Electrochemical measurement of acetylcholine in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex: A technical report

Devavrat Vartak, Chris van der Togt, Bram van Vugt, Pieter R. RoelfsemabioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports on the challenges of adapting an electrochemical technique for measuring acetylcholine in the brains of awake, behaving macaque monkeys. While the method shows promise for high temporal resolution, the researchers encountered significant technical hurdles, leading to inconsistent and noisy results, highlighting the need for further refinement before it can be reliably used in non-human primate research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Acetylcholine is a crucial neurotransmitter involved in various cognitive functions like attention, learning, and memory. However, understanding its precise role in real-time during complex cognitive tasks has been hampered by limitations in measurement techniques. Specifically, existing methods like microdialysis lack the sub-second temporal resolution needed to capture rapid changes in acetylcholine release that occur during cognitive events. Electrochemical amperometry, using enzyme-coupled sensors, offers a potential solution with its high sensitivity, selectivity, and fast response time. This paper attempts to adapt a previously successful rodent-based amperometric method for measuring acetylcholine in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) of macaque monkeys performing an attention-demanding task. The goal is to bridge the gap between understanding acetylcholine's role in simpler systems and its complex functions in primates.

Methods

The core of this study involves adapting an enzyme-coupled amperometric sensor for in vivo measurements in macaque monkeys. The sensor utilizes platinum electrodes coated with an exclusion layer (mPD) to prevent interference from larger molecules and an enzyme layer (choline oxidase) that converts acetylcholine into hydrogen peroxide. Hydrogen peroxide is then electrochemically detected, generating a current proportional to the acetylcholine concentration.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Electrode Design: Ceramic-based microelectrodes with four recording sites, two coated with the enzyme complex and two as sentinel channels to monitor background noise and electrode integrity.
  • Exclusion Layer (mPD): Electropolymerized mPD was used to enhance selectivity by preventing the passage of larger molecules like ascorbic acid and dopamine to the recording surface.
  • Enzyme Immobilization: Choline oxidase was immobilized onto the electrode surface using bovine serum albumin and glutaraldehyde to stabilize the enzyme.
  • Behavioral Paradigm: A curve-tracing task was employed, requiring monkeys to maintain fixation and then make a saccade to a target, designed to elicit shifts in attention.
  • Surgical Procedures: Implantation of a head post and a recording chamber over the dlPFC in adult macaque monkeys.
  • Calibration: Rigorous in vitro calibration procedures were performed before and after in vivo recordings to assess electrode sensitivity and selectivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on in vivo measurements in a single macaque monkey performing a behavioral task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Primate Brain Presents Unique Challenges: Adapting electrochemical techniques from rodents to primates is not a straightforward translation. The physical environment of the primate brain (e.g., dura mater) and potentially different physiological responses pose significant hurdles.
  • Mechanical Damage is a Major Obstacle: The penetration of the electrode through the dura mater and connective tissue caused significant mechanical damage to the enzyme coating and exclusion layer, leading to a loss of sensitivity and selectivity over time. This was a primary reason for the inconsistent results.
  • Signal Degradation Over Time: The electrodes showed a marked decrease in both sensitivity and selectivity after implantation and recording, suggesting that the enzyme activity degraded and the exclusion layer deteriorated.
  • Fast Fluctuations May Not Be Acetylcholine: Observed fast current fluctuations (tens of milliseconds) on both enzyme-coated and sentinel channels were hypothesized to be artifacts related to EEG or evoked potentials, rather than rapid acetylcholine release, due to their presence on both channel types and their speed.
  • Need for Robust Electrode Design: The study strongly suggests that improvements in electrode design, particularly in protecting the enzyme and exclusion layers from mechanical damage during insertion, are critical for future success.

Key Results

  • Low Success Rate: Out of twelve attempts to record acetylcholine, only four yielded results that appeared to be related to the task.
  • Significant Sensitivity Loss: Electrode sensitivity to choline decreased significantly from an average of 16.4 ± 4.7 pA/µM pre-recording to 9.2 ± 6.1 pA/µM post-recording.
  • Increased Limit of Detection (LOD): The LOD for choline increased significantly from a mean of 0.80 ± 0.6 µM pre-calibration to 4.8 ± 4.9 µM post-calibration, indicating a reduced ability to detect low concentrations.
  • Loss of Selectivity: Post-recording calibrations showed that electrodes began responding to ascorbic acid (AA), indicating a breakdown of the mPD exclusion layer and a loss of specificity.
  • No Clear Task-Related Correlation: Despite successful recordings, a clear correlation between observed signal changes and the monkey's engagement in the curve-tracing task could not be established.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Technical Difficulties: The primary limitation was the technical difficulty in maintaining electrode integrity and function in vivo, leading to signal degradation and loss of selectivity.
  • Single Subject: The study was conducted on a single macaque monkey, limiting the generalizability of the findings.
  • Inconclusive Results: The inconsistent and noisy data prevented definitive conclusions about the role of acetylcholine in the task.

Future Work:

The authors propose several avenues for future research:

  • Improved Recording Chamber Design: Enhancements to the recording chamber to minimize mechanical damage to the electrode during insertion.
  • Protective Electrode Coatings: Exploring methods to better protect the enzyme and exclusion layers, such as depositing them within cavities on the electrode or using sharper, more robust electrode tips.
  • Artificial Dura: Investigating the use of artificial dura to facilitate safer and multiple electrode insertions.
  • Advanced Materials: Exploring newer polymer materials (e.g., PANI, PEDOT) and nanotechnology-based sensors (e.g., carbon nanotubes) for improved biocompatibility, stability, and sensitivity.
  • Further Refinement of Behavioral Paradigms: Potentially adapting or refining behavioral tasks to better elicit measurable acetylcholine responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Ever since the discovery of acetylcholine in 1913, its role as neuromodulator has been extensively studied in a variety of model systems. These previous studies revealed that acetylcholine is of critical importance for several cognitive functions including attention, learning and memory. In spite of these previous findings, it has proven difficult to determine the amount of acetylcholine that is released during cognitive tasks with sub-second temporal resolution. One method that might be used to measure acetylcholine release is the use of an enzyme-coupled amperometric sensor, which has been suggested to measure acetylcholine with high sensitivity, selectivity and relatively high temporal resolution (< 1 second). In the present study, we have tried to adapt the technique developed in the rodent model system by Parikh and colleagues 1,2 for use in non-human primates. We aimed to measure in-vivo levels of acetylcholine in the macaque dorsolateral prefrontal cortex while the monkey performed an attention demanding curve-tracing task 3,4 . We report that our attempts to measure acetylcholine using amperometry in an awake behaving macaque monkey proved difficult and tedious and that our results are inconsistent and prone to noise. In the discussion, we will outline the challenges that will need to be addressed to use this technique in non-human primates and hope that our observations inspire solutions to help future research on the role of this important neurotransmitter.
BibTeX
@misc{vartak2017electrochemical,
  author = {Devavrat Vartak and Chris van der Togt and Bram van Vugt and Pieter R. Roelfsema},
  title = {{Electrochemical measurement of acetylcholine in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex: A technical report}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/120691},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure