Electron antineutrino search at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory

B. Aharmim, S. N. Ahmed, E. W. Beier, A. Bellerive, S. D. Biller, J. Boger, M. G. Boulay, T. J. Bowles, S. J. Brice, T. V. Bullard, Y-d. Chan, M. Chen, X. Chen, B. T. Cleveland, G. A. Cox, X. Dai, F. Dalnoki‐Veress, P. J. Doe, R.s. Dosanjh, G. Doucas, M. R. Dragowsky, C. A. Duba, F. A. Duncan, M. Dunford, J. Dunmore, E. D. Earle, S. R. Elliott, H. C. Evans, G. T. Ewan, J. Farine, H. Fergani, F. Fleurot, J. A. Formaggio, M. M. Fowler, K. C. Frame, W. Frati, B. G. Fulsom, N. Gagnon, K. Graham, D. R. Grant, R. L. Hahn, A. L. Hallin, E. D. Hallman, A. S. Hamer, W. B. Handler, C. K. Hargrove, P. J. Harvey, R. Hazama, K. M. Heeger, W. J. Heintzelman, J. Heise, R. L. Helmer, R.j. Hemingway, A. Hime, M. A. Howe, P. Jagam, N.a. Jelley, J. R. Klein, L. L. Kormos, M. Kos, A. Krüger, C. B. Krauss, A. V. Krumins, T. Kutter, Christopher C. M. Kyba, H. Labranche, R. Lange, J. Law, I. Lawson, K. T. Lesko, J. R. Leslie, I. Levine, S. Luoma, R. MacLellan, Steve Majerus, H.‐b. Mak, J. Maneira, A. D. Marino, N. McCauley, A. B. McDonald, S. McGee, G. McGregor, C. Mifflin, K. K. S. Miknaitis, Guthrie Miller, B. A. Moffat, C. W. Nally, M. S. Neubauer, B. G. Nickel, A. J. Noble, E. B. Norman, N. S. Oblath, C. Okada, R. W. Ollerhead, J. L. Orrell, S. M. Oser, C. Ouellet, S. J. M. Peeters, A. W. P. Poon, K. RielagePhysical 2004 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) has established new upper limits on the electron antineutrino ($\bar{\nu}_e$) flux using the charged-current reaction on deuterium. This reaction, which produces a positron and two neutrons in coincidence, provides a distinctive, low-background signature. Searching across an energy range of 4 to 14.8 MeV, the study found no significant evidence of solar $\bar{\nu}_e$ production. The resulting integral limit of $\Phi_{\bar{\nu}_e} \le 3.4 \times 10^4 \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$ (90% C.L.) corresponds to 0.81% of the standard solar model $^8B$ neutrino flux, placing tight constraints on exotic physics such as neutrino decay or spin-flavor precession.

Introduction

While the standard solar model predicts a massive flux of electron neutrinos ($\nu_e$), it predicts zero antineutrinos. The discovery of neutrino oscillations solved the "Solar Neutrino Problem," but researchers continue to probe for sub-dominant "exotic" processes. Specifically, if neutrinos possess a magnetic moment, interactions with the Sun's intense magnetic fields could trigger Spin Flavor Precession (SFP), converting left-handed neutrinos into right-handed antineutrinos. Detecting even a small flux of solar $\bar{\nu}_e$ would provide definitive evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model.

Experimental Method

The SNO detector, located 2 km underground in Sudbury, Ontario, utilized 1,000 tonnes of heavy water ($D_2O$) to detect neutrino interactions. To isolate potential antineutrinos, the team searched for the specific "golden signal" of the charged-current reaction: $$\bar{\nu}_e + d \to e^+ + n + n$$ This process yields a triple coincidence: an immediate Cherenkov flash from the positron ($e^+$) followed by the capture of two neutrons ($n$) on deuterium, which releases 6.25 MeV gamma rays. This unique signature allows for a search with exceptionally low background noise. The analysis covered 305.9 live days of SNO’s Phase I (pure $D_2O$ phase).

Results and Flux Limits

The search identified only two candidate coincidence events—one three-fold and one two-fold—which is entirely consistent with the expected background of $1.68^{+0.93}_{-0.45}$ events. Consequently, no evidence for an antineutrino signal was found.

Upper limits on the electron antineutrino flux as a function of energy. The arrows indicate 90% C.L. upper limits for different energy bins.

The study established an integral limit on the solar $\bar{\nu}_e$ flux of $\Phi_{\bar{\nu}_e} \le 3.4 \times 10^4 \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$ (90% C.L.) for the 4–14.8 MeV range. This result limits the conversion probability of solar neutrinos to antineutrinos to less than 0.81%. Additionally, a search for antineutrinos from natural terrestrial fission (geo-neutrinos) in the 4–8 MeV range yielded a flux limit of $\le 2.0 \times 10^6 \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$.

