Electro‐fermentation triggering population selection in mixed‐culture glycerol fermentation

Roman Moscoviz, Éric Trably, Nicolas BernetMicrobial 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that electro-fermentation (EF) can effectively steer the metabolic output and microbial community composition in mixed-culture glycerol fermentation. By applying a mild electrical potential, researchers achieved a 10% increase in 1,3-propanediol (PDO) production, primarily driven by the selection of specific bacterial populations rather than individual metabolic shifts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Glycerol, a byproduct of biodiesel production, is an abundant and energy-rich substrate. However, its efficient conversion into valuable chemicals like 1,3-propanediol (PDO) in mixed microbial cultures can be challenging. Traditional fermentation methods often result in a mix of products, limiting PDO yield. Electro-fermentation (EF), a technique combining microbial fermentation with bioelectrochemical systems, offers a novel approach to influence metabolic pathways by providing an external electron source or sink. The problem this paper addresses is how to effectively utilize EF to enhance PDO production from glycerol in a mixed microbial community and to understand the underlying mechanisms driving these improvements. Specifically, it investigates whether EF primarily alters individual bacterial metabolism or selects for specific microbial populations that are better suited for PDO production.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-culture glycerol fermentation system in H-type bioreactors. They compared standard fermentation (F) with electro-fermentation (EF) using a cathodic potential of -900 mV versus SCE, chosen to avoid abiotic hydrogen production. A key experimental variation involved pre-colonizing the working electrodes with Geobacter sulfurreducens (EFG1 and EFG2) to investigate the role of an electro-active bacterium as a mediator.

To analyze the microbial community structure, they used MiSeq sequencing to profile the operational taxonomic units (OTUs) in both the bulk liquid and the biofilm on the working electrodes. To understand the metabolic contributions of individual OTUs, they developed a linear inverse model. This model estimated the metabolic pattern of each OTU based on its abundance and known metabolic pathways, allowing for the prediction of global production yields. The model's accuracy was validated through k-fold cross-validation.

Datasets

The study utilized a mixed microbial inoculum from a long-term continuous dark fermentation reactor. The microbial community composition was analyzed using MiSeq sequencing. The model's predictions were compared against experimental yields of glycerol, PDO, and other organic acids (lactate, acetate, ethanol, formate, succinate, propionate) measured by HPLC.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Electro-fermentation as a population selector: The most striking insight is that EF, particularly when mediated by Geobacter sulfurreducens, appears to exert its influence primarily by selecting for specific bacterial populations that are more efficient at PDO production, rather than fundamentally altering the metabolic capabilities of all existing microbes.
  • The power of electro-active mediators: Pre-colonizing electrodes with Geobacter sulfurreducens significantly impacted the microbial community and led to improved PDO yields, highlighting the potential of using electro-active bacteria to bridge the gap between the electrode and the fermentative community.
  • Low energy input, high impact: The observed improvements in PDO production were achieved with a very low electron input from the cathode (<1% of total electron equivalents), suggesting that EF can be an energy-efficient method for metabolic control.
  • Model-driven metabolic deconvolution: The development and application of a linear inverse model to estimate individual OTU metabolic patterns was crucial for distinguishing between population selection and individual metabolic shifts.

Key Results

  • Electro-fermentation (EF) without G. sulfurreducens showed minor shifts in metabolic patterns, with lactate production decreasing and ethanol production increasing compared to standard fermentation (F). PDO yields remained similar.
  • Pre-colonizing electrodes with G. sulfurreducens (EFG1 and EFG2) led to a significant shift in the microbial community composition and a ~10% improvement in PDO yield compared to F and EF.
  • The linear model successfully predicted global production yields and indicated that changes in overall metabolism were predominantly driven by the selection of specific OTUs, rather than a uniform shift in all microbial metabolic activities.
  • Specific OTUs, including Citrobacter freundii (OTU2) and Enterococcus avium (OTU1), were found to be enriched in the EF conditions and were associated with higher PDO production.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the precise nature of the interactions between the cathode, the cathodic biofilm, and the bulk microbial community is not fully elucidated. While the study suggests population selection is the dominant mechanism, it doesn't entirely rule out subtle individual metabolic shifts.

Future work could focus on:

  • Investigating simplified microbial communities to pinpoint specific interspecies interactions that contribute to improved PDO production.
  • Exploring other electro-active bacteria or mediators to further enhance electron transfer efficiency and control.
  • Understanding the specific metabolic roles of newly enriched OTUs, such as Enterococcus avium, in PDO production.
  • Further optimizing EF conditions to maximize PDO yields and minimize unwanted by-products.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electro-fermentation is a new technique that could be used to influence the global metabolism in mixed-culture fermentation. In this study, a mixed-culture cathodic electro-fermentation of glycerol was investigated. Both microbial community structure and metabolic patterns were altered when compared to standard fermentation. This microbial population shift was more significant when the working electrodes were pre-colonized by Geobacter sulfurreducens, before electro-fermentation. The electro-fermenting microbial community was more efficient for producing 1,3-propanediol with an improved yield of 10% when compared with fermentation controls. Such improvement did not require high energy and total electron input represented < 1% of the total electron equivalents provided only by glycerol. A linear model was developed to estimate the individual metabolic pattern of each operational taxonomic unit. Application of this model compared to the experimental results suggests that the changes in global metabolism were supported by bacterial population selection rather than individual metabolism shift. This study shows for the first time that both fermentation pattern and bacterial community composition can be influenced by electro-fermentation conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moscoviz2017electrofermentation,
  author = {Roman Moscoviz and Éric Trably and Nicolas Bernet},
  title = {{Electro‐fermentation triggering population selection in mixed‐culture glycerol fermentation}},
  booktitle = {Microbial},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1111/1751-7915.12747},
}
Figure