Karl K. Berggren, Phillip D. KeathleyIEEE Transactions on Electron Devices 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully isolated three distinct electron emission regimes—Schottky, Fowler-Nordheim, and saturation—within single planar nano-vacuum diodes. By using resilient materials like Titanium Nitride (TiN) and clever fabrication techniques, they resolved long-standing discrepancies in how these devices are modeled, paving the way for ultra-fast, radiation-hard electronics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vacuum tubes were the backbone of early computing (think ENIAC), but they were bulky, power-hungry, and eventually replaced by solid-state semiconductors. However, "nano-vacuum channel" (NVC) devices are bringing the vacuum back. By shrinking the gap between electrodes to the nanoscale, electrons can travel ballistically without hitting gas molecules, even at atmospheric pressure. This promises devices that are faster than silicon and immune to extreme heat or radiation.

The catch? We didn't fully understand how they worked. For years, researchers tried to fit all NVC data to the Fowler-Nordheim (FN) tunneling model. To make the math work, they had to invent "field enhancement factors" ($\gamma$) that were 10 to 100 times higher than what physics simulations predicted. This paper tackles this "$\gamma$ discrepancy" by proving that FN tunneling isn't the only player on the field.

Methods

The team fabricated "bow-tie" diodes—two sharp tips facing each other with a tiny 10–20 nm gap—using two different materials:

  1. Gold (Au): A standard metallic emitter.
  2. Titanium Nitride (TiN): A refractory ceramic known for its robustness and high melting point.

A critical innovation in their fabrication was the undercut. By etching away the insulating silicon dioxide ($SiO_2$) layer directly beneath the metal tips, they prevented electrons from getting trapped in the substrate. This eliminated "hysteresis" (memory effects) and ensured the measured current was actually flowing through the vacuum gap, not crawling along the surface. They then tested these devices across a range of temperatures (20°C to 150°C) and pressures ($10^{-6}$ mbar to atmospheric) to see how the emission behavior changed.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "dataset" consists of thousands of current-voltage (I-V) sweeps collected under controlled environmental conditions. Specifically:

  • Temperature-dependent I-V curves: Used to distinguish between thermionic (Schottky) and tunneling (FN) emission.
  • Pressure-dependent I-V curves: Used to study the impact of surface adsorption and oxidation on emission efficiency.
  • Material comparison: Comparing the performance and breakdown limits of Au vs. TiN emitters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Three-Regime Map: The researchers identified that a single device transitions through three phases as voltage increases:
  • Schottky Regime: At low voltages, emission is "field-enhanced thermionic." Heat helps electrons hop over the barrier.
  • Fowler-Nordheim (FN) Regime: At medium voltages, the barrier becomes so thin that electrons simply tunnel through it.
  • Saturation Regime: At high voltages, the current levels off due to the Child-Langmuir limit, where the cloud of electrons in the gap (space charge) actually repels new electrons from leaving the emitter.
  • Solving the $\gamma$ Mystery: By recognizing that low-voltage data was actually in the Schottky regime, the researchers found that their experimental data finally matched their electromagnetic simulations. The "magic" enhancement factors of $100\times$ seen in previous literature were likely just the result of researchers trying to force-fit Schottky data into an FN model.
  • Material Matters: Gold devices were too fragile to reach the FN or saturation regimes before melting. The TiN devices, however, were "tough" enough to survive the high current densities needed to see all three regimes clearly.

Key Results

  • Consistent Modeling: When using the correct regime-specific models, the field enhancement factor ($\gamma$) was found to be $\sim 10\times$, perfectly aligning with 3D electromagnetic simulations.
  • Turn-on Voltages: The devices operated reliably with turn-on voltages below 10V, making them compatible with modern low-power integrated circuits.
  • Atmospheric Sensitivity: While the devices can operate at atmospheric pressure, the current dropped by $16\times$ (for TiN) to $50\times$ (for Au) when exposed to air. This wasn't because of air molecules blocking the path, but because water and oxygen adsorbed onto the tips, changing their "work function" (the energy needed to kick an electron out).

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the environmental sensitivity. Even though the gap is smaller than the "mean free path" of air molecules, surface contamination (oxidation/adsorption) significantly degrades performance. The authors emphasize that while these devices are promising, they will likely require high-quality vacuum packaging to remain stable over long periods.

Future work will likely focus on optimizing the geometry to maximize the FN regime and exploring how these multi-regime characteristics can be used to design new types of high-speed logic or sensors that operate in "extreme" environments where silicon would fail.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent advancements in nanofabrication have enabled the creation of vacuum electronic devices with nanoscale free-space gaps. These nanoelectronic devices promise the benefits of cold-field emission and transport through free space, such as high nonlinearity and relative insensitivity to temperature and ionizing radiation, all while drastically reducing the footprint, increasing the operating bandwidth, and reducing the power consumption of each device. Furthermore, planarized vacuum nanoelectronics could easily be integrated at scale similar to typical microscale and nanoscale semiconductor electronics. However, the interplay between different electron emission mechanisms from these devices is not well understood, and inconsistencies with pure Fowler–Nordheim (FN) emission have been noted by others. In this work, we systematically study the current–voltage characteristics of planar vacuum nanodevices having few-nanometer radii of curvature and free-space gaps between the emitter and the collector. By investigating the current–voltage characteristics of nearly identical devices fabricated from two different materials and under various environmental conditions, such as temperature and atmospheric pressure, we are able to clearly isolate three distinct emission regimes within a single device: Schottky, FN, and saturation. Our work will enable robust and accurate modeling of vacuum nanoelectronics, which will be critical for future applications requiring high-speed and low-power electronics capable of operation in extreme conditions.
BibTeX
@article{turchetti2022electron,
  author = {Marco Turchetti and Yujia Yang and Mina R. Bionta and Alberto Nardi and Luca Daniel and Karl K. Berggren and Phillip D. Keathley},
  title = {{Electron Emission Regimes of Planar Nano Vacuum Emitters}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/ted.2022.3175706},
}
Figure