Discussion and Comparison

These results are consistent with and complementary to limits set by other major neutrino experiments. While experiments like KamLAND offer higher sensitivity in specific energy windows due to larger target masses or different detection materials, SNO’s use of deuterium provides a unique cross-check over a broad energy spectrum.

Comparison of solar antineutrino flux limits across different experiments, showing SNO's competitive limit in the 4.0-14.8 MeV range.

Conclusion

The SNO Phase I results significantly constrain the parameter space for exotic neutrino conversion mechanisms. The primary limitation of this phase was the neutron detection efficiency in pure heavy water (~14.4%). Subsequent phases of the SNO experiment, involving the addition of salt ($NaCl$) to the heavy water, were designed to increase neutron capture efficiency to approximately 40%, promising even greater sensitivity in future searches for these elusive particles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Upper limits on the ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ flux at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory have been set based on the ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ charged-current reaction on deuterium. The reaction produces a positron and two neutrons in coincidence. This distinctive signature allows a search with very low background for ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$'s from the Sun and other potential sources. Both differential and integral limits on the ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ flux have been placed in the energy range from 4--14.8 MeV. For an energy-independent ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{e}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ conversion mechanism, the integral limit on the flux of solar ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$'s in the energy range from 4--14.8 MeV is found to be ${\ensuremath{\Phi}}_{{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}}\ensuremath{\le}3.4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{4}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{c}\mathrm{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}2}\text{ }{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ (90% C.L.), which corresponds to 0.81% of the standard solar model $^{8}\mathrm{B}$ ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{e}$ flux of $5.05\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{c}\mathrm{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}2}\text{ }{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, and is consistent with the more sensitive limit from KamLAND in the 8.3--14.8 MeV range of $3.7\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{2}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{c}\mathrm{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}2}\text{ }{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ (90% C.L.). In the energy range from 4--8 MeV, a search for ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$'s is conducted using coincidences in which only the two neutrons are detected. Assuming a ${\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}$ spectrum for the neutron induced fission of naturally occurring elements, a flux limit of ${\ensuremath{\Phi}}_{{\overline{\ensuremath{\nu}}}_{e}}\ensuremath{\le}2.0\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{c}\mathrm{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}2}\text{ }{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ (90% C.L.) is obtained.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aharmim2004electron,
  author = {B. Aharmim and S. N. Ahmed and E. W. Beier and A. Bellerive and S. D. Biller and J. Boger and M. G. Boulay and T. J. Bowles and S. J. Brice and T. V. Bullard and Y-D. Chan and M. Chen and X. Chen and B. T. Cleveland and G. A. Cox and X. Dai and F. Dalnoki‐Veress and P. J. Doe and R.S. Dosanjh and G. Doucas and M. R. Dragowsky and C. A. Duba and F. A. Duncan and M. Dunford and J. Dunmore and E. D. Earle and S. R. Elliott and H. C. Evans and G. T. Ewan and J. Farine and H. Fergani and F. Fleurot and J. A. Formaggio and M. M. Fowler and K. C. Frame and W. Frati and B. G. Fulsom and N. Gagnon and K. Graham and D. R. Grant and R. L. Hahn and A. L. Hallin and E. D. Hallman and A. S. Hamer and W. B. Handler and C. K. Hargrove and P. J. Harvey and R. Hazama and K. M. Heeger and W. J. Heintzelman and J. Heise and R. L. Helmer and R.J. Hemingway and A. Hime and M. A. Howe and P. Jagam and N.A. Jelley and J. R. Klein and L. L. Kormos and M. Kos and A. Krüger and C. B. Krauss and A. V. Krumins and T. Kutter and Christopher C. M. Kyba and H. Labranche and R. Lange and J. Law and I. Lawson and K. T. Lesko and J. R. Leslie and I. Levine and S. Luoma and R. MacLellan and Steve Majerus and H.‐B. Mak and J. Maneira and A. D. Marino and N. McCauley and A. B. McDonald and S. McGee and G. McGregor and C. Mifflin and K. K. S. Miknaitis and Guthrie Miller and B. A. Moffat and C. W. Nally and M. S. Neubauer and B. G. Nickel and A. J. Noble and E. B. Norman and N. S. Oblath and C. Okada and R. W. Ollerhead and J. L. Orrell and S. M. Oser and C. Ouellet and S. J. M. Peeters and A. W. P. Poon and K. Rielage},
  title = {{Electron antineutrino search at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.70.093014},
}
Figure